# Section 277 Cr.P.C: Recording of witnesses has to be in their own language only

- Link: https://section1.in/recording-of-witnesses-has-to-be-in-their-own-language-only-section-277-cr-p-c-explained/
- Published: 2023-01-31T08:08:20+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Section 276 Cr.P.C](https://section1.in/recording-of-witnesses-has-to-be-in-their-own-language-only-section-277-cr-p-c-explained/#section-276-crpc)
 * [Section 277 Cr.P.C](https://section1.in/recording-of-witnesses-has-to-be-in-their-own-language-only-section-277-cr-p-c-explained/#section-277-crpc)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/recording-of-witnesses-has-to-be-in-their-own-language-only-section-277-cr-p-c-explained/#party)

##### **Section 276 Cr.P.C**

23. At this juncture, it may be noted that during the course of hearing it was brought
to the notice of the Court that the deposition of the prosecutrix was recorded by
the trial court in English language though she had deposed in her vernacular language.
In this regard, a reference of Section 276 and Section 277 of Cr.P.C. needs to be
made, which reads as under: –

> “S. 276 (1) In all trials before a Court of Session, the evidence of each witness
> shall, as his examination proceeds, be taken down in writing either by the presiding
> Judge himself or by his dictation in open Court or, under his direction and superintendence,
> by an officer of the Court appointed by him in this behalf.
> (2) Such evidence shall ordinarily be taken down in the form of a narrative, but
> the presiding Judge may, in his discretion, take down, or cause to be taken down,
> any part of such evidence in the form of question and answer.
> (3) The evidence so taken down shall be signed by the presiding Judge and shall
> form part of the record.

S. 277. Language of record of evidence. In every case where evidence is taken down
under section 275 or section 276, –

> (a) if the witness gives evidence in the language of the Court, it shall be taken
> down in that language;
> (b) if he gives evidence in any other language, it may, if practicable, be taken
> down in that language, and if it is not practicable to do so, a true translation
> of the evidence in the language of the Court shall be prepared as the examination
> of the witness proceeds, signed by the Magistrate or presiding Judge, and shall
> form part of the record;
> (c) where under clause (b) evidence is taken down in a language other than the
> language of the Court, a true translation thereof in the language of the Court
> shall be prepared as soon as practicable, signed by the Magistrate or presiding
> Judge, and shall form part of the record: Provided that when under clause (b) 
> evidence is taken down in English and a translation thereof in the language of
> the Court is not required by any of the parties, the Court may dispense with such
> translation”.

##### **Section 277 Cr.P.C**

24. We are apprised that in some of the trial courts the depositions of the witnesses
are not being recorded in their language and are being recorded in English language
only, as may be translated by the Presiding officer. In our opinion, the evidence
of the witness has to be taken down in the language of the court as required under
Section 277 Cr.P.C. If the witness gives evidence in the language of the court, 
it has to be taken down in that language only. If the witness gives evidence in 
any other language, it may, if practicable, be taken down in that language, and 
if it is not practicable to do so, a true translation of the evidence in the language
of the court may be prepared. It is only when the witness gives evidence in English
and is taken down as such, and a translation thereof in the language of the court
is not required by any of the parties, then the court may dispense with such translation.
If the witness gives evidence in the language other than the language of the court,
a true translation thereof in the language of the court has to be prepared as soon
as practicable.

25. The evidence of the witness has to be recorded in the language of the court 
or in the language of the witness as may be practicable and then get it translated
in the language of the court for forming part of the record. However, recording 
of evidence of the witness in the translated form in English language only, though
the witness gives evidence in the language of the court, or in his/her own vernacular
language, is not permissible. As such, the text and tenor of the evidence and the
demeanor of a witness in the court could be appreciated in the best manner only 
when the evidence is recorded in the language of the witness. Even otherwise, when
a question arises as to what exactly the witness had stated in his/her evidence,
it is the original deposition of the witness which has to be taken into account 
and not the translated memorandum in English prepared by the Presiding Judge. It
is therefore directed that all courts while recording the evidence of the witnesses,
shall duly comply with the provisions of Section 277 of Cr.P.C.

##### **Party**

**NAIM AHAMED VERSUS STATE (NCT OF DELHI) – CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 257 OF 2023 (Arising
Out of SLP (Crl.) NO. 8586 OF 2017) – 30.01.2023**

**[Naim Ahamed vs. State24828_2017_5_1501_41360_Judgement_30-Jan-2023](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/Naim-Ahamed-vs.-State24828_2017_5_1501_41360_Judgement_30-Jan-2023.pdf)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
