# Quash: When the amount was fully settled by way of compromise before DRT lodging a complaint before CBI for fraud and forgery is an abuse of process of law

- Link: https://section1.in/quash-when-the-amount-was-fully-settled-by-way-of-compromise-before-drt-lodging-a-complaint-before-cbi-for-fraud-and-forgery-is-an-abuse-of-process-of-law/
- Published: 2026-06-04T12:53:36+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Whether criminal prosecution for cheating will continue after settlement of loan by way of compromise in DRT?](https://section1.in/quash-when-the-amount-was-fully-settled-by-way-of-compromise-before-drt-lodging-a-complaint-before-cbi-for-fraud-and-forgery-is-an-abuse-of-process-of-law/#whether-criminal-prosecution-for-cheating-will-continue-after-settlement-of-loan-by-way-of-compromise-in-drt)
 * [Prefatory facts](https://section1.in/quash-when-the-amount-was-fully-settled-by-way-of-compromise-before-drt-lodging-a-complaint-before-cbi-for-fraud-and-forgery-is-an-abuse-of-process-of-law/#prefatory-facts)
    - [UCO Bank Zonal head registered FIR with the CBI that the appellants had got released two valuable properties mortgaged and substituted with an encroached property](https://section1.in/quash-when-the-amount-was-fully-settled-by-way-of-compromise-before-drt-lodging-a-complaint-before-cbi-for-fraud-and-forgery-is-an-abuse-of-process-of-law/#uco-bank-zonal-head-registered-fir-with-the-cbi-that-the-appellants-had-got-released-two-valuable-properties-mortgaged-and-substituted-with-an-encroached-property)
    - [Appellants have filed quash petition](https://section1.in/quash-when-the-amount-was-fully-settled-by-way-of-compromise-before-drt-lodging-a-complaint-before-cbi-for-fraud-and-forgery-is-an-abuse-of-process-of-law/#appellants-have-filed-quash-petition)
    - [High Court dismissed the quash petition](https://section1.in/quash-when-the-amount-was-fully-settled-by-way-of-compromise-before-drt-lodging-a-complaint-before-cbi-for-fraud-and-forgery-is-an-abuse-of-process-of-law/#high-court-dismissed-the-quash-petition)
 * [Summation of facts](https://section1.in/quash-when-the-amount-was-fully-settled-by-way-of-compromise-before-drt-lodging-a-complaint-before-cbi-for-fraud-and-forgery-is-an-abuse-of-process-of-law/#summation-of-facts)
 * [Analysis and reasoning](https://section1.in/quash-when-the-amount-was-fully-settled-by-way-of-compromise-before-drt-lodging-a-complaint-before-cbi-for-fraud-and-forgery-is-an-abuse-of-process-of-law/#analysis-and-reasoning)
    - [Cheating: What is meant by cheating? Explained](https://section1.in/quash-when-the-amount-was-fully-settled-by-way-of-compromise-before-drt-lodging-a-complaint-before-cbi-for-fraud-and-forgery-is-an-abuse-of-process-of-law/#cheating-what-is-meant-by-cheating-explained)
    - [Section 417 IPC explained](https://section1.in/quash-when-the-amount-was-fully-settled-by-way-of-compromise-before-drt-lodging-a-complaint-before-cbi-for-fraud-and-forgery-is-an-abuse-of-process-of-law/#section-417-ipc-explained)
    - [Judgments reference](https://section1.in/quash-when-the-amount-was-fully-settled-by-way-of-compromise-before-drt-lodging-a-complaint-before-cbi-for-fraud-and-forgery-is-an-abuse-of-process-of-law/#judgments-reference)
    - [Question](https://section1.in/quash-when-the-amount-was-fully-settled-by-way-of-compromise-before-drt-lodging-a-complaint-before-cbi-for-fraud-and-forgery-is-an-abuse-of-process-of-law/#question)
    - [Nikhil Merchant case](https://section1.in/quash-when-the-amount-was-fully-settled-by-way-of-compromise-before-drt-lodging-a-complaint-before-cbi-for-fraud-and-forgery-is-an-abuse-of-process-of-law/#nikhil-merchant-case)
    - [3 Judge bench held Nikhil Merchant case was decided correctly](https://section1.in/quash-when-the-amount-was-fully-settled-by-way-of-compromise-before-drt-lodging-a-complaint-before-cbi-for-fraud-and-forgery-is-an-abuse-of-process-of-law/#3-judge-bench-held-nikhil-merchant-case-was-decided-correctly)
    - [Compromise in Special Acts like P.C Act and Inherent powers](https://section1.in/quash-when-the-amount-was-fully-settled-by-way-of-compromise-before-drt-lodging-a-complaint-before-cbi-for-fraud-and-forgery-is-an-abuse-of-process-of-law/#compromise-in-special-acts-like-pc-act-and-inherent-powers)
    - [When the amount was fully settled by way of compromise before DRT lodging a complaint before CBI for fraud and forgery is an abuse of process of law](https://section1.in/quash-when-the-amount-was-fully-settled-by-way-of-compromise-before-drt-lodging-a-complaint-before-cbi-for-fraud-and-forgery-is-an-abuse-of-process-of-law/#when-the-amount-was-fully-settled-by-way-of-compromise-before-drt-lodging-a-complaint-before-cbi-for-fraud-and-forgery-is-an-abuse-of-process-of-law)
    - [Reason for quash explained](https://section1.in/quash-when-the-amount-was-fully-settled-by-way-of-compromise-before-drt-lodging-a-complaint-before-cbi-for-fraud-and-forgery-is-an-abuse-of-process-of-law/#reason-for-quash-explained)
 * [Conclusion](https://section1.in/quash-when-the-amount-was-fully-settled-by-way-of-compromise-before-drt-lodging-a-complaint-before-cbi-for-fraud-and-forgery-is-an-abuse-of-process-of-law/#conclusion)
 * [Resources](https://section1.in/quash-when-the-amount-was-fully-settled-by-way-of-compromise-before-drt-lodging-a-complaint-before-cbi-for-fraud-and-forgery-is-an-abuse-of-process-of-law/#resources)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/quash-when-the-amount-was-fully-settled-by-way-of-compromise-before-drt-lodging-a-complaint-before-cbi-for-fraud-and-forgery-is-an-abuse-of-process-of-law/#party)

