# Quash set-aside: Prosecution may be lodged by or with the permission of the Sub-Registrar as per section 83 of the Registration Act, 1908

- Link: https://section1.in/quash-set-aside-prosecution-may-be-lodged-by-or-with-the-permission-of-the-sub-registrar-as-per-section-83-of-the-registration-act-1908/
- Published: 2024-02-22T20:10:55+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Challenge against the quash order](https://section1.in/quash-set-aside-prosecution-may-be-lodged-by-or-with-the-permission-of-the-sub-registrar-as-per-section-83-of-the-registration-act-1908/#challenge-against-the-quash-order)
 * [Brief Background](https://section1.in/quash-set-aside-prosecution-may-be-lodged-by-or-with-the-permission-of-the-sub-registrar-as-per-section-83-of-the-registration-act-1908/#brief-background)
 * [Analysing the order](https://section1.in/quash-set-aside-prosecution-may-be-lodged-by-or-with-the-permission-of-the-sub-registrar-as-per-section-83-of-the-registration-act-1908/#analysing-the-order)
 * [How to consider and analyse the quash petition – Explained](https://section1.in/quash-set-aside-prosecution-may-be-lodged-by-or-with-the-permission-of-the-sub-registrar-as-per-section-83-of-the-registration-act-1908/#how-to-consider-and-analyse-the-quash-petition-8211-explained)
 * [Prosecution may be lodged by or with the permission of the Sub-Registrar](https://section1.in/quash-set-aside-prosecution-may-be-lodged-by-or-with-the-permission-of-the-sub-registrar-as-per-section-83-of-the-registration-act-1908/#prosecution-may-be-lodged-by-or-with-the-permission-of-the-subregistrar)
 * [Case restored](https://section1.in/quash-set-aside-prosecution-may-be-lodged-by-or-with-the-permission-of-the-sub-registrar-as-per-section-83-of-the-registration-act-1908/#case-restored)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/quash-set-aside-prosecution-may-be-lodged-by-or-with-the-permission-of-the-sub-registrar-as-per-section-83-of-the-registration-act-1908/#party)

##### Challenge against the quash order

2. These appeal(s) call into question the correctness of a common judgment and order
dated 24th March 2022 passed by the High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi, in W.P(s)(
Crl.)Nos. 02 of 2021 and 47 of 2021, by which the High Court quashed Giridih(T)P.
S.Case No.217 of 2020 @ FIR No.04797769 dated 5th November, for the offences under
Sections 420, 467, 468, and 471 of the Indian Penal Code, 18601 , pending before
the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Giridih.

##### Brief Background

3. One Purushotam Kumar (A-1) forged a Power of Attorney2 on the basis of which 
transfer of certain land in favour of Bikash Kumar Singh, S/o Surendra Singh (A-
2), Surendra Singh (A-3) with the latter witnessing the sale transaction stood registered
with the Registrar having competent jurisdiction at a place known as Giridih. The
original owner Naveen Kumar Rai, having learnt of such an illegal transaction instituted
proceedings before a Civil Court seeking a declaration of the transaction to be 
null and void. Independently, the District Deputy Registrar, Giridih initiated an
inquiry in terms of Circular No.15/R(Miscellaneous)Public Applications-04/163 dated
Nil resulting in the passing of an order, prima facie holding A-1 to have forged
the PoA impersonating Naveen Kumar Rai, leading to the execution of a sale deed 
which document also stood registered with the very same Authority. Resultantly, 
on the basis of such an inquiry both the documents i.e., the PoA and the sale deed
stood cancelled. Further, on the basis of the communication dated 15th October, 
2020 that of the District Deputy Registrar, Giridih, FIR bearing the above-noted
particulars stood registered by Sahdeo Mehra, against seven accused persons including
A-1, A-2 and A-3.

##### Analysing the order

6. In our considered view, the premise on which the Court proceeded in quashing 
the FIR is on the wrong assumption, interpretation, and application of the law.

10. It is not in dispute that the communication dated 15th October, 2020 resulting
in registration of the FIR was that of a competent authority i.e., the Sub-Registrar
of the concerned district. In any event, such a power is the result of an action
only in reference to and in connection with the Act and not the general provisions
of IPC in relation to other penal provisions for which the FIR actually stood registered.

##### How to consider and analyse the quash petition – Explained

11. Given that the FIR against which the petition under Section 482 Code of Criminal
Procedure4 had been preferred were offences contained only in the IPC, what the 
Court was required to consider was whether any of the well-established grounds that
are enumerated in judgments of this Court viz., State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal [
1992 Suppl.(1) SCC 335]; Neeharika Infrastructure v. State of Maharashtra [2021 
SCC OnLine 315] and reiterated in **[Peethambaran v. State of Kerala](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2020/1351/1351_2020_8_1503_44297_Judgement_03-May-2023.pdf)**[
2023 SCC OnLine 553], were made out or not. We find the High Court to have referred
to the detailed discussion in Vineet Kumar and Ors. v. State of Uttar Pradesh and
Anr [(2017) 13 SCC 369] . but, however, discussion is conspicuously absent as to
how the aspect of “criminality” is not present. It is all too well settled that 
while exercising such inherent powers what is required to be examined is only the
prima facie existence of the offence sought to be quashed. For the offence of cheating,
for instance, this Court has enumerated certain factors to be considered in Vijay
Kumar Ghai v. State of West Bengal [(2022) 7 SCC 124].

##### Prosecution may be lodged by or with the permission of the Sub-Registrar

12. The Court’s observation that because there is no order of the Inspector General,“
in spite of that this FIR has been lodged by the District Sub-Registrar, Giridih,
which is against Section 83 of the Registration Act, 1908” as demonstrated (supra)
is completely divorced from the text of the Section itself, for, it provides, as
reproduced above, that a prosecution may be lodged by or with the permission of 
the Sub-Registrar in whose territory the offence has been committed

##### Case restored

13. It is for both the above reasons that the exercise of power under Section 482
Cr.P.C., in the attending facts and circumstances, was unjustified and entirely 
unsustainable. The FIR and the consequent case, quashed vide the impugned judgment
stand restored to the file of the concerned district Court. All consequential steps
may follow including the Trial Court commencing proceedings as per law. The appellant
is directed to appear before the Court on 01.03.2024 at 10.00 a.m. Once such presence
is registered with the Court and the proceedings begin, we direct the trial to be
expedited and, if not inconvenient and otherwise, possibly conduct the same on a
day-to-day basis, minimizing adjournments so as to ensure that the proceedings are
taken to the lawful conclusion at the earliest.

##### Party

NAVIN KUMAR RAI … APPELLANT(S) VERSUS SURENDRA SINGH AND ORS. ETC. … RESPONDENT(
S) – CRIMINAL APPEAL NOS. 890-891 OF 2024 (Arising out of Special Leave Petition(
Crl.)Nos.5531-32 of 2022) – 2024 INSC 116 – February 14, 2024

**[Click here to go to direct link ](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2022/16242/16242_2022_9_1503_50523_Judgement_14-Feb-2024.pdf)**

**[Navin-Kumar-Rai-vs.-Surendra-Singh](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/Navin-Kumar-Rai-vs.-Surendra-Singh-1.pdf)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
