# Quash: The security clause in the agreement discusses adjustment and not refunds thus no criminal offence made out

- Link: https://section1.in/quash-the-security-clause-in-the-agreement-discusses-adjustment-and-not-refunds-thus-no-criminal-offence-made-out/
- Published: 2026-03-04T15:17:13+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Appeal](https://section1.in/quash-the-security-clause-in-the-agreement-discusses-adjustment-and-not-refunds-thus-no-criminal-offence-made-out/#appeal)
 * [Facts](https://section1.in/quash-the-security-clause-in-the-agreement-discusses-adjustment-and-not-refunds-thus-no-criminal-offence-made-out/#facts)
    - [Appellants and respondent no.2 are parties to the agreement in which appellants to provide lands and the respondent to construct residential units  ](https://section1.in/quash-the-security-clause-in-the-agreement-discusses-adjustment-and-not-refunds-thus-no-criminal-offence-made-out/#appellants-and-respondent-no2-are-parties-to-the-agreement-in-which-appellants-to-provide-lands-and-the-respondent-to-construct-residential-units-nbsp)
    - [Appellants are accused respondents no.2 is the informant](https://section1.in/quash-the-security-clause-in-the-agreement-discusses-adjustment-and-not-refunds-thus-no-criminal-offence-made-out/#appellants-are-accused-respondents-no2-is-the-informant)
    - [The First Information Report: Despite received security amount the appellants did not hand over the possession of lands to the respondent](https://section1.in/quash-the-security-clause-in-the-agreement-discusses-adjustment-and-not-refunds-thus-no-criminal-offence-made-out/#the-first-information-report-despite-received-security-amount-the-appellants-did-not-hand-over-the-possession-of-lands-to-the-respondent)
    - [Appellants preferred W.P before High Court: High Court’s dismissal Order](https://section1.in/quash-the-security-clause-in-the-agreement-discusses-adjustment-and-not-refunds-thus-no-criminal-offence-made-out/#appellants-preferred-wp-before-high-court-high-courts-dismissal-order)
 * [Discussion](https://section1.in/quash-the-security-clause-in-the-agreement-discusses-adjustment-and-not-refunds-thus-no-criminal-offence-made-out/#discussion)
    - [Whether Quash petition screens criminal offence or FIR amounts to abuse of process of law to be examine?](https://section1.in/quash-the-security-clause-in-the-agreement-discusses-adjustment-and-not-refunds-thus-no-criminal-offence-made-out/#whether-quash-petition-screens-criminal-offence-or-fir-amounts-to-abuse-of-process-of-law-to-be-examine)
    - [The Joint Venture Agreement](https://section1.in/quash-the-security-clause-in-the-agreement-discusses-adjustment-and-not-refunds-thus-no-criminal-offence-made-out/#the-joint-venture-agreement)
    - [Clauses in JVA](https://section1.in/quash-the-security-clause-in-the-agreement-discusses-adjustment-and-not-refunds-thus-no-criminal-offence-made-out/#clauses-in-jva)
    - [Assurance of appellants regarding court matters in respect of the land](https://section1.in/quash-the-security-clause-in-the-agreement-discusses-adjustment-and-not-refunds-thus-no-criminal-offence-made-out/#assurance-of-appellants-regarding-court-matters-in-respect-of-the-land)
    - [Security clause: This clause does not say about refund of security money but speaks of adjustment of the same in the share](https://section1.in/quash-the-security-clause-in-the-agreement-discusses-adjustment-and-not-refunds-thus-no-criminal-offence-made-out/#security-clause-this-clause-does-not-say-about-refund-of-security-money-but-speaks-of-adjustment-of-the-same-in-the-share)
    - [Since the clause is for adjustment the allegation of security money not refunded would nto make out a criminal offence](https://section1.in/quash-the-security-clause-in-the-agreement-discusses-adjustment-and-not-refunds-thus-no-criminal-offence-made-out/#since-the-clause-is-for-adjustment-the-allegation-of-security-money-not-refunded-would-nto-make-out-a-criminal-offence)
    - [Letter written by Tehsildar is not traced in the Tehsildar office hence false document](https://section1.in/quash-the-security-clause-in-the-agreement-discusses-adjustment-and-not-refunds-thus-no-criminal-offence-made-out/#letter-written-by-tehsildar-is-not-traced-in-the-tehsildar-office-hence-false-document)
    - [Merely a document is not traceable in the records it cannot be said to be forged](https://section1.in/quash-the-security-clause-in-the-agreement-discusses-adjustment-and-not-refunds-thus-no-criminal-offence-made-out/#merely-a-document-is-not-traceable-in-the-records-it-cannot-be-said-to-be-forged)
    - [Non-fulfilment of contractual obligations only civil remedy is required](https://section1.in/quash-the-security-clause-in-the-agreement-discusses-adjustment-and-not-refunds-thus-no-criminal-offence-made-out/#nonfulfilment-of-contractual-obligations-only-civil-remedy-is-required)
    - [No criminal breach of trust offence made out](https://section1.in/quash-the-security-clause-in-the-agreement-discusses-adjustment-and-not-refunds-thus-no-criminal-offence-made-out/#no-criminal-breach-of-trust-offence-made-out)
    - [FIR only discloses civil cause of action thus case quashed](https://section1.in/quash-the-security-clause-in-the-agreement-discusses-adjustment-and-not-refunds-thus-no-criminal-offence-made-out/#fir-only-discloses-civil-cause-of-action-thus-case-quashed)
 * [Resources](https://section1.in/quash-the-security-clause-in-the-agreement-discusses-adjustment-and-not-refunds-thus-no-criminal-offence-made-out/#resources)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/quash-the-security-clause-in-the-agreement-discusses-adjustment-and-not-refunds-thus-no-criminal-offence-made-out/#party)