#### **Whether criminal prosecution for cheating will continue after settlement of loan by way of compromise in DRT?**

2. A short but interesting question which arises for consideration in this appeal
is whether a criminal prosecution can be initiated under Sections 420 and 471 of
the Indian Penal Code, 1860 and allowed to continue after settlement of the loan
account by way of an approved compromise and which had the imprimatur of the Debts
Recovery Tribunal?

3. The above question arises in the context of a challenge by the appellants to 
the order dated 05.07.2024 passed by the High Court of Chhattisgarh (‘High Court’)
in Cr.M.P. No. 1361 of 2023 (Vijay Kumar Kela & Anr. Vs. CBI & Anr.).

#### **Prefatory facts**

4. For proper adjudication of the question framed, it would be appropriate to briefly
narrate the relevant facts.

4.1. Appellant No. 2 was established as a proprietary trading concern in the year
1998 dealing in agricultural inputs like fertilizers and other allied products. 
Elder brother of appellant No. 1 late Parmanand Kela had established appellant No.
2 firm and was managing the affairs of the said firm. Following the death of late
Parmanand Kela, appellant No. 1 became the sole proprietor of the firm.

4.2. Erstwhile proprietor Parmanand Kela had applied to the UCO Bank on 28.07.2006
for extending cash credit facility of fund based limit to the extent of Rs. 50 Lakhs
and non-fund based limit i.e. letter of credit to the extent of Rs. 1 crore in the
name of appellant No. 2. After examining the proposal and on due consideration, 
cash credit facility of fund based limit to the extent of Rs. 50 lakhs and non-fund
based limit i.e. letter of credit to the extent of Rs. 1 crore was extended by the
UCO Bank to appellant No. 2 on 02.09.2006 on proper security, both primary and collateral.
Subsequently, on application by the appellants, the credit facility was enhanced
to Rs. 5 crores for which additional property was given by way of mortgage. Finally,
on 30.01.2009, credit facility was extended to Rs. 8 crores (Rs. 3 crores for cash
credit and Rs. 5 crores for letter of credit limit) for which the mortgaged properties
were substituted by another property having higher valuation.

4.3. Parmanand Kela passed away on 28.11.2009. At that stage, appellant No. 1 stepped
into the shoes of his late brother and started looking after the affairs of appellant
No. 2. Appellant No. 1 informed the UCO Bank that the firm was unable to procure
big orders as a result of which it was facing financial crunch. Because of financial
constraints, repayment of loan amounts became irregular, following which the loan
account of the appellant No. 2 was declared as a Non-Performing Asset (NPA).

4.4. UCO Bank invoked provisions of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial
Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (‘SARFAESI Act’, hereinafter)
against the appellants and issued notice dated 05.02.2011 under Section 13(2) of
the SARFAESI Act to the appellants.

4.5. At that stage, a compromise proposal was worked out between the two parties
on 14.03.2015 which was recommended by the UCO Bank, Raipur Main Branch for sanctioning
by the competent authority of the said Bank. Vide letter dated 30.03.2015, the competent
authority informed the UCO Bank, Raipur Main Branch that the compromise proposal
was approved and in this connection, a sanction letter was also issued for doing
the needful. The settlement amount was Rs. 4.25 crores against the outstanding dues
of Rs. 6.49 crores as on 14.03.2015, which included notional interest of Rs. 3.09
crores.

5. It may be mentioned that UCO Bank had filed Original Application No. 355/2011
before the Debts Recovery Tribunal at Jabalpur (DRT) for realization of the loan
amount from the appellants with interest etc. In the said proceedings, a joint application
was filed by the UCO Bank and the appellants for recording compromise. Vide the 
order dated 10.07.2015, DRT recorded the details of the compromise reached between
the parties and fixed 07.10.2015 for submitting compliance with regard to the compromise
settlement.

