# PC Act: Mere registration of disproportionate assets in the name of public servant’s relative or friend does not make that person guilty of abetment [dissenting version in judgment]

- Link: https://section1.in/pc-act-mere-registration-of-disproportionate-assets-in-the-name-of-public-servants-relative-or-friend-does-not-make-that-person-guilty-of-abetment-dissenting-version-in-judgment/
- Published: 2025-09-17T12:12:31+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [As per Sudhanshu Dhulia](https://section1.in/pc-act-mere-registration-of-disproportionate-assets-in-the-name-of-public-servants-relative-or-friend-does-not-make-that-person-guilty-of-abetment-dissenting-version-in-judgment/#as-per-sudhanshu-dhulia)
 * [Facts](https://section1.in/pc-act-mere-registration-of-disproportionate-assets-in-the-name-of-public-servants-relative-or-friend-does-not-make-that-person-guilty-of-abetment-dissenting-version-in-judgment/#facts)
    - [Appeal against conviction](https://section1.in/pc-act-mere-registration-of-disproportionate-assets-in-the-name-of-public-servants-relative-or-friend-does-not-make-that-person-guilty-of-abetment-dissenting-version-in-judgment/#appeal-against-conviction)
    - [Case of the prosecution is appellant abetted her husband in acquisition of these assets](https://section1.in/pc-act-mere-registration-of-disproportionate-assets-in-the-name-of-public-servants-relative-or-friend-does-not-make-that-person-guilty-of-abetment-dissenting-version-in-judgment/#case-of-the-prosecution-is-appellant-abetted-her-husband-in-acquisition-of-these-assets)
    - [Trial court’s finding was upheld by the High Court](https://section1.in/pc-act-mere-registration-of-disproportionate-assets-in-the-name-of-public-servants-relative-or-friend-does-not-make-that-person-guilty-of-abetment-dissenting-version-in-judgment/#trial-courts-finding-was-upheld-by-the-high-court)
    - [Story of defence is A1 purchased the disproportionate assets from his brother](https://section1.in/pc-act-mere-registration-of-disproportionate-assets-in-the-name-of-public-servants-relative-or-friend-does-not-make-that-person-guilty-of-abetment-dissenting-version-in-judgment/#story-of-defence-is-a1-purchased-the-disproportionate-assets-from-his-brother)
    - [Burden of proof is reversed and accused is to dislodge the presumption against him](https://section1.in/pc-act-mere-registration-of-disproportionate-assets-in-the-name-of-public-servants-relative-or-friend-does-not-make-that-person-guilty-of-abetment-dissenting-version-in-judgment/#burden-of-proof-is-reversed-and-accused-is-to-dislodge-the-presumption-against-him)
    - [Evaluation of assets was done by the High Court correctly](https://section1.in/pc-act-mere-registration-of-disproportionate-assets-in-the-name-of-public-servants-relative-or-friend-does-not-make-that-person-guilty-of-abetment-dissenting-version-in-judgment/#evaluation-of-assets-was-done-by-the-high-court-correctly)
    - [Mere registration of disproportionate assets in the name of public servant’s relative or friend does not make that person guilty of abetment](https://section1.in/pc-act-mere-registration-of-disproportionate-assets-in-the-name-of-public-servants-relative-or-friend-does-not-make-that-person-guilty-of-abetment-dissenting-version-in-judgment/#mere-registration-of-disproportionate-assets-in-the-name-of-public-servants-relative-or-friend-does-not-make-that-person-guilty-of-abetment)
    - [In the case on hand the appellant allowed her husband to register the disproportionate assets in her name](https://section1.in/pc-act-mere-registration-of-disproportionate-assets-in-the-name-of-public-servants-relative-or-friend-does-not-make-that-person-guilty-of-abetment-dissenting-version-in-judgment/#in-the-case-on-hand-the-appellant-allowed-her-husband-to-register-the-disproportionate-assets-in-her-name)
    - [It is not the appellant’s case that she was not aware of her husband purchasing the properties in her name using the illegitimate sources](https://section1.in/pc-act-mere-registration-of-disproportionate-assets-in-the-name-of-public-servants-relative-or-friend-does-not-make-that-person-guilty-of-abetment-dissenting-version-in-judgment/#it-is-not-the-appellants-case-that-she-was-not-aware-of-her-husband-purchasing-the-properties-in-her-name-using-the-illegitimate-sources)
    - [Appellant’s previous case was relied by the High Court to convict her](https://section1.in/pc-act-mere-registration-of-disproportionate-assets-in-the-name-of-public-servants-relative-or-friend-does-not-make-that-person-guilty-of-abetment-dissenting-version-in-judgment/#appellants-previous-case-was-relied-by-the-high-court-to-convict-her)
    - [Appellant actively participated in the purchase of various movable and immovable properties in her name](https://section1.in/pc-act-mere-registration-of-disproportionate-assets-in-the-name-of-public-servants-relative-or-friend-does-not-make-that-person-guilty-of-abetment-dissenting-version-in-judgment/#appellant-actively-participated-in-the-purchase-of-various-movable-and-immovable-properties-in-her-name)
 * [Conclusion: appeal dismissed and conviction confirmed](https://section1.in/pc-act-mere-registration-of-disproportionate-assets-in-the-name-of-public-servants-relative-or-friend-does-not-make-that-person-guilty-of-abetment-dissenting-version-in-judgment/#conclusion-appeal-dismissed-and-conviction-confirmed)
 * [As per Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah](https://section1.in/pc-act-mere-registration-of-disproportionate-assets-in-the-name-of-public-servants-relative-or-friend-does-not-make-that-person-guilty-of-abetment-dissenting-version-in-judgment/#as-per-justice-ahsanuddin-amanullah)
    - [Conclusion: Appeal allowed and appellant acquitted](https://section1.in/pc-act-mere-registration-of-disproportionate-assets-in-the-name-of-public-servants-relative-or-friend-does-not-make-that-person-guilty-of-abetment-dissenting-version-in-judgment/#conclusion-appeal-allowed-and-appellant-acquitted)
 * [Case was placed before Hon’ble Chief Justice](https://section1.in/pc-act-mere-registration-of-disproportionate-assets-in-the-name-of-public-servants-relative-or-friend-does-not-make-that-person-guilty-of-abetment-dissenting-version-in-judgment/#case-was-placed-before-honble-chief-justice)
    - [Party](https://section1.in/pc-act-mere-registration-of-disproportionate-assets-in-the-name-of-public-servants-relative-or-friend-does-not-make-that-person-guilty-of-abetment-dissenting-version-in-judgment/#party)

