# Quash: Bald allegation as if Granddaughter compelled Grandparent to execute the deed in favour of her would not attract offence

- Link: https://section1.in/quash-bald-allegation-as-if-granddaughter-compelled-grandparent-to-execute-the-deed-in-favour-of-her-would-not-attract-offence/
- Published: 2024-11-10T15:48:43+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Factual aspect](https://section1.in/quash-bald-allegation-as-if-granddaughter-compelled-grandparent-to-execute-the-deed-in-favour-of-her-would-not-attract-offence/#factual-aspect)
 * [Appellant is the complainant registered FIR under IPC and Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007](https://section1.in/quash-bald-allegation-as-if-granddaughter-compelled-grandparent-to-execute-the-deed-in-favour-of-her-would-not-attract-offence/#appellant-is-the-complainant-registered-fir-under-ipc-and-maintenance-and-welfare-of-parents-and-senior-citizens-act-2007)
 * [Dispute regarding Gift deed of immovable property](https://section1.in/quash-bald-allegation-as-if-granddaughter-compelled-grandparent-to-execute-the-deed-in-favour-of-her-would-not-attract-offence/#dispute-regarding-gift-deed-of-immovable-property)
 * [Accused preferred quash before the Hon’ble High Court and the same was allowed in part hence appellant preferred SLP](https://section1.in/quash-bald-allegation-as-if-granddaughter-compelled-grandparent-to-execute-the-deed-in-favour-of-her-would-not-attract-offence/#accused-preferred-quash-before-the-honble-high-court-and-the-same-was-allowed-in-part-hence-appellant-preferred-slp)
 * [Consideration of submissions](https://section1.in/quash-bald-allegation-as-if-granddaughter-compelled-grandparent-to-execute-the-deed-in-favour-of-her-would-not-attract-offence/#consideration-of-submissions)
 * [Consideration will be only to the quash order and not concerned to the case made out by the appellant](https://section1.in/quash-bald-allegation-as-if-granddaughter-compelled-grandparent-to-execute-the-deed-in-favour-of-her-would-not-attract-offence/#consideration-will-be-only-to-the-quash-order-and-not-concerned-to-the-case-made-out-by-the-appellant)
 * [Perusal of letter shows that it was sent 16 months after the execution of second gift deed and no allegations were made against the respondents in that letter](https://section1.in/quash-bald-allegation-as-if-granddaughter-compelled-grandparent-to-execute-the-deed-in-favour-of-her-would-not-attract-offence/#perusal-of-letter-shows-that-it-was-sent-16-months-after-the-execution-of-second-gift-deed-and-no-allegations-were-made-against-the-respondents-in-that-letter)
 * [There is a delay in registration of FIR and no allegation against the 4th and 5th respondents](https://section1.in/quash-bald-allegation-as-if-granddaughter-compelled-grandparent-to-execute-the-deed-in-favour-of-her-would-not-attract-offence/#there-is-a-delay-in-registration-of-fir-and-no-allegation-against-the-4th-and-5th-respondents)
 * [Therefore, the view taken by the High Court that the FIR deserves to be quashed cannot be faulted](https://section1.in/quash-bald-allegation-as-if-granddaughter-compelled-grandparent-to-execute-the-deed-in-favour-of-her-would-not-attract-offence/#therefore-the-view-taken-by-the-high-court-that-the-fir-deserves-to-be-quashed-cannot-be-faulted)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/quash-bald-allegation-as-if-granddaughter-compelled-grandparent-to-execute-the-deed-in-favour-of-her-would-not-attract-offence/#party)

##### **Factual aspect**

##### **Appellant is the complainant registered FIR under IPC and Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007**

1. The appellant is the complainant on whose complaint a First Information Report
being Crime No.21 of 2021 (for short, ‘the impugned FIR’) was registered for the
offences punishable under Sections 342, 347, 504, 506, 116 and 384 read with Section
34 of the Indian Penal Code (for short, ‘the IPC’) as well as under Sections 23 
and 24 of the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007 (
for short, ‘the 2007 Act’). 2nd to 5th respondents were shown as accused. The 2nd
respondent is a son of the appellant. The 3rd respondent is the wife of the 2nd 
respondent. The 4th respondent is the daughter of 2nd and 3rd respondents. The 5th
respondent is the father of the 3rd respondent.

##### **Dispute regarding Gift deed of immovable property**

2. One Dhanyakumar Doshi was the appellant’s husband. The appellant has two sons(
2nd respondent and Akshay) and two daughters – Shubhangi and Sangita. The appellant’s
husband died on 24th February 2020. On 4th September 2017, the appellant and her
husband executed a registered Gift Deed by which they gifted an immovable property
and a residential house to 4th respondent. On 16th October 2017, the appellant and
her husband executed a Deed of Rectification to correct the mistake that crept into
the description of the property in the Gift Deed dated 4th September 2017. Another
Gift Deed was executed by the appellant and her husband on 7th November 2017, by
which they gifted a flat/apartment in Hyderabad to the 2nd and 4th respondents.

3. It is the case of the appellant that on 29th March 2019, her husband addressed
a letter to the District Magistrate and District Commissioner of Hyderabad Urban
District alleging that the 2nd and 3rd respondents have been harassing and threatening
him and the appellant and that they forced them to execute gift deeds of their valuable
properties. He alleged that the 2nd and 3rd respondents had threatened him not to
disclose the execution of gift deeds. He was afraid of revealing the said facts 
to anyone. He alleged that 2nd and 3rd respondents were ill-treating his younger
son. Therefore, the appellant’s husband requested the District Magistrate to cancel
the Gift Deeds. In the letter, the appellant’s husband mentioned that his confidant
shall post the same only after his death. The appellant’s case is that when her 
daughter Sangita visited Hyderabad, her husband handed her a copy of the letter 
dated 29th March 2019.