5.1. Following the same, appellants paid the settlement amount to the UCO Bank pursuant
to which the latter issued no dues certificate dated 30.09.2015 certifying that 
the cash credit account of appellant No. 2 was settled pursuant to a compromise 
and that payment was received in terms of the approved compromise.

5.2. By order dated 27.10.2015, DRT dismissed OA No. 355/2011 as withdrawn in view
of the fact that the entire compromise amount had been deposited by the appellants
which was acknowledged in the application dated 27.10.2015 filed by the UCO bank
before the DRT.

##### **UCO Bank Zonal head registered FIR with the CBI that the appellants had got released two valuable properties mortgaged and substituted with an encroached property**

6. After more than 2 years, on 27.02.2018, the Zonal Head of UCO Bank, Raipur Zonal
Office submitted a written complaint to the Superintendent of Police, Central Bureau
of  Investigation (CBI), New Delhi stating that appellants, more particularly appellant
No. 1, in collusion with certain officials of the Bank had defrauded the UCO Bank
by diverting the funds of the Bank made available to the appellant firm to the account
of appellant No. 1. It was further alleged that by entering into the settlement,
appellants had got released two valuable properties mortgaged with the UCO Bank 
and substituted the above properties with an encroached property. It was submitted
that the borrowers with the dishonest intention of causing wrongful loss to the 
Bank and wrongful gain to themselves fraudulently committed the act of cheating 
and thus committed offences of cheating, criminal breach of trust etc. under the
Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC). The Superintendent of Police, CBI was requested to
register an FIR, investigate the matter and thereafter to initiate appropriate criminal
proceedings against the offenders.

7. On the basis of the aforesaid complaint, the first respondent i.e. CBI registered
FIR bearing No. RC2202018E0002 dated 08.03.2018 under Section 120B read with Section
420 IPC and Section 13(2) read with Section 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption
Act, 1988 (PC Act).

8. Thereafter, CBI filed chargesheet on 27.11.2018 before the Court of Special Judicial
Magistrate, CBI Cases, Raipur (‘Special Judicial Magistrate’ for short). In the 
chargesheet, it is stated that investigation revealed that on the basis of forged
audit reports submitted by appellant No. 1, appellant No. 2 was able to get a renewal/
enhancement of cash credit limit of more than two times of the original amount sanctioned.
He had forged audit reports as genuine with the intention to cheat the UCO Bank.
In the process, UCO Bank suffered wrongful loss of Rs. 223.7 lakhs and unapplied
interest of Rs. 308.8 lakhs and correspondingly there was wrongful gain of the said
amount for appellant No. 1. Thus, he had committed the offences of cheating and 
using of forged documents as genuine ones which are punishable under Sections 420
and 471 IPC. It was further stated that the investigation did not disclose any proactive
role played by Bank officials in respect of sanction or renewal/enhancement of the
cash credit limit. Therefore, none of the Bank officials were charge sheeted. Consequently,
the charges under the PC Act were dropped.

8.1. Vide order dated 20.02.2023, the learned Special Judicial Magistrate framed
charges under Sections 420 and 471 IPC against appellant No. 1.

##### **Appellants have filed quash petition**

9. Appellants filed a petition under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973 (CrPC) before the High Court for quashing of the chargesheet dated 27.11.2018
as well as the order passed by the Special Judicial Magistrate dated 20.02.2023 
whereby charges have been framed. The quashing petition was registered as Criminal
MP No. 1361 of 2023. The said petition was contested by the respondents.

##### **High Court dismissed the quash petition**

9.1. By the impugned order dated 05.07.2024, the High Court dismissed the criminal
petition prima facie observing that appellants with a fraudulent intention got released
two valuable properties which were mortgaged with the Bank by substituting it with
encroached property and had also enhanced the credit limit by submitting forged 
audit reports which was issued by the chartered accountant.

10. Assailing the aforesaid impugned order dated 05.07.2024, the instant special
leave petition came to be filed by the appellants. On 13.12.2024, notice was issued.

#### **Summation of facts**

15.13. Almost after two and a half years of the DRT putting its imprimatur on the
compromise vide the order dated 27.10.2015, the Zonal Head of UCO Bank, Raipur Zonal
Office submitted a written complaint dated 27.02.2018 to the CBI with the request
to lodge FIR against the appellants. In the written complaint, after mentioning 
about the compromise settlement entered into between the parties, it was stated 
that the UCO Bank had declared the account of appellant No. 2 as ‘fraud’ and the
same was reported to RBI on 18.04.2016. It was mentioned that the element of fraud
was first suspected on 20.12.2013 but the same was not discernible beyond doubt.
The account was not treated as fraud before accepting the compromise proposal. UCO
Bank took the commercial decision for accepting the compromise proposal for reducing
any further loss to the Bank. There was specific mention in the complaint about 
two Bank officials viz. Shri C. Ramakrishna, the then Assistant General Manager 
and Shri A.K. Pattanaik, the then Senior Manager for accepting substitution of property
without proper valuation and for observing that the substituted property was marketable.
It was alleged that the appellants with the dishonest intention of causing wrongful
loss to the Bank and corresponding wrongful gain to themselves fraudulently committed
the act of cheating by substituting valuable properties offered as security with
an encroached property and by siphoning of the Bank’s money; thus, committing the
offence of cheating, criminal breach of trust, etc. under the IPC.

