# P.C Act – All about sanction and its limitations

- Link: https://section1.in/p-c-act-all-about-sanction-and-its-limitation/
- Published: 2023-02-28T12:25:46+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Issue No. 1 – Whether the order of sanction is illegal due to non-application of mind and acting as per dictation if the appointing authority, the DoPT refers and considers the opinion and advise of the CVC?](https://section1.in/p-c-act-all-about-sanction-and-its-limitation/#issue-no-1-8211-whether-the-order-of-sanction-is-illegal-due-to-nonapplication-of-mind-and-acting-as-per-dictation-if-the-appointing-authority-the-dopt-refers-and-considers-the-opinion-and-advise-of-t)
 * [Issue No: 1 – Answer (as per the case)](https://section1.in/p-c-act-all-about-sanction-and-its-limitation/#issue-no-1-answer-as-per-the-case)
 * [Issue No. 2: Whether the criminal proceedings could be quashed for the delay in the issuance of the sanction order?](https://section1.in/p-c-act-all-about-sanction-and-its-limitation/#issue-no-2-whether-the-criminal-proceedings-could-be-quashed-for-the-delay-in-the-issuance-of-the-sanction-order)
 * [Abnormal delay in granting sanction – Whether quash necessary?](https://section1.in/p-c-act-all-about-sanction-and-its-limitation/#abnormal-delay-in-granting-sanction-8211-whether-quash-necessary)
 * [Limitation for grant of sanction](https://section1.in/p-c-act-all-about-sanction-and-its-limitation/#limitation-for-grant-of-sanction)
 * [Limitation for grant of sanction – Four months in total](https://section1.in/p-c-act-all-about-sanction-and-its-limitation/#limitation-for-grant-of-sanction-8211-four-months-in-total)
 * [Issue No. 2 – Answer](https://section1.in/p-c-act-all-about-sanction-and-its-limitation/#issue-no-2-8211-answer)
 * [ https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2022/3264/3264_2022_15_1501_38812_Judgement_11-Oct-2022.pdfFiles : VijY Rajmohan vs. State 3264_2022_15_1501_38812_Judgement_11-Oct-2022](https://section1.in/p-c-act-all-about-sanction-and-its-limitation/#%c2%a0httpsmainscigovinsupremecourt202232643264202215150138812judgement11oct2022pdffiles-vijy-rajmohan-vs-state-3264202215150138812judgement11oct2022)

**Vijay Rajmohan Vs. State Represented By The Inspector Of Police, CBI, ACB, Chennai,
Tamil Nadu  – Criminal Appeal No. _______Of 2022 Arising Out Of SLP (Crl) No. 1568
Of 2022 – October 11, 2022.**

Two important questions of law arise for consideration in this appeal. The first
question is whether an order of the Appointing Authority granting sanction for prosecution
of a public servant under Section 19 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, 
would be rendered illegal on the ground of acting as per dictation if it consults
the Central Vigilance Commission for its decision. The second question is whether
the period of three months (extendable hereinafter referred to as ‘the PC Act’ by
one more month for legal consultation) for the Appointing Authority to decide upon
a request for sanction is mandatory or not. The further question in this context,
is whether the criminal proceedings can be quashed if the decision is not taken 
within the mandatory period.

##### **Issue No. 1 – Whether the order of sanction is illegal due to non-application of mind and acting as per dictation if the appointing authority, the DoPT refers and considers the opinion and advise of the CVC?**

 15. At the outset, we will take note of the ratio in Mansukhlal (**Mansukhlal Vithaldas
     Chauhan v. State of Gujarat – (1997) 7 SCC 622**) relied on by Shri Jethmalani.
     Relevant portion of the judgment holding that “if the sanctioning authority is
     under an obligation or compulsion to grant sanction, the order will be bad for
     the reason that the discretion is taken away”, is extracted hereinunder:

“18. The validity of the sanction would, therefore, depend upon the material placed
before the sanctioning authority and the fact that all the relevant facts, material
and evidence have been considered by the sanctioning authority. Consideration implies
application of mind. The order of sanction must ex facie disclose that the sanctioning
authority had considered the evidence and other material placed before it. This 
fact can also be established by extrinsic evidence by placing the relevant files
before the Court to show that all relevant facts were considered by the sanctioning
authority.