#### **Appeal**

2. This appeal impugns the judgment and order of the High Court of Judicature at
Allahabad1 dated 30.07.2021 passed in Misc. Bench No. 16314 of 2021 whereby the 
[writ petition](https://section1.in/writ-miscellaneous-applications-not-entertained-after-disposal-of-a-main-writ-petition/)
of the appellants seeking quashing of FIR 2 No.0112 of 2021, dated 14.03.2021, lodged
at Police Station (for short, P.S.) Hazratganj, District Lucknow, under Sections
406, 420, 467, 468 and 471 of the [Indian Penal Code](https://section1.in/title-understanding-section-120b-of-the-indian-penal-code-ipc-criminal-conspiracy-and-its-implications/),
18603, has been dismissed.

#### **Facts**

##### **Appellants and respondent no.2 are parties to the agreement in which appellants to provide lands and the respondent to construct residential units  **

3. Vandana Jain (appellant no. 1), Divya Bhatia, Siddharth Jain (appellant no.2)
and Kanishk Jain (appellant no.3), described as first party, entered into a joint
venture agreement dated 16.08.2010 with Motor General Sales Ltd. (Respondent No.
2), described as second party. As per the terms and conditions of the JVA, the first
party gave development rights to the second party for developing land i.e., Plot
No. 61 (Old No. 276A), admeasuring 1500 Square Yards, bearing Municipal No. 3A/207&
208, Azad Nagar, Kanpur. Under the agreement, the second party was required to construct
residential units/apartments over the land at its own cost. The capital contribution
of the first party was the land which was valued at Rupees Two Crores Fifty Lacs
Only. The project was to come up as a single unit in which both first and second
party had 50% share.

4. Under the JVA, the second party undertook to complete the project within two 
years, upon fulfillment of certain conditions such as (i) sanction of plan by Kanpur
Development Authority5; and (ii) handing over of vacant possession of the site to
the second party.