#### **As per Sudhanshu Dhulia [dissenting]**

1. I had the benefit of going through the Judgment authored by my learned brother
Ahsanuddin Amanullah, J. where the Accused No.2 (P. Nallammal) has been acquitted
for the offence under Section 109 of IPC read with Section 13(1)(e) and Section 
13(2) of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the PC 
Act’). Though I agree with some of the observations made by my brother Judge, yet
I am unable to accept the conclusion and findings of acquittal as regards Accused
No.2, who was the wife of the public servant Accused No.1. Consequently, I have 
found it necessary to pen down my reasons for doing so.

#### **Facts**

6. For the present purpose, it is sufficient to take note of the following details
of this case:

a. Accused no.1 (husband of the appellant) who was a Member of the Legislative Assembly
and a Minister, was accused of acquiring disproportionate assets while holding public
office as a public servant. The properties were also accumulated in the name of 
the present appellant i.e. Accused no.2 and their minor children. The present appellant
was thus accused of abetting the accumulation of disproportionate assets.

b. The Trial Court convicted Accused No.1 under sections 13(2) and 13(1)(e) of the
PC Act, whereas the appellant (Accused No.2) was convicted under sections 13(2) 
and 13(1)(e) of the PC Act read with section 109 of the IPC. Accused No.1 and appellant(
Accused No.2) were sentenced to rigorous imprisonment of two years and one year,
respectively.

c. An attachment order dated 03.01.2001 was passed under sections 3 and 4 of the
Criminal Law Amendment Ordinance, 1944 (hereinafter referred to as ‘Ordinance’),
whereby the disproportionate assets belonging to Accused No.1 and the appellant 
were attached.

d. Against both these orders (of conviction and sentence, and attachment, respectively),
the accused filed appeals before the High Court. The High Court dismissed the criminal
5 appeals by the impugned judgment dated 20.11.2023. However, the High Court modified
the attachment order by reducing the quantum of disproportionate assets calculated
by the Trial Court.

e. During the pendency of the appeal before the High Court, Accused No.1 (husband
of the appellant) has passed away. Now, we have only Accused No.2 i.e. P. Nallammal,
wife of the main accused (A.M Paramasivam) who is now deceased, before us.

##### **Appeal against conviction**

7. The challenge before us is to a judgment delivered by the Madras High Court on
20.11.2023, whereby the conviction of the appellant under sections 13(2) and 13(
1)(e) of the PC Act read with section 109 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter
referred to as ‘IPC’) and consequent sentence of rigorous imprisonment of one year
imposed by the Trial Court was upheld.

