# POCSO or IPC?

- Link: https://section1.in/pocso-or-ipc/
- Published: 2025-03-11T12:50:54+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

    - [Appeal against dismissing jail appeal by the Hon’ble High Court](https://section1.in/pocso-or-ipc/#appeal-against-dismissing-jail-appeal-by-the-honble-high-court)
    - [Division bench Hon’ble High Court convicted for IPC and POCSO](https://section1.in/pocso-or-ipc/#division-bench-honble-high-court-convicted-for-ipc-and-pocso)
 * [Facts](https://section1.in/pocso-or-ipc/#facts)
    - [Appellant/accused is the father of minor victim (PW.2) who committed sexual assault on PW.2](https://section1.in/pocso-or-ipc/#appellantaccused-is-the-father-of-minor-victim-pw2-who-committed-sexual-assault-on-pw2)
    - [During investigation DNA mapping and examination of present of spermatozoa](https://section1.in/pocso-or-ipc/#during-investigation-dna-mapping-and-examination-of-present-of-spermatozoa)
    - [DOB certificate collected and s.164 CrPC was recorded](https://section1.in/pocso-or-ipc/#dob-certificate-collected-and-s164-crpc-was-recorded)
    - [Appellant took the defence that he had earlier lodged an FIR against his wife and father hence falsely implicated in this case](https://section1.in/pocso-or-ipc/#appellant-took-the-defence-that-he-had-earlier-lodged-an-fir-against-his-wife-and-father-hence-falsely-implicated-in-this-case)
    - [Trial court convicted and sentenced the appellant](https://section1.in/pocso-or-ipc/#trial-court-convicted-and-sentenced-the-appellant)
 * [Analysis](https://section1.in/pocso-or-ipc/#analysis)
    - [Appeal is for limited to question of sentence](https://section1.in/pocso-or-ipc/#appeal-is-for-limited-to-question-of-sentence)
    - [Sections 42 and 42A POCSO Act](https://section1.in/pocso-or-ipc/#sections-42-and-42a-pocso-act)
    - [Arguments regarding punishment only under POCSO Act and under IPC and its findings by the Apex court](https://section1.in/pocso-or-ipc/#arguments-regarding-punishment-only-under-pocso-act-and-under-ipc-and-its-findings-by-the-apex-court)
    - [Though section 42A POCSO Act overrides any other law that are inconsistent with POCSO Act but not section 42 POCSO Act](https://section1.in/pocso-or-ipc/#though-section-42a-pocso-act-overrides-any-other-law-that-are-inconsistent-with-pocso-act-but-not-section-42-pocso-act)
    - [No illegality in directing the appellant to under punishment under sections376(2)(f) and 376(2)(i) of IPC and Sections 3/4 of POCSO Act](https://section1.in/pocso-or-ipc/#no-illegality-in-directing-the-appellant-to-under-punishment-under-sections3762f-and-3762i-of-ipc-and-sections-34-of-pocso-act)
 * [Judgments Cited and Relied Upon in the Judgment:](https://section1.in/pocso-or-ipc/#judgments-cited-and-relied-upon-in-the-judgment)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/pocso-or-ipc/#party)

##### **Appeal against dismissing jail appeal by the Hon’ble High Court**

4. This appeal, preferred on behalf of the appellant-accused, takes an exception
to the judgment dated 2nd August, 2019, passed by the High Court of Judicature at
Allahabad dismissing Jail Appeal No. 6590 of 2016 preferred by the appellant.

##### **Division bench Hon’ble High Court convicted for IPC and POCSO**

5. The Division Bench, while dismissing the appeal, affirmed the judgment and order
dated 16th September, 2016, passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge Court
No.2, Fatehpur3 in Sessions Trial No. 06 of 2016, arising out of Case Crime No. 
236 of 2015 registered at Police Station Chandpur, District Fatehpur, convicting
the appellant for the offences punishable under Sections 376(2)(f) and 376(2)(i)
of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 and Sections 3/4 of Protection of Children from Sexual
Offences Act, 2012. The appellant was awarded punishment of imprisonment for life
along with a fine of Rs. 25,000/-. In default of payment of aforesaid fine, it was
ordered that the appellant was to undergo two months of additional imprisonment 
on each count.