##### **Appellants are accused respondents no.2 is the informant**

7. For certain reasons, not necessary to be disclosed in these proceedings, the 
JVA could not materialize, resulting in dispute between the parties. In consequence,
on 14.03.2021, the second respondent lodged the impugned [FIR implicating the appellants along with Divya Bhati as accused](https://section1.in/sc-st-act-as-per-fir-accused-insulted-the-complainant-inside-his-office-hence-does-not-come-within-public-view/).

##### **The First Information Report: Despite received security amount the appellants did not hand over the possession of lands to the respondent**

8. In the FIR it was, inter-alia, alleged: (a) that despite receiving Rs. 1 Crore
as security for due compliance of the JVA, the accused did not hand over possession
of the land; (b) that despite repeated demands for return of the advance money, 
the accused did not return the same; (c) that the accused made a false promise that
the land was free from litigation; (d) that the accused had forged documents to 
deceive the complainant; (e) that, later, it was discovered that in respect of the
land concerned, the accused were in litigation with one Indira Devi Kanodia and 
the said litigation had been pending since before the date of the agreement, therefore,
by suppressing this fact, the accused cheated the complainant. On these allegations,
the [FIR was registered under Sections](https://section1.in/section-188-ipc-registering-fir-investigation-procedure-explained/)
406, 420, 467, 468 and 471 I.P.C.

##### **Appellants preferred W.P before High Court: High Court’s dismissal Order**

11. High Court dismissed the writ petition in limine, vide impugned order, without
considering [whether the facts spelt out in the FIR](https://section1.in/whether-the-same-accused-can-be-arrested-and-grant-bail-for-new-offence-added-in-the-fir-whether-victim-has-rights-during-bail/)
disclosed a pure civil cause of action as also whether the allegations made, make
out an offence qua preparation of a false document.

12. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and have perused the record.

#### **Discussion**

##### **Whether Quash petition screens criminal offence or FIR amounts to abuse of process of law to be examine?**

15. At the outset, we may [observe that while considering a prayer to quash an FIR](https://section1.in/pc-act-fir-quash-high-court-would-not-have-entered-into-the-observation-that-there-is-no-direct-evidence-for-the-demand-for-bribe/),
ordinarily the allegations made therein are to be taken at their face value to assess
whether prima facie commission of a cognizable offence is made out or not. However,
where the cause espoused in the FIR is essentially of a civil nature, while addressing
a quashing petition, the Court must have regard to the attending circumstances and
assess whether it has been given cloak of [criminal offence](https://section1.in/wrong-a-wrongful-contract-may-constitute-both-civil-wrong-and-criminal-offence/)
and whether proceeding further on the FIR would amount to the abuse of the process
of the court/ law. In making such assessment, the Court may consider not only the
contents of the [FIR but also the admitted facts / documents](https://section1.in/fir-is-a-public-document-and-also-a-dying-declaration-and-hence-it-shall-be-treated-as-substantive-piece-of-evidence-and-admissible-u-s-321-evidence-act-1872/)
recited therein.

16. In the case on hand, a perusal of the FIR would indicate that existence of JVA
is admitted. The thrust of the allegations is on: (a) false representation by the
appellants about their title to the property/land including suppression of litigation
pending in respect thereof; (b) non-fulfilment of contractual obligations; (c) non-
refund of security money; (d) furnishing false document. We shall deal with each
of the above allegations.

##### **The Joint Venture Agreement**

17. There is no dispute between the parties that they had executed a JVA dated 16th
August 2010. The dispute between the parties have arisen from the said JVA. In such
circumstances, as it is part of the record, it would be useful to refer to its relevant
clauses. The said agreement introduces the property in question in the following
manner:

“……………..”

##### **Clauses in JVA**

19. A careful reading of the aforesaid clauses would reflect that the first party,
which means the appellants herein, had assured — (a) that the premises is not attached
in Banks or Government Department for Income Tax demand, Sales Tax dues etc. nor
it will be attached for any financial liability in future; (b) that if any financial
liability demand, taxes, etc. of first party arises it will be realized from the
portion of the land and building of first party’s share only and will not be recoverable
from the share of the second party; and (c) that the first party would indemnify
the second party in all respect with regard to perfect and good marketable title
over the subject land and assure that the first party has not been restrained by
any court order or income tax or other government department or otherwise to enter
into this JVA.

