# Once a foreigner is released on bail he cannot leave India without the permission of the Civil Authority and the Court should direct the investigating agency or the State to inform the concerned Registration Officer

- Link: https://section1.in/once-a-foreigner-is-released-on-bail-he-cannot-leave-india-without-the-permission-of-the-civil-authority-and-the-court-should-direct-the-investigating-agency-or-the-state-to-inform-the-concerned-regis/
- Published: 2025-01-07T14:28:59+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Appeal](https://section1.in/once-a-foreigner-is-released-on-bail-he-cannot-leave-india-without-the-permission-of-the-civil-authority-and-the-court-should-direct-the-investigating-agency-or-the-state-to-inform-the-concerned-regis/#appeal)
    - [Question of law](https://section1.in/once-a-foreigner-is-released-on-bail-he-cannot-leave-india-without-the-permission-of-the-civil-authority-and-the-court-should-direct-the-investigating-agency-or-the-state-to-inform-the-concerned-regis/#question-of-law)
    - [Central Government has power to regulate entry or departure of foreigners](https://section1.in/once-a-foreigner-is-released-on-bail-he-cannot-leave-india-without-the-permission-of-the-civil-authority-and-the-court-should-direct-the-investigating-agency-or-the-state-to-inform-the-concerned-regis/#central-government-has-power-to-regulate-entry-or-departure-of-foreigners)
    - [“5. Power to grant permission to depart from India.](https://section1.in/once-a-foreigner-is-released-on-bail-he-cannot-leave-india-without-the-permission-of-the-civil-authority-and-the-court-should-direct-the-investigating-agency-or-the-state-to-inform-the-concerned-regis/#5-power-to-grant-permission-to-depart-from-india)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/once-a-foreigner-is-released-on-bail-he-cannot-leave-india-without-the-permission-of-the-civil-authority-and-the-court-should-direct-the-investigating-agency-or-the-state-to-inform-the-concerned-regis/#party)

#### **Appeal**

##### **Question of law**

1. By judgment and order dated 08th July, 2024, two main issues concerning bail 
conditions were decided. Now, the issue that remains to be answered is whether it
is necessary to implead a Foreign Registration Officer appointed under Rule 3 of
the Registration of Foreigners Rules, 1992 (for short ‘the Rules’) in the bail application
filed by a foreigner within the meaning of the Foreigners Act, 1946 (for short ‘
the Act’). Under Section 2(a) of the Act, a foreigner means a person who is not 
a citizen of India.

##### **Central Government has power to regulate entry or departure of foreigners**

2. Under Section 3 of the Act, there is a power vested in the Central Government
to issue an order making provisions either generally or concerning any particular
foreigner or class of foreigners of prohibiting, regulating or restricting the entry
of foreigners into India or their departure therefrom or their presence or continued
presence. Under clause (g) of Section 3(2), a power has been conferred on the Central
Government to issue an order directing that a foreigner shall be arrested or detained
or confined.

3. In the exercise of the power conferred under Section 3 of the Act, the Foreigners
Order, 1948 (for short, ‘the Order’) has been issued. Clause 2(2) of the Order provides
for appointing a Civil Authority by the Central Government. Clause 5 of the Order
deals with the power to grant permission to depart from India. Clause 5 of the Order
reads thus:

##### “5. **Power to grant permission to depart from India.**

(1) No foreigner shall leave India:-

(a) otherwise than at such port or other recognised place of departure on the borders
of India as a Registration Officer having jurisdiction at that port or place may
appoint in this behalf, either for foreigners generally or for any specified class
or description of foreigners; or

**(b) without the leave of the civil authority having jurisdiction at such port 
or place**.

(2) Leave shall be refused if the civil authority is satisfied that

(a) the foreigner has failed to comply with the formalities of departure prescribed
under the Registration of Foreigners Rules, 1939;

**(b) the foreigners presence is required in India to answer a criminal charge;**

(c) the foreigners departure will prejudice the relations of the Central Government
with a foreign power;

(d) the departure of the foreigner has been prohibited under an order issued by 
a competent authority.

