# Preliminary Enquiry: There is no provision for a preliminary enquiry under Section 13 or Section 17 of the PC Act only Lalita Kumari case headed it

- Link: https://section1.in/preliminary-enquiry-there-is-no-provision-for-a-preliminary-enquiry-under-section-13-or-section-17-of-the-pc-act-only-lalita-kumari-case-headed-it/
- Published: 2025-04-11T12:13:21+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Appeal](https://section1.in/preliminary-enquiry-there-is-no-provision-for-a-preliminary-enquiry-under-section-13-or-section-17-of-the-pc-act-only-lalita-kumari-case-headed-it/#appeal)
    - [State of Karnataka preferred this appeal against the quash order](https://section1.in/preliminary-enquiry-there-is-no-provision-for-a-preliminary-enquiry-under-section-13-or-section-17-of-the-pc-act-only-lalita-kumari-case-headed-it/#state-of-karnataka-preferred-this-appeal-against-the-quash-order)
 * [Facts](https://section1.in/preliminary-enquiry-there-is-no-provision-for-a-preliminary-enquiry-under-section-13-or-section-17-of-the-pc-act-only-lalita-kumari-case-headed-it/#facts)
    - [Repondent1 being a public servant enriched himself illicitly](https://section1.in/preliminary-enquiry-there-is-no-provision-for-a-preliminary-enquiry-under-section-13-or-section-17-of-the-pc-act-only-lalita-kumari-case-headed-it/#repondent1-being-a-public-servant-enriched-himself-illicitly)
    - [Hon’ble High Court quashed the FIR on the ground of violation of second proviso to section 17 of PC Act](https://section1.in/preliminary-enquiry-there-is-no-provision-for-a-preliminary-enquiry-under-section-13-or-section-17-of-the-pc-act-only-lalita-kumari-case-headed-it/#honble-high-court-quashed-the-fir-on-the-ground-of-violation-of-second-proviso-to-section-17-of-pc-act)
    - [State’s ground of appeal](https://section1.in/preliminary-enquiry-there-is-no-provision-for-a-preliminary-enquiry-under-section-13-or-section-17-of-the-pc-act-only-lalita-kumari-case-headed-it/#states-ground-of-appeal)
    - [No provision for preliminary enquiry under sections 13 or 17 of PC Act](https://section1.in/preliminary-enquiry-there-is-no-provision-for-a-preliminary-enquiry-under-section-13-or-section-17-of-the-pc-act-only-lalita-kumari-case-headed-it/#no-provision-for-preliminary-enquiry-under-sections-13-or-17-of-pc-act)
    - [Since detailed information was already before SP preliminary enquiry was not mandated](https://section1.in/preliminary-enquiry-there-is-no-provision-for-a-preliminary-enquiry-under-section-13-or-section-17-of-the-pc-act-only-lalita-kumari-case-headed-it/#since-detailed-information-was-already-before-sp-preliminary-enquiry-was-not-mandated)
 * [Conclusion](https://section1.in/preliminary-enquiry-there-is-no-provision-for-a-preliminary-enquiry-under-section-13-or-section-17-of-the-pc-act-only-lalita-kumari-case-headed-it/#conclusion)
    - [Hon’ble High Court’s quash order set aside](https://section1.in/preliminary-enquiry-there-is-no-provision-for-a-preliminary-enquiry-under-section-13-or-section-17-of-the-pc-act-only-lalita-kumari-case-headed-it/#honble-high-courts-quash-order-set-aside)
    - [Judgments that are cited or relied](https://section1.in/preliminary-enquiry-there-is-no-provision-for-a-preliminary-enquiry-under-section-13-or-section-17-of-the-pc-act-only-lalita-kumari-case-headed-it/#judgments-that-are-cited-or-relied)
    - [The acts and sections involved in this case are](https://section1.in/preliminary-enquiry-there-is-no-provision-for-a-preliminary-enquiry-under-section-13-or-section-17-of-the-pc-act-only-lalita-kumari-case-headed-it/#the-acts-and-sections-involved-in-this-case-are)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/preliminary-enquiry-there-is-no-provision-for-a-preliminary-enquiry-under-section-13-or-section-17-of-the-pc-act-only-lalita-kumari-case-headed-it/#party)

#### **Appeal**

##### **State of Karnataka preferred this appeal against the quash order**

2. The State of Karnataka has presently challenged the order dated 25.04.2024 passed
by the Karnataka High Court where the learned Single Judge has quashed the entire
proceedings initiated by the State against respondent no.1 (Sri Channakeshava. H.
D.) for offences under Section 13(1)(b) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention
of Corruption Act, 1988 (for short ‘PC Act’), in a case of Disproportionate Assets(
or DA case as it is called).

#### **Facts**

3. In the year 1998, respondent no.1 was appointed as an Assistant Engineer in Karnataka
Power Transmission Corporation Limited. Later, he was promoted to the post of Executive
Engineer in Bangalore Electricity Supply Corporation (for short ‘BESCOM’).

##### **Repondent1 being a public servant enriched himself illicitly**

4. According to the prosecution, the respondent no.1, while working as a public 
servant, had enriched himself illicitly and consequently, an FIR (No.54/2023) at
P.S Karnataka Lokayukta, Bangalore Town (Bangalore) was registered on 04.12.2023
under Section 13(1)(b) read with 13(2) of the PC Act. Thereafter, the investigation
commenced.