15.14. Upon registration of the FIR, CBI investigated the matter and thereafter 
submitted chargesheet before the Special Judicial Magistrate on 27.11.2018. **As
per the chargesheet, on the basis of forged copies of audit report appellants got
enhancement of cash credit limit more than two times of the original amount. In 
the process, the UCO Bank was cheated resulting in wrongful loss of Rs. 223.74 lakhs
with notional interest of Rs. 308.80 lakhs. Thus, appellant No. 1 had committed 
the offence of cheating and using of forged documents as genuine ones which are 
punishable under Sections 420 and 471 IPC**. Insofar Bank officials are concerned,
the chargesheet stated that investigation did not disclose any proactive role played
by Bank officials in respect of sanction or renewal or enhancement of the cash credit
limit; no criminal misconduct was found to have been committed by any of the Bank
officials in this regard.

15.15. Vide order dated 20.02.2023, Special Judicial Magistrate framed charges against
appellant No. 1 under Sections 420 and 471 IPC.

#### **Analysis and reasoning**

##### **Cheating**: **What is meant by cheating? Explained**

16. It can be seen from the above that charges have been framed only against appellant
No. 1 under Sections 420 and 471 IPC. None of the Bank officials have been charge
sheeted and, therefore, there is no prosecution under the PC Act. Substratum of 
Section 420 IPC is cheating and dishonest inducement leading to delivery of property.**
Cheating is defined under Section 415 IPC which says that whoever by deceiving any
person, fraudulently or dishonestly induces the person so deceived to deliver any
property to any person, etc. which causes or is likely to cause damage or harm to
that person in body, mind, reputation or property, is said to ‘cheat’**. Cheating
is only one of the ingredients of Section 420, the other being dishonest inducement
leading to delivery of property. ‘Dishonesty’ is defined in Section 24 IPC to mean
deliberate intention to cause wrongful gain or wrongful loss to one person. When
with such intention, deception is practiced and delivery of property is induced 
thereby then the offence under Section 420 of the IPC can be said to have been committed.

##### **Section 417 IPC explained**

16.1. Section 471 IPC on the other hand provides that whoever fraudulently or dishonestly
uses as genuine any document or electronic record which he knows or has reason to
believe to be a forged document or electronic record, shall be punished in the same
manner as if he had forged such document or electronic record.

##### **Judgments reference**

16.2. This Court in Mohammed Ibrahim Vs. State of Bihar explained that to constitute
an offence under Section 471 IPC, the requirement is that the document should be
made or executed dishonestly or fraudulently with the intention of causing it to
be believed that such document was made or executed by, or by the authority of a
person, by whom or by whose authority he knows that it was not made or executed.

16.3. Again, in Deepak Gaba Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh, this Court examined the 
ingredients of Sections 420 and 471 IPC and observed that in order to apply Section
420 IPC viz. cheating and dishonestly inducing delivery of property, the ingredients
of Section 415 IPC have to be satisfied. To constitute an offence of cheating under
Section 415 IPC, a person should be induced, either fraudulently or dishonestly,
to deliver any property to any person, or consent that any person, shall retain 
any property; the second class of acts set forth in the section is the intentional
inducement of doing or omitting to do anything which the person deceived would not
do or omit to do, if she were not so deceived. Thus, the sine qua non of Section
415 IPC is fraudulence, dishonesty or intentional inducement, and the absence of
these elements would debase the offence of cheating. Referring to Mohammed Ibrahim,
the Bench observed that for the offence under Section 420 IPC, there should not 
only be cheating but as a consequence of such cheating, the accused should also 
have dishonestly induced the person deceived to deliver any property to a person
etc. Insofar as Section 471 IPC is concerned, the Bench again referred to Mohammed
Ibrahim and observed that Section 471 IPC would be applicable when a person fraudulently
or dishonestly uses as genuine any document or electronic record which he knows 
or has reasons to believe to be a forged document or electronic record. Unless the
document is false and forged in terms of Section 464 IPC (making a false document)
and 470 IPC (forged document or electronic record), the requirement of Section 471
IPC would not be met.

16.4. It may be mentioned that while Section 420 IPC is compoundable under Section
320 CrPC, Section 471 is not compoundable.