#### **Facts**

##### **Appellant/accused is the father of minor victim (PW.2) who committed sexual assault on PW.2**

6. Brief facts of the case are that the appellant, Gyanendra Singh @ Raja Singh,
is the father of victim (PW-2) who was of about 9 years at the time of the incident.
On 28th October,2015, an FIR came to be lodged by the wife of the appellant, Smt.
Rajani, at P.S. Chandpur, District Fatehpur, alleging inter alia, that she had gone
to her parental house about two months ago with her youngest son Krishna, aged about
2 years, leaving her minor daughter, the victim herein, aged about 9 years, and 
a son named Vishnu, aged about 4 years at her matrimonial house in the custody of
her husband, i.e., the appellant. On 22nd October, 2015 at about 8:00 p.m., the 
appellant enticed the minor victim (PW-2) and took her to the rooftop and committed
sexual assault upon the child. She was detained on the roof by threatening her. 
The minor victim came down from the roof in the morning and narrated the whole incident
to her grandfather, Ram Naresh Singh (PW-3), who, in turn, telephonically informed
the informant about the occurrence. The appellant went absconding after the incident.
The informant (PW-1) got frightened because of the incident and did not go to her
matrimonial home. She somehow mustered the courage and approached the police station
along with her father Ranjeet Singh and father-in-law, Ram Naresh Singh (PW-3), 
as well as the victim and filed the FIR against the appellant. It was, inter alia,
urged in the FIR that the child victim should be medically examined. It was also
stated in the FIR that a day prior to the lodging of the report, the informant had
approached the District Headquarter, Fatehpur from where she was redirected to approach
P.S. Chandpur for lodging the FIR.

##### **During investigation DNA mapping and examination of present of spermatozoa**

7. Investigation was undertaken by Rajesh Kumar Singh (PW-7), Investigating Officer(
I.O.). The minor victim was subjected to medical examination by Dr. Manisha Shukla(
PW-4) who opined that no external injury was found on the body of the victim. On
internal examination, redness was seen present over the labia minora in the vagina
of the victim and her hymen was intact. Forensic material was collected from the
oral, vaginal, vulval and anal swab of the minor victim, slide was prepared and 
sent for pathological examination, D.N.A. mapping and examination of presence of
spermatozoa. The place of the incident was inspected, the site plan was prepared
and accordingly, the appellant was arrested.

##### **DOB certificate collected and s.164 CrPC was recorded**

8. The certificate of date of birth was collected from the school. The child was
examined under Section 164 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 19738 wherein she made
an emphatic allegation of penetrative sexual assault against the appellant.

##### **Appellant took the defence that he had earlier lodged an FIR against his wife and father hence falsely implicated in this case**

9. Investigation was concluded and the charge-sheet was filed against the appellant
in the trial Court for the offences punishable under Sections 376(2)(f) and 376(
2)(i) of IPC and Sections 3/4/5 of the POCSO Act. The trial Court framed charges
against the appellant for the said offences, who pleaded not guilty and claimed 
trial. As many as witnesses were examined and 8 documents were exhibited by the 
prosecution in its evidence. After the completion of prosecution evidence, the appellant
was questioned under Section 313 CrPC and was confronted with the allegations as
appearing in the prosecution case, which the appellant denied and claimed to have
been falsely implicated. The appellant stated that he had earlier lodged an FIR 
against his wife, the informant herein, and his father (PW-3) and therefore, a false
case had been registered against him. He further stated that at the time of the 
incident, the child was residing with his sister. No evidence was led from the side
of the defence.

##### **Trial court convicted and sentenced the appellant**

10. Upon hearing the arguments advanced by the defence counsel and the public prosecutor
and appreciating the evidence available on record, the learned trial Court convicted
and sentenced the appellant as stated above. The appeal preferred by the appellant
was rejected by the High Court vide judgment dated 2nd August, 2019, which is assailed
in this appeal by special leave.

#### **Analysis**

##### **Appeal is for limited to question of sentence**

11. While entertaining the special leave petition, notice limited to the question
of sentence was issued by this Court vide order dated 2nd September, 2024.

17. The only moot question which thus, requires adjudication is whether the conviction
of the appellant ought to have been recorded under the IPC or whether the provisions
of the Special law, i.e., Section 42A of POCSO Act, would prevail thereby, vitiating
the sentence awarded to the appellant for the offences punishable under Sections
376(2)(f) and 376(2)(i) of IPC.

##### **Sections 42 and 42A POCSO Act**

18. Sections 42 and 42A of the POCSO Act would be relevant to adjudicate this issue
and are reproduced hereinbelow for ready reference: –

“42. Alternate punishment.— Where an act or omission constitutes an offence punishable
under this Act and also under sections 166A, 354A, 354B, 354C, 354D, 370, 370A, 
375, 376, [376A, 376AB, 376B, 376C, 376D, 376DA, 376DB], [376E, section 509 of the
Indian Penal Code or section 67B of the Information Technology Act, 2000 (21 of 
2000)], then, notwithstanding anything contained in any law for the time being in
force, the offender found guilty of such offence shall be liable to punishment only
under this Act or under the Indian Penal Code as provides for punishment which is
greater in degree.

42A. Act not in derogation of any other law.— The provisions of this Act shall be
in addition to and not in derogation of the provisions of any other law for the 
time being in force and, in case of any inconsistency, the provisions of this Act
shall have overriding effect on the provisions of any such law to the extent of 
the inconsistency.”

19. A bare perusal of Section 42 of the POCSO Act, would make it clear that when
the alleged acts or omissions constitute offence both under the IPC and the POCSO
Act then, the law which prescribes the punishment of greater degree would have to
be applied.