##### **Hon’ble High Court quashed the FIR on the ground of violation of second proviso to section 17 of PC Act**

5. The respondent no.1 filed a Writ Petition before the High Court seeking quashing
of above-mentioned FIR. The FIR was primarily challenged on the ground that there
has been a violation of the second proviso to Section 17 of the PC Act which mandates
that investigation cannot be done without the order of a police officer not below
the rank of a Superintendent of Police (for short ‘SP’) in relation to the offence
mentioned in clause (b) of sub-section 1 of Section 13. Section 17 of the PC Act
reads as follows:

“17. Persons authorised to investigate.—

Provided further that an offence referred to in clause (b) of sub-section (1) of
Section 13 shall not be investigated without the order of a police officer not below
the rank of a Superintendent of Police.” (emphasis supplied)

##### **State’s ground of appeal**

7. **This order of the High Court has been challenged by the State of Karnataka 
before this Court primarily on the ground that a preliminary enquiry visualized 
under the said proviso is desirable but not mandatory**. Further, it has been argued
on behalf of the State of Karnataka that, in the present case, SP had passed an 
order dated 04.12.2023 under Section 17 of the PC Act and this order was passed 
on consideration of relevant materials inasmuch as it was passed on the basis of
a source report dated 05.10.2023.

##### **No provision for preliminary enquiry under sections 13 or 17 of PC Act**

8. **There is no provision for a preliminary enquiry under Section 13 or Section
17 of the PC Act. The second proviso to Section 17 of the PC Act does not speak 
of a preliminary enquiry. It was only in Lalita Kumari v. Government of Uttar Pradesh&
Ors. (2014) 2 SCC 1 that this Court had held that before proceeding against a public
servant in matters of corruption, it is desirable to have a preliminary enquiry.**
Much before Lalita Kumari (Supra), this Court in **P. Sirajuddin v. State of Madras(
1970) 1 SCC 595** had observed that “before a public servant, whatever be his status,
is publicly charged with acts of dishonesty which amount to serious misdemeanour
or misconduct of the type alleged in this case and a first information is lodged
against him, there must be some suitable preliminary enquiry into the allegations
by a responsible officer.” Relying on this judgement, Lalita Kumari (Supra) had 
put the corruption matters under the category of cases in which preliminary enquiry
may be made before registration of FIR. The relevant portion of Lalita Kumari (Supra)
reads as follows:

> “117. In the context of offences relating to corruption, this Court in P. Sirajuddin[
> P. Sirajuddin v. State of Madras, (1970) 1 SCC 595 : 1970 SCC (Cri) 240] expressed
> the need for a preliminary inquiry before proceeding against public servants.
> Conclusion/Directions
> 120. In view of the aforesaid discussion, we hold: ……
> 120.6. As to what type and in which cases preliminary inquiry is to be conducted
> will depend on the facts and circumstances of each case. The category of cases
> in which preliminary inquiry may be made are as under:
> (a) Matrimonial disputes/family disputes
> (b) Commercial offences
> (c) Medical negligence cases
> (d) Corruption cases
> (e) Cases where there is abnormal delay/laches in initiating criminal prosecution,
> for example, over 3 months’ delay in reporting the matter without satisfactorily
> explaining the reasons for delay.” (Emphasis supplied)

The learned counsel for the State of Karnataka would, however, argue that once a
detailed source report is there before the SP, explaining the reasons for initiation
of proceedings and when details are given, a formal preliminary enquiry may not 
be necessary as all the relevant material is already there before the SP.

##### **Since detailed information was already before SP preliminary enquiry was not mandated**

15. **In view of the above, it is clear that preliminary enquiry was not mandated
in the present case, considering that detailed information was already there before
the SP in the form of the source report referred above**. We have also gone through
the order passed by the SP, directing registration of FIR against respondent no.
1, which reflects that the SP had passed that order on the basis of material placed
before him in the form of the source report.

#### **Conclusion**

##### **Hon’ble High Court’s quash order set aside**

16. Considering all the facts and circumstances of the case, we are of the considered
opinion that the High Court ought not to have quashed the FIR in the present case.
Accordingly, we allow this appeal and impugned order dated 25.04.2024 is hereby 
set aside.

##### **Judgments that are cited or relied**

Lalita Kumari v. Government of Uttar Pradesh & Ors. (2014) 2 SCC 1

P. Sirajuddin v. State of Madras (1970) 1 SCC 595

State of Karnataka v. T.N Sudhakar Reddy 2025 SCC OnLine SC 382

CBI v. Thommandru Hannah Vijayalakshmi, (2021) 18 SCC 135

##### **The acts and sections involved in this case are**

**Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988**

+ Section 13(1)(b): offences relating to corruption

+ Section 13(2): punishment for offences under Section 13(1)(b)

+ Section 17: persons authorised to investigate offences under the Act, specifically
the second proviso which mandates investigation not below the rank of a Superintendent
of Police (SP) for offences under Section 13(1)(b)

#### **Party**

State of Karnataka – appellant vs. Sri Channakeshava.H.D & Anr – respondents -Criminal
Appeal No 1849 of 2025 @ Special Leave Petition (Criminal) No.16212 of 2024 – 2025
INSC 471 – April 8, 2025 – Hon’ble Justice Sudhanshu Dhulia and Hon’ble Justice 
K. Vinod Chandran.

[State of Karnataka vs. Sri Channakeshava 460972024_2025-04-08](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/State-of-Karnataka-vs.-Sri-Channakeshava-460972024_2025-04-08.pdf)
[Download](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/State-of-Karnataka-vs.-Sri-Channakeshava-460972024_2025-04-08.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