##### **Case of the prosecution is appellant abetted her husband in acquisition of these assets**

9. The prosecution case was that the accused had amassed disproportionate assets,
since there was a vast difference between the assets in their name at the beginning
of the check period i.e., between 16.06.1991 and 09.05.1996. The prosecution case
against the present appellant was that although she had no independent income as
such, she abetted her husband in acquisition of these assets in her name and in 
the name of her children as their representative and natural guardian.

##### **Trial court’s finding was upheld by the High Court**

12. The Trial Court undertook a thorough examination of the oral and documentary
evidence on record, as well as the arguments made by both sides, to arrive at the
conclusion that the prosecution had proved its case beyond reasonable doubt and 
that the Accused No.1 was guilty of misusing his public office in order to accumulate
disproportionate assets, which constituted ‘criminal misconduct’ under section 13
of the Act. Further, the present appellant, i.e. Accused no.2, was held guilty of
abetment of the offence of Section 13(1)(e) of the PC Act. It was specifically held
that the accused had failed to establish that the assets treated as disproportionate
by the prosecution were traceable to legitimate sources of income, since the evidence
brought on record by the accused to prove the same was not satisfactory. These findings
of the Trial Court were affirmed by the High Court by the impugned judgment.

##### **Story of defence is A1 purchased the disproportionate assets from his brother**

14. The story of defence that some portion of land, included in ‘disproportionate
assets’, was purchased by Accused No.1 from his brother in the year 1988 (i.e. before
the check period), but for which the sale deed was executed in favour of the children
of the Accused No.1 and appellant only in the year 1994, is very difficult to believe,
and the High Court and the Trial Court rightly rejected this line of reasoning.

15. The efforts to prove that the income alleged to be ‘disproportionate assets’
by the prosecution is from legitimate sources failed as the evidence presented by
the defence was not only vague but lacked credibility as well.

##### **Burden of proof is reversed and accused is to dislodge the presumption against him**

16. We must also keep in mind that insofar as corruption cases under section 13(
1)(e) of the PC Act are concerned, the burden of proof is reversed, and it becomes
the responsibility of the accused to dislodge the presumption against him. This 
position has been reiterated by this Court in **State of T.N. v. R. Soundirarasu(
2023) 6 SCC 768**:

“83. Section 13(1)(e) of the 1988 Act makes a departure from the principle of criminal
jurisprudence that the burden will always lie on the prosecution to prove the ingredients
of the offences charged and never shifts on the accused to disprove the charge framed
against him. The legal effect of Section 13(1)(e) is that it is for the prosecution
to establish that the accused was in possession of properties disproportionate to
his known sources of income but the term “known sources of income” would mean the
sources known to the prosecution and not the sources known to the accused and within
the knowledge of the accused. It is for the accused to account satisfactorily for
the money/assets in his hands. The onus in this regard is on the accused to give
satisfactory explanation”

In the present case, the prosecution succeeded in establishing that the accused 
were in possession of assets hugely disproportionate to their known sources of income.
The prosecution had successfully discharged its initial burden. Thereafter, it was
for the accused to satisfy the Court, through cogent evidence, that the assets are
from legitimate sources. Upon perusal of the material on record and considering 
the concurrent findings of the Courts below, I am of the opinion that the accused
miserably failed to discharge this burden of satisfactorily explaining the source
of income behind the ‘disproportionate assets’.

##### **Evaluation of assets was done by the High Court correctly**

17. In fact, as far as the evaluation of disproportionate assets is concerned, I
and my learned brother (Ahsanuddin Amanullah, J.), both agree that the High Court
has rightly evaluated the assets, after considering the material on record. The 
only point of our disagreement is the question of the culpability of the appellant(
P. Nallammal). In the opinion of my learned brother Ahsanuddin Amanullah, J., it
was the appellant’s husband (Accused No.1) who had accumulated assets disproportionate
to his known sources of income and the prosecution could not prove that the appellant
was aware that the money from which assets were being purchased or bought in her
name, were from unlawful sources. It is this finding that I disagree with.

##### **Mere registration of disproportionate assets in the name of public servant’s relative or friend does not make that person guilty of abetment**

18. There is no doubt that mere registration of disproportionate assets in the name
of a public servant’s relative or friend does not make that person guilty of abetment
of the offence of Section 13(1)(e) of the PC Act. All the same, it is also a settled
position of law that a person who is not a public servant still can commit an offence
under Section 13(1)(e) and Section 13(2) of the PC Act read with Section 109 of 
the IPC. I am of the opinion that the appellant was an accomplice in the commission
of the crime when she allowed Accused No.1 to register the properties in her name.
Where there is abetment by a close relative in corruption matters, such as the spouse
in the present case, the culpability of such a relative has to be tested by the 
surrounding circumstances and his/her overall conduct. This is because, in such 
cases, there would rarely be direct evidence of abetment. This factor has to be 
kept in mind.