##### **Question**

17. The question is, whether, in a case of this nature, the offences under Sections
420 and 471 IPC can be said to have been made out against the appellants when the
subject transaction was a banking one which ultimately led to a compromise settlement
approved by the competent authority of the Bank and which had the imprimatur of 
the DRT. However, this issue need not detain us since we are focusing on the larger
question of permissibility of continuance of criminal prosecution which was set 
in motion after settlement of the loan account on compromise between the borrower(
appellants) and the Bank and which had the endorsement of the DRT.

##### **Nikhil Merchant case**

18. In Nikhil Merchant vs. Central Bureau of Investigation, CBI filed charges against
the accused persons under Section 120B read with Sections 420, 467, 468 and 471 
IPC read with Sections 5 (2) and 5 (1) (d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 
1947 and Section 13 (2) read with Section 13 (1) (d) of the PC Act. One of the accused
was the company whereas another one was Managing Director of the company. The other
three accused were officials of Andhra Bank. Accused company had availed financial
assistance from Andhra Bank but defaulted in repayment. Andhra Bank filed a suit
for recovery and also lodged a complaint before the CBI which led to registration
of FIR and filing of chargesheet in the Court of the Special Judge. The gist of 
the allegations against the accused persons was that they had conspired with each
other in fraudulently diverting the funds of Andhra Bank; besides, offences alleging
forgery were also included in the chargesheet.

19. The correctness of the view taken in Nikhil Merchant and two other cases was
doubted by a subsequent coordinate Bench whereafter the matter was referred to a
larger Bench. In Gian Singh Vs. State of Punjab4, the appellant was convicted under
Sections 420 and 120B IPC. During pendency of the appeal against his conviction,
appellant filed an application for compounding the offence. Thereafter, appellant
also filed a petition under Section 482 CrPC for quashing of the FIR on the ground
of compounding the offence. The petition under Section 482 CrPC was dismissed by
the High Court.

##### **3 Judge bench held Nikhil Merchant case was decided correctly**

19.1. A three-Judge Bench of this Court considered the question as to whether the
inherent power of the High Court to quash criminal proceedings against an offender
who had settled his dispute with the victim of the crime but the crime is not compoundable
under Section 320 CrPC should be invoked or not. After delineating the amplitude
of the power under Section 482 CrPC and after discussing various case laws, the 
larger Bench held that the power of the High Court in quashing a criminal proceeding
or FIR or complaint in exercise of its inherent jurisdiction under Section 482 CrPC
is distinct and different from the power given to a criminal court for compounding
the offence under Section 320 CrPC. Inherent power is of wide plenitude with no 
statutory limitation but it has to be exercised in accord with the guidelines engrafted
in such power viz. (i) to secure the ends of justice or (ii) to prevent abuse of
the process of any court. In what cases power to quash the criminal proceeding or
complaint or FIR may be exercised where the offender and the victim have settled
their dispute would depend on the facts and circumstances of each case and no category
can be prescribed but before exercise of such power, the High Court must have due
regard to the nature and gravity of the crime. Heinous and serious offences of mental
depravity or offences like murder, rape, dacoity, etc. cannot be fittingly quashed
even though the victim or victim’s family and the offender have settled the dispute.
Similarly, any compromise between the victim and the offender in relation to offences
under special statutes like the PC Act or offences committed by public servants 
while working in that capacity cannot provide for any basis for quashing criminal
proceedings involving such offences. However, criminal cases having overwhelmingly
and predominantly civil flavour stand on a different footing for the purposes of
quashing, particularly the offences arising from commercial, financial, mercantile,
civil, partnership or such like transactions or for that matter matrimonial disputes.
In such category of cases, the High Court may quash the criminal proceedings if 
in its view because of the compromise between the offender and the victim, the possibility
of conviction is remote and bleak and, therefore, continuation of the criminal case
would put the accused to great oppression and prejudice and extreme injustice would
be caused by not quashing the criminal case despite full and complete settlement
and compromise with the victim. **On that basis, the Bench held that Nikhil Merchant
and the other two cases were correctly decided.**

##### **Compromise in Special Acts like P.C Act and Inherent powers**

    ```wp-block-verse
    20. In Narinder Singh Vs. State of Punjab, the appellant faced charges amongst others under Section 307 of the IPC. A compromise was arrived at between the appellant and the complainant pursuant to which the appellant had moved the High Court under Section 482 CrPC for quashing of the FIR. High Court refused to do so on the ground that one of the four injuries suffered by the complainant was serious in nature as per medical opinion. This Court held that offences under Section 307 IPC would fall in the category of heinous and serious offences; therefore, such offences are to be generally treated as crime against the society and not against the individual alone. Such cases should not ordinarily be quashed. The Bench reiterated what was held in Gian Singh and held that those criminal cases having overwhelmingly and predominantly civil character, particularly those arising out of commercial transactions or arising out of matrimonial relationships or family disputes should be quashed when the parties have resolved their entire disputes amongst themselves. However, offences alleged to have been committed under special statutes like the PC Act should not be quashed merely on the basis of compromise between the victim and the offender. Finally, this Court held that while deciding whether to exercise its power under Section 482 CrPC, timing of settlement plays a crucial role. Those cases where settlement is arrived at immediately after the alleged commission of offence and the matter is still under investigation, the High Court may be liberal in accepting the settlement to quash the criminal proceedings.
    ```