##### **Arguments regarding punishment only under POCSO Act and under IPC and its findings by the Apex court**

20. Shri R. Balasubramanian, learned senior counsel, tried to draw a distinction
by urging that Section 42A of the POCSO Act, provides that where there is an inconsistency
between the provisions of the POCSO Act and any other law, the provisions of the
special law would have an overriding effect to the extent of the inconsistency. 
He submitted that since the offence under Sections 3/4 of the POCSO Act does not
carry punishment of imprisonment for life, which means imprisonment for remainder
of person’s natural life, the accused could only have been punished under the said
provision and not under Sections 376(2)(f) and 376(2)(i) of IPC, looking to the 
inconsistency in the sentence provided.

21. We feel that the said submission lacks merit. On the face of it, the fields 
of operation of Section 42 and Section 42A are in completely different spheres. 
Section 42 specifically deals with the quantum of punishment mandating that when
a particular act or omission constitutes an offence, both under the POCSO Act and
also under the provisions of the IPC or the Information Technology Act, 2000 then,
the offender found guilty of the offence would be liable to punishment under the
POCSO Act or under the provisions of the IPC whichever provides a punishment of 
a greater degree.

##### **Though section 42A POCSO Act overrides any other law that are inconsistent with POCSO Act but not section 42 POCSO Act**

22. Section 42A of POSCO Act, on the other hand, deals with the procedural aspects
and gives an overriding effect to the provisions of the POCSO Act over any other
law for the time being in force where, the two acts are inconsistent with each other.
Hence, the provisions of Section 42A of POSCO Act, by no stretch of imagination,
can be interpreted so as to override the scope and ambit of enabling provision, 
i.e., Section 42 of POCSO Act.

##### **No illegality in directing the appellant to under punishment under sections376(2)(f) and 376(2)(i) of IPC and Sections 3/4 of POCSO Act**

23. Consequently, we are of the view that conviction of the appellant for the offences
punishable under Sections 376(2)(f) and 376(2)(i) of IPC and Sections 3/4 of POCSO
Act is wholly justified. However, we feel that the High Court erred while directing
that the appellant would have to serve life imprisonment for remainder of his natural
life as provided under Sections 376(2)(f) and 376(2)(i) of IPC.

26. The trial Court, however, had awarded imprisonment for life to the appellant
while convicting him for the offences punishable under Sections 376(2)(f) and 376(
2)(i) of IPC. Since, the said Sections of IPC provides for a higher sentence as 
compared to Sections 3/4 of POCSO Act, the trial Court was justified in choosing
the former to award punishment in terms of Section 42 of POCSO Act. However, we 
have to consider whether the award of imprisonment for life, which means imprisonment
for remainder of person’s natural life, was warranted in the facts and circumstances
of the case. This Court in case of **Shiva Kumar @ Shiva @ Shivamurthy v. State 
of Karnataka**, held as below:-

> “14. Hence, we have no manner of doubt that even in a case where capital punishment
> is not imposed or is not proposed, the Constitutional Courts can always exercise
> the power of imposing a modified or fixed-term sentence by directing that a life
> sentence, as contemplated by “secondly” in Section 53 of the IPC, shall be of 
> a fixed period of more than fourteen years, for example, of twenty years, thirty
> years and so on. The fixed punishment cannot be for a period less than 14 years
> in view of the mandate of Section 433-A CrPC.”

30. Keeping in view the aforesaid exposition of the law, we thus, direct that the
ends of justice would be served by restoring the judgment of the trial Court and
directing that the sentence of life imprisonment awarded to the accused, by the 
trial Court, for the offence under Sections 3/4 of the POCSO Act shall stand revived.

31. For the offences punishable under Sections 376(2)(f) and 376(2) (i) of IPC, 
the accused is sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life, as awarded by the trial
Court, without the stipulation that the life term will enure till the natural life
of the appellant and a fine of Rs. 5,00,000/- and in default, to further undergo
imprisonment of two years. Both the sentences shall run concurrently.

32. The fine, upon being deposited, shall be paid to the victim. 33. The appeal 
is partially allowed in these terms.

#### **Judgments Cited and Relied Upon in the Judgment:**

> 1. Shiva Kumar @ Shiva @ Shivamurthy v. State of Karnataka – (2023) 9 SCC 817
> 2. Navas @ Mulanavas v. State of Kerala – 2024 SCC Online SC 315
> 3. Swamy Shraddhananda v. State of Karnataka – (2008) 13 SCC 767
> 4. Union of India v. V. Sriharan alias Murugan – (2016) 7 SCC 1
> 5. Veerendra v. State of Madhya Pradesh – (Case involving offences under the POCSO
> Act and IPC)

#### **Party**

Gyanendra Singh @ Raja Singh – State of U.P – Criminal Appeal No(s). of 2025 (Arising
out of SLP(Criminal) No(s). of 2025) (Diary No. 36334 of 2024) – 2025 INSC 335 –
March 7, 2025 – Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sandeep Mehta

[Gyanendra Singh @ Raja Singh vs. State of U.P – 363342024_2025-03-07](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/Gyanendra-Singh-@-Raja-Singh-vs.-State-of-U.P-363342024_2025-03-07.pdf)
[Download](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/Gyanendra-Singh-@-Raja-Singh-vs.-State-of-U.P-363342024_2025-03-07.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