##### **Assurance of appellants regarding court matters in respect of the land**

20. It is clear from the afore-extracted clauses that there is no specific statement
by the first party as regards no litigation pending. The representation of the first
party is about there being no restraint order of any court or income tax or other
government department on dealing with the land. What is clear from the agreement
is that the appellants had assured the complainant party (a) that there was no attachment
or demand against the property; (b) that there is no restraint order operating on
them to deal with the property; and (c) that they will indemnify the second party
in all respect with regard to perfect, good and marketable title over the subject
land. Therefore, the allegation that the accused had falsely represented about there
being no litigation qua the land/ property is unfounded.

##### **Security clause: This clause does not say about refund of security money but speaks of adjustment of the same in the share**

21. Clause 5 provides for giving of security by the second party for due compliance
of the agreement. What is important is that clause 5 does not envisage refund of
the security money. Rather, it speaks of adjustment of the security deposit from
the share of the first party derived from [sale proceeds](https://section1.in/prosecution-has-to-prove-to-whom-a1-has-sold-the-stolen-article-and-obtained-sale-proceeds-of-rs-8000/)
of the proposed flats in the complex. Interestingly, the expression “respective 
share of the parties” is defined in the definition clause of the agreement as follows:

> “That the entire project will be a single unit however for safe consideration 
> in case of any disputes the ratio of both parties in constructed portion of the
> project shall be 50% each. Immediately after sanction of the map and before commencement
> of construction work, both the parties shall decide their respective portions 
> in the map. The share shall be: 50% to First Party 50% to Second Party”.

##### **Since the clause is for adjustment the allegation of security money not refunded would nto make out a criminal offence**

22. Therefore, the [deposit of security money](https://section1.in/section-167-cr-p-c-condition/)
is nonrefundable. The object of it was to ensure fulfilment of contractual obligations.
In lieu of refund, the security amount had to be adjusted from the share of the 
first party derived from sale proceeds. In such circumstances, the allegation about
security money being not refunded would not make out a criminal [offence though](https://section1.in/juvenile-justice-act-2015-though-offences-pocso-and-murder-have-been-proved-accused-acquitted-based-on-procedural-illegalities/)
it may give rise to a civil cause of action.

##### **Letter written by Tehsildar is not traced in the Tehsildar office hence false document**

23. During arguments, we had put a specific question to the learned counsel for 
the respondent as to which document is alleged to have been forged by the accused
to disclose their title. In response thereto, the learned counsel for the complainant
placed before us a letter written by Tehsildar (Judicial), Sadar, Kanpur, U.P. which
disclosed that plot no. 61 (Old Plot No. 276A) area 1500 Sq. Yds. bearing Municipal
No. 3A/207 and 208, Azad Nagar, Kanpur is the ancestral property of Shri Siddharth
Jain and others regarding which there is no dispute. According to the complainant,
this letter is not traceable in the office from which it is purported to have been
issued therefore, it is a false document.

##### **Merely a document is not traceable in the records it cannot be said to be forged**

    ```wp-block-verse
    24. In our view, merely because a document is not traceable in the records after several years of its issuance, it cannot be said that the document is forged. It is a matter of common knowledge that certificate/letters, such as the one in question, are not maintained in perpetuity. Therefore, if, after 10 or 11 years, merely because the office reports that such letter/ certificate is not traceable in the records of the office, it cannot be said that it is forged. A document would be considered forged document only when the allegations are to the effect that it is a false document within the meaning of section 464 of the I.P.C.
    ```

There appears no allegations that title documents submitted by the accused were 
forged. In such circumstances, the allegation that false document has been submitted
is baseless.