**19. Since the validity of “sanction” depends on the applicability of mind by the
sanctioning authority to the facts of the case as also the material and evidence
collected during investigation, it necessarily follows that the sanctioning authority
has to apply its own independent mind for the generation of genuine satisfaction
whether prosecution has to be sanctioned or not. The mind of the sanctioning authority
should not be under pressure from any quarter nor should any external force be acting
upon it to take a decision one way or the other. Since the discretion to grant or
not to grant sanction vests absolutely in the sanctioning authority, its discretion
should be shown to have not been affected by any extraneous consideration.If it 
is shown that the sanctioning authority was unable to apply its independent mind
for any reason whatsoever or was under an obligation or compulsion or constraint
to grant the sanction, the order will be bad for the reason that the discretion 
of the authority “not to sanction” was taken away and it was compelled to act mechanically
to sanction the prosecution.”**

**16. The decision in Mansukhlal (supra) was rendered in the year 1997, when the
legislative changes to the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, were not made. Further,
the decision was prior to the enactment of the CVC Act and also the amendments to
the PC Act. The submission of Shri Jethmalani therefore overlooks the march of law,
which we have endeavoured to explain hereinunder.**

xxx

 18. It is evident from the above referred formulation that the position of law and
     the legal regime obtained by virtue of the five legislations on the subject of
     corruption, operates as integrated scheme. The five legislations being the Cr.
     P.C, DSPE Act, PC Act, CVC Act, and Lokpal Act, must be read together to enable
     the authorities to sub-serve the common purpose and objectives underlying these
     legislations. The Central Vigilance Commission, constituted under the CVC Act 
     is specifically entrusted with the duty and function of providing expert advice
     on the subject. It may be necessary for the appointing authority to call for and
     seek the opinion of the CVC before it takes any decision on the request for sanction
     for prosecution. The statutory scheme under which the appointing authority could
     call for, seek and consider the advice of the CVC can neither be termed as acting
     under dictation nor a factor which could be referred to as an irrelevant consideration.
     The opinion of the CVC is only advisory. It is nevertheless a valuable input in
     the decision-making process of the appointing authority. The final decision of
     the appointing authority must be of its own by application of independent mind.
     The issue is, therefore, answered by holding that there is no illegality in the
     action of the appointing authority, the DoPT, if it calls for, refers, and considers
     the opinion of the Central Vigilance Commission before it takes its final decision
     on the request for sanction for prosecuting a public servant.

##### **Issue No: 1 – Answer (as per the case)**

19. Returning to the case facts, we have examined the correspondence and the long-
drawn communications between the CBI, the DoPT, and the CVC. We found that the inquiry
made by the appointing authority, the DoPT, was only for soliciting further information,
and particularly the opinion given by CVC is also advisory. The sanction order of
the DoPT dated 24.07.2017 is an independent decision of the department that was 
taken based on the material before it. Under these circumstances, we are not inclined
to accept the first submission made on behalf of the Appellant that the order of
sanction suffers from illegality due to non-application of mind or acting under 
dictation.

##### **Issue No. 2: Whether the criminal proceedings could be quashed for the delay in the issuance of the sanction order?**

xxx

 21. Statutory provisions requiring sanction before prosecution either under Section
     197 Cr.P.C. or under Section 97 of the PC Act also intend to serve the very same
     purpose of protecting a public servant. These protections are not available to
     other citizens because of the inherent vulnerabilities of a public servant and
     the need to protect them. However, the said protection is neither a shield against
     dereliction of duty nor an absolute immunity against corrupt practices. The limited
     immunity or bar is only subject to a sanction by the appointing authority.

##### **Abnormal delay in granting sanction – Whether quash necessary? **

22. Grant of sanction being an exercise of executive power, it is subject to the
standard principles of judicial review such as application of independent mind; 
only by the competent authority, without bias, after consideration of relevant material
and by eschewing irrelevant considerations. As the power to grant sanction for prosecution
has legal consequences, it must naturally be exercised within a reasonable period.
This principle is anyway inbuilt in our legal structure, and our Constitutional 
Courts review the legality and proprietary of delayed exercise of power quite frequently.
In Mahendra Lal Das v. State of Bihar & Ors. [(2002) 1 SCC 149 paras. 7,8,9]and 
Ramanand Chaudhary v. State of Bihar & Ors. [(2002) 1 SCC 153 para. 5] this Court
found it expedient to quash the criminal proceedings due to the abnormal delay in
granting a sanction for prosecution.

##### **Limitation for grant of sanction**

23. Noticing that there is no legislation prescribing the period within which a 
decision for sanction is to be taken, this Court, in Vineet Narian (Supra), sought
to fill the gap by setting a normative prescription of three months for grant of
sanction.