##### **In the case on hand the appellant allowed her husband to register the disproportionate assets in her name**

20. Thus, it is not the case that there were only one or two transactions in the
name of the appellant for which the appellant can say that she acted in a bona fide
manner without knowing that the funds which were used for acquiring these assets
were from unlawful sources. In my considered opinion, these transactions during 
the check period demonstrate how the appellant aided her husband in the accumulation
of disproportionate assets by allowing him to register the same in her name. The
High Court notes that the total salary drawn by accused No.1 during the check period
was Rs. 2,17,178, and considering this, it is impossible to imagine that the appellant
was not aware of her husband’s legitimate income. It is very hard to believe that
she was not aware that these assets which were in her name were not acquired from
her husband’s legitimate sources of income.       

##### **It is not the appellant’s case that she was not aware of her husband purchasing the properties in her name using the illegitimate sources**

21. Moreover, it was never the appellant’s case that she was not aware that her 
husband had been purchasing the properties in her name by using the funds gained
from illegitimate sources. From the Trial Court to this Court, what the appellant
has only been unsuccessfully arguing is that her independent income was not taken
into account and her assets prior to the check period were not properly assessed.
All these grounds have already been dealt with by the Trial Court and High Court,
and the appellant has failed to show that there has been any discrepancy in the 
evaluation of assets. Even on re-evaluation by the High Court, the High Court has
only found a discrepancy of around Rs.2 lacs and even by reducing that amount from
the total worth of disproportionate assets, the percentage of disproportionality
remained above 400% of the accused’s known sources of income. There is no doubt 
that the appellant intentionally aided her husband in the accumulation of disproportionate
assets.

##### **Appellant’s previous case was relied by the High Court to convict her**

22. The Trial Court as well as the High Court have rightly relied upon the decision
of this Court in P. Nallammal & Anr. v. State (1999) 6 SCC 559 to hold the appellant
guilty of abetment of the offence of Section 13(1)(e) of the PC Act. In that case,
this Court had accepted the submission of the State that a person who is not a public
servant, can also be an abettor for the offences under Section 13 of the PC Act.
Accepting and reiterating the illustrations suggested by the State’s Counsel, it
was observed by this Court as follows:

“para.24”

It is clear that the appellant’s case squarely falls within the third illustration
produced above. Interestingly, the case cited above i.e. of P. Nallamal (Supra) 
relates to none other but the present appellant and her deceased husband, who had
earlier approached this Court seeking quashing of the present criminal case.

##### **Appellant actively participated in the purchase of various movable and immovable properties in her name**

26. In no way can the facts of the above cases be compared to the case at hand. 
In the present case, the appellant actively participated in the purchase of various
movable and immovable properties in her name. It has come in unrebuttable evidence
of the prosecution that the present appellant had visited the office of the concerned
Registrar for getting the sale deeds registered. And this had happened on more than
one occasion for different sale deeds. The Trial Court and the High Court had rightly
accepted the prosecution’s case that the appellant knowingly allowed her husband
to accumulate illegal wealth in her name and thus, committed an offence under Section
109 of the IPC read with Section 13(1)(e) and Section 13(2) of the PC Act.

#### **Conclusion: appeal dismissed and conviction confirmed**

27. In view of the above, I find no reason to interfere with the impugned order 
dated 20.11.2023 passed by the High Court. Also, like my brother Judge, I do not
see any fault in the administrative order dated 03.03.2022 passed by the High Court.
Accordingly, I dismiss all these appeals.

#### **As per Justice ****Ahsanuddin Amanullah**

##### **Conclusion: Appeal allowed and appellant acquitted**

41. Consequently, the appeal arising from SLP (Criminal) No.2127/2024] is allowed;
the appeal arising from SLP (Criminal) No.2288/2024 is dismissed, and; the appeals
arising from SLP (Criminal) Nos.5196-5197/2024 are dismissed.

#### **Case was placed before Hon’ble Chief Justice**

##### **Party**

P. Nallammal v. State by the Inspector of Police, Vigilance and Anti-Corruption 
Police, Dindigul, Tamil Nadu – Criminal Appeal No. 2489 of 2025 – 2025 INSC 643 –
May 07, 2025 – Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sudhanshu Dhulia and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ahsanuddin
Amanullah.

[P. Nallammal vs State618_2024_12_1501_61739_Judgement_07-May-2025](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/P.-Nallammal-vs-State618_2024_12_1501_61739_Judgement_07-May-2025.pdf)
[Download](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/P.-Nallammal-vs-State618_2024_12_1501_61739_Judgement_07-May-2025.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