##### **Non-fulfilment of contractual obligations only civil remedy is required**

25. Insofar as the allegation regarding non-fulfillment of contractual obligations
is concerned, recourse to appropriate civil remedy was required. Moreover, this 
is not a case where something emerged quickly after the agreement to indicate that
dishonest intention existed from the beginning. The JVA is [dated 16th August 2010 whereas the FIR was lodged](https://section1.in/quash-delay-in-lodging-fir-without-date-and-time-affects-the-case/)
in 2021. If there was something stark about the [dishonest intention on part](https://section1.in/cheating-taking-possession-of-the-truck-on-hire-and-failing-to-pay-hire-charges-for-months-together-while-making-false-promises-for-its-payment-shows-dishonest-intention-on-the-part-of-the-accused/)
of one of the parties to the agreement, it would have been reported promptly and
not after 10 years. This clearly indicates that the [dispute between the parties was purely of a civil](https://section1.in/summoning-order-magistrate-failed-to-see-the-criminal-colour-of-a-commercial-civil-dispute/)
nature.

26. No offence of cheating is made out because, as discussed above, there is no 
false representation in the JVA. As far as the allegation of false representation
about the title is concerned, there is nothing to indicate that what the appellants
had stated in the JVA was false. Further, there is no allegation that history of
title of the property/land narrated in the JVA contains any false statement. Moreover,
the JVA nowhere states that there is no litigation or dispute pending, rather it
speaks of indemnifying the complainant party in case of any loss on account of any
dispute. The statement in the JVA that there was no restraint order of any court
or Government department in respect of dealing with the land is not alleged or shown
to be false or incorrect.

27. As far as non-fulfillment of contractual obligations are concerned, recourse
can be had to civil remedies. On facts, recourse to [criminal proceedings](https://section1.in/initiation-of-criminal-proceeding-under-sections-138-141-n-i-act-is-covered-under-moratorium-provision-u-s-14-ibc/),
in our view, is nothing but abuse of the process of law/ court. More so, when there
is nothing to show that the accused had harbored a dishonest intention from inception.

##### **No criminal breach of trust offence made out**

28. There is no [criminal breach of trust](https://section1.in/subject-study-on-cheating-and-criminal-breach-of-trust/)
because the security amount was not refundable, rather it was adjustable against
the share of the first party derived from sale proceeds. Thus, in the event of breach
of any of the conditions of the agreement, the appropriate course was to take recourse
to civil remedies.

29. For the foregoing reasons, we are of the considered view that dispute between
the parties is essentially of a civil nature arising from the JVA. Further, a complete
reading of the FIR along with admitted documents, does not disclose commission of
offence of either [cheating or criminal breach](https://section1.in/s-c-on-cheating-breach-of-contract/)
of trust much less creation or using of a false document.

##### **FIR only discloses civil cause of action thus case quashed**

30. We are therefore of the considered view that the impugned first information 
report only discloses a civil cause of action. The High Court, unfortunately, did
not take pains to carefully read the FIR and consider the admitted documents including
the JVA to find out whether, [prima facie](https://section1.in/section-138-n-i-act-time-barred-debt-or-not-itself-a-prima-facie-for-evidence-and-cannot-invoke-section-482-cr-p-c-to-quash-the-same/),
cognizable offence was made out or not. The [appeal](https://section1.in/who-can-prefer-the-appeal-against-acquittal-in-the-case-initially-registered-by-state-police-later-transferred-to-cbi-investigation-is-left-open-to-decide-in-a-suitable-case/)
is, therefore, allowed. The judgment and [order of the High Court is set aside](https://section1.in/habeas-corpus-unexplained-delay-in-disposing-the-representation-made-by-the-detenu-is-sufficient-to-set-aside-the-order-of-detention/).
The impugned FIR and all [proceedings emanating therefrom are hereby quashed](https://section1.in/fraud-if-any-is-the-matter-for-trial-and-not-to-be-decided-in-quash-proceedings/).