> **“58. (I)(15) Time-limit of three months for grant of sanction for prosecution
> must be strictly adhered to. However, additional time of one month may be allowed
> where consultation is required with the Attorney General (AG) or any other law
> officer in the AG’s office.”**

 26. Yet another legislative development took place in 2018 when the Parliament, by
     way of an amendment to the PC Act, inserted the following provisos to Section 
     19 of the PC Act;

“19. Previous sanction necessary for prosecution. —

(1) No court shall take cognizance of an offence punishable under sections 7, 11,
13 and 15 alleged to have been committed by a public servant, except with the previous
sanction [save as otherwise provided in the Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act, 2013] –

(a) in the case of….

(b) in the case of….

(c) in the case of….

Provided further that…..

Provided also that the appropriate Government or any competent authority shall, 
after the receipt of the proposal requiring sanction for prosecution of a public
servant under this sub-section, endeavour to convey the decision on such proposal
within a period of three months from the date of its receipt:

Provided also that in case where, for the purpose of grant of sanction for prosecution,
legal consultation is required, such period may, for the reasons to be recorded 
in writing, be extended by a further period of one month:

Provided also that the Central Government may, for the purpose of sanction for prosecution
of a public **servant, prescribe such guidelines as it considers necessary.….”**

 27. The new proviso to Section 19 mandating that the competent authority shall endeavour
     to convey the decision on the proposal for sanction within a period of three months
     can only be read and understood as a compelling statutory obligation. We are not
     inclined to accept the submission of the learned ASG that this proviso is only
     directory in nature. In the first place, the consistent effort made by all branches
     of the State, the Judiciary24, the Legislative25, and the Executive26, to ensure
     early decision-making by the competent authority cannot be watered down by lexical
     interpretation of the expression endeavour in the proviso.
 28. The sanctioning authority must bear in mind that public confidence in the maintenance
     of the Rule of Law, which is fundamental in the administration of justice, is 
     at stake here. By causing delay in considering the request for sanction, the sanctioning
     authority stultifies judicial scrutiny, thereby vitiating the process of determination
     of the allegations against the corrupt official27. Delays in prosecuting the corrupt
     breeds a culture of impunity and leads to systemic resignation to the existence
     of corruption in public life. Such inaction is fraught with the risk of making
     future generations getting accustomed to corruption as a way of life. Viewed in
     this context, the duty to take an early decision inheres in the power vested in
     the appointing authority to grant or not to grant sanction.

##### **Limitation for grant of sanction – Four months in total**

** **29. The intention of the Parliament is evident from a combined reading of the
first proviso to Section 19, which uses the expression ‘endeavour’ with the subsequent
provisions. The third proviso mandates that the extended period can be granted only
for one month after reasons are recorded in writing. There is no further extension.
The fourth proviso, which empowers the Central Government to prescribe necessary
guidelines for ensuring the mandate, may also be noted in this regard. It can thus
be concluded that the Parliament intended that the process of grant of sanction 
must be completed within four months, which includes the extended period of one 
month.

XXX

 37. In conclusion, we hold that upon expiry of the three months and the additional
     one-month period, the aggrieved party, be it the complainant, accused or victim,
     would be entitled to approach the concerned writ court. They are entitled to seek
     appropriate remedies, including directions for action on the request for sanction
     and for the corrective measure on accountability that the sanctioning authority
     bears. This is especially crucial if the non-grant of sanction is withheld without
     reason, resulting in the stifling of a genuine case of corruption. Simultaneously,
     the CVC shall enquire into the matter in the exercise of its powers under Section
     8(1)(e) and (f) and take such corrective action as it is empowered under the CVC
     Act.

##### **Issue No. 2 – Answer**

38. The second issue is answered by holding that the period of three months, extended
by one more month for legal consultation, is mandatory. The consequence of non-compliance
with this mandatory requirement shall not be quashing of the criminal proceeding
for that very reason. The competent authority shall be Accountable for the delay
and be subject to judicial review and administrative action by the CVC under Section
8(1)(f) of the CVC Act.

#####  **󠀁[https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2022/3264/3264_2022_15_1501_38812_Judgement_11-Oct-2022.pdf](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2022/3264/3264_2022_15_1501_38812_Judgement_11-Oct-2022.pdf)󠁿**⏎ **Files : 󠀁[VijY Rajmohan vs. State 3264_2022_15_1501_38812_Judgement_11-Oct-2022](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/VijY-Rajmohan-vs.-State-3264_2022_15_1501_38812_Judgement_11-Oct-2022.pdf)󠁿**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