##### **Accused preferred quash before the Hon’ble High Court and the same was allowed in part hence appellant preferred SLP**

4. On 7th November 2020 and on 12th November 2020, the appellant’s daughter – Sangita,
addressed letters to Adarshnagar Colony Police Station at Hyderabad and Saidabad
Police Station at Hyderabad, respectively, complaining about the fact that the 2nd
and 3rd respondents were ill-treating the appellant and that they had confined her
to the house. The appellant signed a document dated 24th November 2020 (Annexure
P-7) wherein she declared that her life was in danger as she was apprehending some
actions by the 2nd and 3rd respondents. Another complaint was filed by the appellant
on 7th December 2020 to the Commissioner of Police Saidabad, Telangana, making similar
allegations. On 17th January 2021, the impugned FIR was registered based on the 
complaint made by the appellant on 17th January 2021. Before the High Court of Telangana,
the 2nd to 5th respondents filed a petition under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 (for short, ‘the CrPC’) for quashing the impugned FIR. The learned
Single Judge of the High Court, by the impugned order dated 1st June 2021, allowed
the quashing petition in part and quashed the proceedings insofar as the 4th and
5th respondents are concerned. This is the impugned judgment which has been challenged
by way of present appeal.

##### **Consideration of submissions**

##### **Consideration will be only to the quash order and not concerned to the case made out by the appellant**

7. At the outset, we must clarify that we are examining the challenge to the impugned
judgment only to the limited extent of the order of quashing the impugned FIR as
far as the 4th and 5th respondents are concerned. We are not examining the case 
made out by the appellant as against the 2nd and 3rd respondents.

8. The appellant and her husband executed the Gift Deeds on 4th September 2017 and
7th November 2017. In between, there was a Deed of Rectification dated 16th October
2017 in respect of the Gift Deed dated 4th September 2017.

##### **Perusal of letter shows that it was sent 16 months after the execution of second gift deed and no allegations were made against the respondents in that letter**

9. We have perused the letter dated 29th March 2019, allegedly written by the appellant’s
husband. We may note here that the letter was addressed by him more than 16 months
after the execution of the second Gift Deed. No allegations were made against the
4th and 5th respondents in this letter. We have carefully perused the complaints
dated 7th November 2020 and 12th November 2020 addressed by the appellant’s daughter–
Sangita, to officers in charge of two different Police Stations. The letter dated
7th November 2020 records that the 4th respondent had left for the UK and was staying
there. We find no specific allegations against the 4th and 5th respondents in the
complaint. It is pertinent to note that as stated in the letter dated 7th November
2020 sent by the appellant’s daughter Sangita, in January 2020, the appellant’s 
husband gave her a copy of the letter dated 29th March 2019. In both letters, there
are only vague and general allegations against the 4th and 5th respondents. In the
writing dated 24th November 2020, allegedly signed by the appellant, she had complained
about the burn injuries sustained by her. Even in the letter, no specific allegations
were made against the 4th and 5th respondents. In the complaint dated 7th December
2020 addressed by the appellant to the Commissioner of Police, Cyberabad, Telangana,
only general allegations have been made that the 4th and 5th respondents were acting
hand in hand at the instance of the 2nd and 3rd respondents. This is the only allegation
made against the 4th and 5th respondents. In the complaint dated 11th January 2021
made by the appellant, there is a bald allegation that the 2nd to 5th respondents
compelled herself and her husband to execute the gift deeds. It is also stated that
the 2nd and 3rd respondents were ill-treating her other son, Akshay.

##### There is a **delay in registration of FIR and no allegation against the 4^(th) and 5^(th) respondents**

10. There is a delay involved in the registration of FIR. The letter dated 29th 
March 2019, which was relied upon by the appellant and addressed by her husband,
shows that on 29th March 2019, her deceased husband was aware of the two gift deeds
executed by him and the appellant. The appellant’s husband complained about the 
gift deeds after a gap of 16 months from the date of the execution of the second
gift deed. The appellant’s first complaint was on 24th November 2020. Apart from
this delay, after having perused not only the letters/complaints of the appellant
but also the letters addressed by her husband and daughter, we find that the appellant
has not made any allegation against the 4th and 5th respondents ascribing them any
specific role.

11. The role allegedly played by the 4th and 5th respondent is within the special
knowledge of the appellant. She cannot improve upon what she said in her earlier
complaints/letters even if the investigation proceeds against them.

##### Therefore, the view taken by the High Court** that the FIR deserves to be quashed cannot be faulted**

12. Therefore, the view taken by the High Court that the FIR deserves to be quashed
as against the 4th and 5th respondents cannot be faulted. Therefore, no case is 
made out to interfere in this criminal appeal. Accordingly, the Criminal Appeal 
is dismissed.

##### **Party**

Aruna Dhanyakumar Doshi …Appellant Versus The State Of Telangana & Ors …Respondents–
Criminal Appeal No. 4130 Of 2024 – 2024 INSC 855 – November 07, 2024.

[Aruna Dhanyakumar Doshi vs. The State of Telangana 189162021_2024-11-07](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Aruna-Dhanyakumar-Doshi-vs.-The-State-of-Telangana-189162021_2024-11-07.pdf)
[Download](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Aruna-Dhanyakumar-Doshi-vs.-The-State-of-Telangana-189162021_2024-11-07.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