21. Parbatbhai Aahir alias Parbatbhai Bhimsinhbhai Karmur Vs. State of Gujarat6 
is a case where the High Court dismissed an application filed by the accused persons
seeking quashing of FIR which was registered under Sections 384, 467, 468, 471, 
120B and 506 (2) IPC. This Court after examining the precedents summarized and culled
out the broad principles in the following manner:

“16.1 to 16.10”

21.1. Thus, this Court, while setting out the broad principles, held that the power
to quash under Section 482 CrPC is separate and distinct from the power to compound
under Section 320 CrPC and can be invoked even if the offence is non-compoundable.

    ```wp-block-verse
    22. This Court in Anil Bhavarlal Jain Vs. State of Maharashtra was examining an order passed by the High Court dismissing the petition filed by the appellants under Section 482 CrPC for quashing the FIR and the consequential chargesheet. In addition to IPC offences, the appellants were charged under Section 13(2) read with 13(1)(d) of the PC Act. In that case, some of the accused i.e. the appellants in the connected appeal were employees of the concerned Bank i.e. State Bank of India. The appellants had obtained a loan from the State Bank of India but failed to repay the same for which the loan account was declared as NPA. For recovery of the outstanding dues, State Bank of India approached the DRT where the matter was disposed of on consent terms. Thereafter, the Bank lodged a complaint before the CBI pursuant to which the FIR was registered whereafter chargesheets were filed. Appellants sought for quashing of the FIR and the chargesheet and filed a writ petition before the High Court under Section 482 CrPC. However, High Court dismissed the said writ petition observing that the appellant had a substantive alternative remedy under the provisions of the CrPC. Posing the question as to whether the criminal proceedings should be quashed based upon a settlement arrived at between the parties as per the consent terms drawn and submitted before the DRT, a two-Judge Bench of this Court observed that in view of the fact that a special statute i.e. the PC Act had been invoked, quashing of offences under the said Act would not be justified.
    ```

Bharthi Devi case:

23. In K. Bharthi Devi Vs. State of Telangana, the accused persons were granted 
various credit facilities by the Indian Bank which were secured by collateral security.
As the accused persons failed to repay the dues, the loan account was declared as
NPA and to realize the outstanding dues Indian Bank filed an original application
before the DRT. During pendency of the proceedings before the DRT, Indian Bank lodged
a written complaint before the CBI alleging that some of the title documents executed
by the accused persons by virtue of which equitable mortgage was created were not
original documents, rather those were fake, forged and fabricated. CBI registered
an FIR whereafter chargesheet was filed stating that offences punishable under Sections
120B read with Section 420, 409, 467, 468 and 471 IPC and Sections 13 (1) (d) and
13 (2) of the PC Act were committed.

23.1. At that stage, the accused persons approached the Indian Bank for settlement.
After negotiations, the parties arrived at a settlement whereafter the settlement
amount was paid by the accused persons following which the Indian Bank issued no
dues certificate to the borrowers (accused persons). DRT recorded that the dispute
was settled in full satisfaction of the dues of the respondent-Indian Bank.

23.2. Thereafter, the accused persons filed a criminal petition before the High 
Court under Section 482 CrPC seeking quashing of the chargesheet. The High Court,
however, rejected the said petition holding that the settlement arrived at was only
a private settlement and was not a part of any decree given by any court. The charges
include the use of fraudulent, fake and forged documents that were used to embezzle
public money; if the charges were proved, those would be grave crimes against the
society as a whole and hence merely due to a private settlement between the Bank
and the accused, it cannot be said that prosecution of the accused persons would
amount to abuse of the process of the court.

    ```wp-block-verse
    23.3. A two-Judge Bench of this Court referred to the previous decisions of this Court including Nikhil Merchant, Gian Singh, Narinder Singh, etc. and held that criminal cases having overwhelmingly and predominantly civil character, particularly those arising out of commercial transactions or arising out of matrimonial relationships or family disputes should be quashed when the parties have resolved their entire disputes among themselves. The Bench observed that the dispute involved in the said case had predominantly overtures of a civil dispute. After the settlement, the Bank had also closed the loan account. That apart, the Bench noted that in view of the settlement between the parties in a proceeding before the DRT, the possibility of conviction is remote and bleak. In such a case, continuation of the criminal proceedings would put the accused to great oppression and prejudice. Holding that it was a fit case where the High Court ought to have exercised its jurisdiction under Section 482 CrPC and ought to have quashed the criminal proceedings, the Bench allowed the appeal, set aside the order of the High Court and quashed the criminal proceedings.
    ```

##### **When the amount was fully settled by way of compromise before DRT lodging a complaint before CBI for fraud and forgery is an abuse of process of law**