#### **Resources**

**Judgments that are involved or cited**

 * Vandana Jain & Ors. v. The State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors. (2026 INSC 192): This
   is the primary judgment of the [Supreme Court](https://section1.in/burden-of-proof-public-prosecutor-while-explaining-the-principles-of-106-iea-in-criminal-cases-honble-supreme-court-has-addressed-the-government-to-appoint-skilled-lawyers-as-public-prosec/)
   of India that quashed the FIR and set aside the previous order of the High Court
   of Judicature at Allahabad.
 * High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, Misc. Bench No. 16314 of 2021: This is
   the impugned judgment dated July 30, 2021, which had originally [dismissed the appellants’ petition to quash](https://section1.in/bihari-migrant-ill-treatment-in-tamilnadu-case-quash-dismissed-since-the-alternative-remedy-is-available-u-s-482-cr-p-c/)
   the FIR.
 * Paramjeet Batra v. State of Uttarakhand and others, (2013) 11 SCC 673: Cited 
   by the [Supreme Court to support the principle](https://section1.in/supreme-court-overturns-high-courts-decision-in-mumbai-eviction-case-and-directed-to-proceed-with-the-principles-of-natural-justice/)
   that when an FIR’s cause is essentially civil in nature, the Court must assess
   if it has been given a “cloak of criminal offence” to ensure the process of law
   is not abused.

**[Acts and Sections](https://section1.in/pc-act-sections-7-131di-and-ii-presumption-can-also-be-drawn-for-smaller-bribe-amounts-further-accused-has-not-proved-that-rs-2000-bribe-amount-was-a-legal-fee-or-repayment-of-loan/)**

Indian Penal Code (IPC), 1860

 * Section 406: Relating to criminal breach of trust; the Court held this was not
   made out as the security money was adjustable, not refundable.
 * Section 420: Relating to [cheating and dishonestly inducing delivery of property](https://section1.in/supreme-court-quashes-fir-in-property-dispute-emphasizes-civil-in-nature-and-held-it-is-impossible-to-appreciate-how-appellant-deceived-the-respondent/).
 * Section 464: Defines the making of a “false document,” which is a prerequisite
   for forgery.
 * Section 467: Forgery of valuable security, will, etc..
 * Section 468: Forgery for the purpose of cheating.
 * Section 471: Using as genuine a forged document.

Other Statutory References

 * Arbitration Act: Referenced regarding Clause 7 of the JVA, which mandated that
   disputes be referred to arbitration rather than civil courts.
 * Indian [Registration Act](https://section1.in/quash-set-aside-prosecution-may-be-lodged-by-or-with-the-permission-of-the-sub-registrar-as-per-section-83-of-the-registration-act-1908/),
   Section 32: Cited in Clause 6.9 of the JVA regarding the right of the second 
   party to execute and register sale deeds.

#### **Party**

    ```wp-block-verse
    Vandana Jain & Ors. versus The State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors - Criminal Appeal No. 1127 of 2026 - 2026 INSC 192 - February 25, 2026 – Hon’ble Mr. Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, J. and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Manoj Misra, J.
    ```

### Further Study

 * [Quash: Normal rule is prosecution for defamation cannot be quashed on the ground that the offending allegations were withdrawn](https://section1.in/quash-normal-rule-is-prosecution-for-defamation-cannot-be-quashed-on-the-ground-that-the-offending-allegations-were-withdrawn/)
 * [Quash: Cheating: In order to constitute an offence of cheating, the intention to cheat must be available from the inception](https://section1.in/quash-cheating-in-order-to-constitute-an-offence-of-cheating-the-intention-to-cheat-must-be-available-from-the-inception/)
 * [Quash: Courts must be vigilant on identifying false complaints](https://section1.in/quash-courts-must-be-vigilant-on-identifying-false-complaints/)
 * [Quash: Alleged substance is not only drug so also food under the Food and safety act](https://section1.in/quash-alleged-substance-is-not-only-drug-so-also-food-under-the-food-and-safety-act/)
 * [QUASH: How to find out and appreciate the fir being registered with ulterior motive?](https://section1.in/quash-how-to-find-out-and-appreciate-the-fir-being-registered-with-ulterior-motive/)