(3) (a) Notwithstanding anything contained in the above sub-paragraphs, a civil 
authority may prohibit the departure of a foreigner where it is satisfied that such
departure would not be conducive to the public interest.

(b) Whenever a civil authority issues an order under clause (a), it shall report
the matter forthwith to the Central Government which may cancel or modify the order
in such manner as it thinks fit.” (emphasis added)

Under sub-clause (2) of clause 5, leave must be refused by the Civil Authority if
it is satisfied that the foreigner’s presence is required in India to answer a criminal
charge.

> 5. Under clause (b) of Section 3(2) of the Act, there is a power vested in the
> Central Government to issue an order generally or with respect to any particular
> foreigner or class of foreigners that they shall not depart from India or shall
> depart subject to observance of such conditions on departure as may be prescribed.
> The Rules do not impose any such restriction on departure from India. However,
> as noted earlier, according to clause 5(1)(b) of the Order, no foreigner shall
> leave India without the leave of the Civil Authority having jurisdiction. When
> a foreigner’s presence is required in India to answer a criminal charge, permission
> to leave India must be refused. Under the Order, the Civil Authority can impose
> restrictions on the movements of a foreigner. Therefore, once a foreigner is released
> on bail, he cannot leave India without the permission of the Civil Authority, 
> as provided in clause 5 of the Order. Under clause 11 and other clauses of the
> Order, various restrictions can be imposed on a foreigner while he is in India.
> The said power is wholly independent of the power to grant bail. As of today, 
> there is no order passed by the Central Government for giving effect to clause(
> g) of Section 3(2) of the Act. In any event, even if such an order is issued, 
> the power to arrest or detain a foreigner under the Act is independent of the 
> power of the criminal court to grant bail. Notwithstanding the bail granted by
> a criminal court, the power to arrest and detain a foreigner can be exercised,
> provided the Central Government makes an order in terms of clause (g) of Section
> 3(2) of the Act.

6. Therefore, we do not see any propriety in issuing a direction that either the
Civil Authority or the Registration Officer should be made a party to a bail application
filed by a foreigner or a notice of the bail application be issued to the said authorities.
The reason is that the authorities under the Act and the Order have no locus to 
oppose bail application filed by a foreigner unless bail is sought where the allegation
is of the offence punishable under Section 14 of the Act. The impleadment of the
Civil Authority or Registration Officer in all bail applications filed by foreigners
may result in unnecessary delay in deciding the bail applications.

7. All that can be done is that while releasing a foreigner on bail, the Court should
direct the investigating agency or the State, as the case may be, to immediately
inform the concerned Registration Officer appointed under Rule 3 of the Rules about
the grant of bail so that the Registration Officer can bring the fact of the grant
of bail to the notice of concerned Civil Authority.

8. In addition to what we held by judgment and order dated 08th July, 2024, we issue
the following directions:

> (i) While granting bail to a foreigner within the meaning of the Act, the concerned
> court shall issue direction to the State or prosecuting agency, as the case may
> be, to immediately communicate the order granting bail to the concerned Registration
> Officer appointed under Rule 3 of the Rules who, in turn, shall communicate the
> order to all concerned authorities including the Civil Authorities. If such information
> is furnished, it will enable the authorities under the Act, the Rules and the 
> Order to take appropriate steps in accordance with the law; and
> (ii) A copy of this order shall be forwarded to Registrar Generals of all the 
> High Courts, who in turn will forward the copies of the order to all the criminal
> courts in the respective States.

9. The Criminal Appeals shall be treated as disposed of in terms of the judgment
and order dated 08th July, 2024 and this order.

#### **Party**

Frank Vitus …Appellant versus Narcotics Control Bureau and Ors. …Respondents – Criminal
Appeal Nos. 2814-2815 of 2024 – 2025 INSC 30 – JANUARY 06, 2025

[Frank Vitus vs. NCB – 66872023_2025-01-06](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/Frank-Vitus-vs.-NCB-66872023_2025-01-06.pdf)
[Download](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/Frank-Vitus-vs.-NCB-66872023_2025-01-06.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