24. Applying the above principles to the facts of the present case, we find that
in the pending proceedings before the DRT instituted by the second respondent-Bank,
a negotiated compromise was arrived at between the parties. The settlement was approved
by the competent authority of the respondent-Bank. Joint application was filed before
the DRT by appellant No. 1 and respondent No. 2-Bank to place on record the settlement
which was noted by the DRT and adjourned to a subsequent date to ensure compliance.
Following the same, appellants paid the entire settlement amount whereafter the 
Bank issued no dues certificate to the appellants. Thereafter, on a further application
by the respondent-Bank, the original application was dismissed as withdrawn by the
DRT after noting that the claim to the outstanding dues were settled as per the 
compromise and the settlement amount was paid by the appellants whereafter no dues
certificate was issued by the Bank. When the matter was fully settled which was 
endorsed by the DRT, the respondent-Bank after more than two years lodged complaint
before the CBI to initiate criminal prosecution alleging fraud and forgery by the
appellants. In the facts and circumstances, we are of the view that the present 
case is squarely covered by the decision of this Court in K. Bharthi Devi.

26. We are afraid, such conduct of the respondent Bank betrays lack of good faith.
If the Bank had suspected fraud in 2013 itself, it should have lodged complaint 
at that stage itself. However, such stand of the Bank that fraud was committed by
appellant No. 1 is not supported by the contents of the compromise settlement itself.
We have already noted that in clause 9.1.9 of the compromise settlement, it was 
clearly mentioned by the Bank that there were no lapses in documentation or any 
irregularity was observed in the cash credit proposal of the appellants as per legal
audit dated 12.02.2009. Additionally, the Bank certified in clause 25 that the compromise
amount was in terms of the RBI policy guidelines and that it was not lower than 
the distress sale value of the securities available. After entering into a compromise
settlement with the appellants wherein it was clearly stated that there was no tampering
of any of the documents and after filing joint application before the DRT to record
the compromise settlement, it was not proper on the part of the respondent-Bank 
to belatedly initiate criminal proceedings against the appellants, that too, after
withdrawing the proceedings from the DRT on execution of the compromise settlement
leading to closure of the loan account. Such a criminal proceeding in our view would
not only be oppressive qua the appellants but would also amount to an abuse of the
process of the court.

##### **Reason for quash explained**

28. There is one more reason why we say so. If the respondent-Bank is permitted 
to go ahead with the criminal prosecution initiated after settlement of the loan
account before the DRT, it would adversely impact the sanctity of such settlement
which has become part of the judicial proceeding and which had the approval of a
judicial forum like the DRT. If such a conduct is overlooked and prosecution is 
allowed to continue, many persons including commercial entities would be hesitant
to come forward and seek resolution of their disputes arising out of banking transactions
which are after all commercial transactions, having predominantly elements of civil
dispute(s). This in turn would have a debilitating effect on the overall economy,
more so, when the focus is on settlement of commercial disputes. This is the larger
picture we need to keep in mind.

#### **Conclusion**

29. For the aforementioned reasons, we allow this appeal and set aside the impugned
order of the High Court dated 05.07.2024. Consequently, chargesheet dated 27.11.2018
and the charge framing order of the Special Judicial Magistrate dated 20.02.2023
are hereby quashed.

#### **Resources**

**Judgments references**

1. Mohammed Ibrahim Vs. State of Bihar

 * Citation: (2009) 8 SCC 751
 * Brief: Clarifies the essential ingredients required to constitute an offence 
   under Section 471 of the IPC (using a forged document as genuine). The court 
   noted that the document must be executed dishonestly or fraudulently with the
   specific intention of deceiving someone into believing it was made by an authority
   that did not actually authorize it.

2. Deepak Gaba Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh

 * Citation: (2023) 3 SCC 423
 * Brief: Examines the intersection of Sections 415, 420, and 471 of the IPC. It
   establishes that fraudulence, dishonesty, or intentional inducement are the _sine
   qua non_ (essential conditions) for the offence of cheating, and that a charge
   under Section 471 fails unless the underlying document is proven to be false 
   or forged under Sections 464 and 470 IPC.

3. Nikhil Merchant Vs. Central Bureau of Investigation

 * Citation: (2008) 9 SCC 677
 * Brief: A foundational case where the Supreme Court held that technicalities should
   not prevent the quashing of criminal proceedings (even those involving non-compoundable
   offenses like forgery) if the dispute has overwhelming civil or commercial overtones
   and has been fully settled via a compromise between the borrower and the bank.

4. Gian Singh Vs. State of Punjab

 * Citation: (2012) 10 SCC 303
 * Brief: A landmark three-judge bench judgment clarifying that the High Court’s
   inherent power to quash under Section 482 CrPC is distinct from a trial court’s
   power to compound under Section 320 CrPC. It ruled that while heinous or statutory
   crimes (like the PC Act) cannot be quashed, commercial, financial, or matrimonial
   disputes with a predominantly civil flavour can be quashed if a settlement renders
   the chance of conviction bleak.

5. Narinder Singh Vs. State of Punjab

 * Citation: (2014) 6 SCC 466
 * Brief: Reaffirmed the principles of _Gian Singh_, distinguishing serious crimes
   against society (like Section 307 IPC) from commercial or family transactions.
   It also emphasized that the timing of the settlement plays a crucial role in 
   deciding whether the court should exercise its quashing powers.

6. Parbatbhai Aahir alias Parbatbhai Bhimsinhbhai Karmur Vs. State of Gujarat

 * Citation: (2017) 9 SCC 641
 * Brief: Summarizes and structures the broad legal principles governing the invocation
   of Section 482 CrPC based on settlements. It carves out a strict exception for
   economic offenses involving financial fraud or misdemeanors that hurt the State’s
   economic well-being, stating that such cases should not be easily quashed.

7. Anil Bhavarlal Jain Vs. State of Maharashtra

 * Citation: 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3823
 * Brief: Held that quashing a criminal case purely on the basis of consent terms
   drawn before the Debts Recovery Tribunal (DRT) is not justified if bank employees
   are charged under a special statute like the Prevention of Corruption Act (PC
   Act).

8. K. Bharthi Devi Vs. State of Telangana

 * Citation: (2024) 10 SCC 384
 * Brief: Dealt with a similar factual matrix where bank borrowers used allegedly
   fake title deeds to secure credit. The Supreme Court quashed the criminal case
   under Section 482 CrPC because a full settlement was later reached before the
   DRT, the loan account was closed, and the underlying nature of the dispute was
   overwhelmingly commercial and civil.

**Acts and the Sections**

Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC)

 * Section 24: Definition of ‘Dishonesty’.
 * Section 120B: Criminal conspiracy.
 * Section 307: Attempt to murder.
 * Section 409: Criminal breach of trust by a public servant, banker, etc..
 * Section 415: Definition of ‘Cheating’.
 * Section 420: Cheating and dishonestly inducing delivery of property.
 * Section 464: Making a false document.
 * Section 467: Forgery of valuable security, will, etc..
 * Section 468: Forgery for purpose of cheating.
 * Section 470: Forged document or electronic record.
 * Section 471: Using as genuine a forged document or electronic record.
 * Section 506(2): Criminal intimidation.

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC)

 * Section 320: Compounding of offences.
 * Section 482: Saving of inherent powers of the High Court to quash proceedings.

Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 & 1947 (PC Act)

 * Section 13(1)(d) (1988 Act): Criminal misconduct by a public servant.
 * Section 13(2) (1988 Act): Punishment for criminal misconduct.
 * Section 5(1)(d) & 5(2) (1947 Act): Historical equivalents for criminal misconduct
   mentioned in cited case law.

Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security
Interest Act, 2002 (SARFAESI Act)

 * Section 13(2): Notice to borrower for enforcement of security interest.

Delhi Special Police Establishment Act, 1946

 * Section 6: Consent of the State Government for the CBI to exercise powers and
   jurisdiction.

#### **Party**

    ```wp-block-verse
    Vijay Kumar Kela & Anr. versus Central Bureau of Investigation & Anr - Criminal Appeal No. 2974 of 2026 - 2026 INSC 588 - May 29, 2026 – Hon’ble Mr. Justice B.V. Nagarathna and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ujjal Bhuyan.
    ```

[Vijay Kumar Kela vs. CBI 544732024_2026-05-29](https://section1.in/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Vijay-Kumar-Kela-vs.-CBI-544732024_2026-05-29.pdf)
[Download](https://section1.in/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Vijay-Kumar-Kela-vs.-CBI-544732024_2026-05-29.pdf)

### Further Study

 * [Quash: Cheating: In order to constitute an offence of cheating, the intention to cheat must be available from the inception](https://section1.in/quash-cheating-in-order-to-constitute-an-offence-of-cheating-the-intention-to-cheat-must-be-available-from-the-inception/)
 * [Quash: Alleged substance is not only drug so also food under the Food and safety act](https://section1.in/quash-alleged-substance-is-not-only-drug-so-also-food-under-the-food-and-safety-act/)
 * [QUASH: How to find out and appreciate the fir being registered with ulterior motive?](https://section1.in/quash-how-to-find-out-and-appreciate-the-fir-being-registered-with-ulterior-motive/)
 * [POCSO Case: Petition for compromise quash filed by the victim herself stating she wants to marry some other person: Madras High Court after enquiry dismissed the petition on impression that the petitioner was not filed the petition voluntarily](https://section1.in/pocso-case-petition-for-compromise-quash-filed-by-the-victim-herself-stating-she-wants-to-marry-some-other-person-madras-high-court-after-enquiry-dismissed-the-petition-on-impression-that-the-pe/)
 * [Quash: Apex Court quashed the G.O of TamilNadu constituting special courts for Land Grabbing cases and advice to enact appropriate legislation](https://section1.in/s-c-quashed-g-o-of-tamilnadu-for-anti-land-grabbing-cell-and-adviced-to-enact-appropriate-legislation-for-land-grabbing-cases/)
