# Section 167 crpc: Accused cannot claim default bail on the ground that the further investigation against other accused is pending

- Link: https://section1.in/section-167-crpc-accused-cannot-claim-default-bail-on-the-ground-that-the-further-investigation-against-other-accused-is-pending/
- Published: 2024-01-27T20:15:04+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Challenge](https://section1.in/section-167-crpc-accused-cannot-claim-default-bail-on-the-ground-that-the-further-investigation-against-other-accused-is-pending/#challenge)
 * [Facts](https://section1.in/section-167-crpc-accused-cannot-claim-default-bail-on-the-ground-that-the-further-investigation-against-other-accused-is-pending/#facts)
 * [Arrest & custody](https://section1.in/section-167-crpc-accused-cannot-claim-default-bail-on-the-ground-that-the-further-investigation-against-other-accused-is-pending/#arrest-amp-custody)
 * [Application filed under section 167(2) crpc on the ground chargesheet was incomplete](https://section1.in/section-167-crpc-accused-cannot-claim-default-bail-on-the-ground-that-the-further-investigation-against-other-accused-is-pending/#application-filed-under-section-1672-crpc-on-the-ground-chargesheet-was-incomplete)
 * [Special court by a separate order took cognizance on the offence](https://section1.in/section-167-crpc-accused-cannot-claim-default-bail-on-the-ground-that-the-further-investigation-against-other-accused-is-pending/#special-court-by-a-separate-order-took-cognizance-on-the-offence)
 * [Thereafter Special court granted bail under section 167(2) crpc](https://section1.in/section-167-crpc-accused-cannot-claim-default-bail-on-the-ground-that-the-further-investigation-against-other-accused-is-pending/#thereafter-special-court-granted-bail-under-section-1672-crpc)
 * [Hon’ble High Court dismissed the petition filed by the appellant (CBI)](https://section1.in/section-167-crpc-accused-cannot-claim-default-bail-on-the-ground-that-the-further-investigation-against-other-accused-is-pending/#honble-high-court-dismissed-the-petition-filed-by-the-appellant-cbi)
 * [Analysis](https://section1.in/section-167-crpc-accused-cannot-claim-default-bail-on-the-ground-that-the-further-investigation-against-other-accused-is-pending/#analysis)
 * [Two different standpoints of the Special court on deciding default bail](https://section1.in/section-167-crpc-accused-cannot-claim-default-bail-on-the-ground-that-the-further-investigation-against-other-accused-is-pending/#two-different-standpoints-of-the-special-court-on-deciding-default-bail)
 * [CBI having kept the investigation pending for other accused is to be considered the present chargesheet as incomplete](https://section1.in/section-167-crpc-accused-cannot-claim-default-bail-on-the-ground-that-the-further-investigation-against-other-accused-is-pending/#cbi-having-kept-the-investigation-pending-for-other-accused-is-to-be-considered-the-present-chargesheet-as-incomplete)
 * [Final report explained: Final report is complete if it is accompanied with all the documents section 173(5) crpc](https://section1.in/section-167-crpc-accused-cannot-claim-default-bail-on-the-ground-that-the-further-investigation-against-other-accused-is-pending/#final-report-explained-final-report-is-complete-if-it-is-accompanied-with-all-the-documents-section-1735-crpc)
 * [Further investigation pending against other accused and non-production of documents while filing charge sheet would not vitiate the chargesheet](https://section1.in/section-167-crpc-accused-cannot-claim-default-bail-on-the-ground-that-the-further-investigation-against-other-accused-is-pending/#further-investigation-pending-against-other-accused-and-nonproduction-of-documents-while-filing-charge-sheet-would-not-vitiate-the-chargesheet)
 * [Accused cannot claim default bail on the ground that the investigation against other accused is pending](https://section1.in/section-167-crpc-accused-cannot-claim-default-bail-on-the-ground-that-the-further-investigation-against-other-accused-is-pending/#accused-cannot-claim-default-bail-on-the-ground-that-the-investigation-against-other-accused-is-pending)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/section-167-crpc-accused-cannot-claim-default-bail-on-the-ground-that-the-further-investigation-against-other-accused-is-pending/#party)

##### Challenge

2.The appellant-CBI has sought to challenge the impugned order dated 30.05.2023 
passed by the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in CRL. M.C. No. 6544 of 2022 upholding
the order dated 03.12.2022 passed by the Special Judge (PC Act), CBI-08, New Delhi(
hereinafter referred to as the Special Court), by which respondent nos. 1 and 2 
have been granted default bail under Section 167(2) Cr.P.C.

##### Facts

3.The short facts giving rise to the present appeal are that an FIR bearing no. 
RC2242022A0001 came to be registered in CBI, AC VI / SIT, New Delhi on 20.06.2022,
on the basis of the complaint lodged by Sh. Vipin Kumar Shukla, DGM, Union Bank 
of India, Nariman Point, Mumbai, for the offences punishable under Section 120-B
r/w Section 409, 420 and 477A of IPC and Section 13(2) r/w Section 13(1)(d) of PC
Act, 1988 (hereinafter referred to as the PC Act), against Dewan Housing Finance
Corporation Ltd. (DHFL) and 12 other accused persons/companies. It was alleged in
the said FIR inter alia that the DHFL, Sh. Kapil Wadhawan, the then Chairman and
Managing Director, DHFL, along with 12 other accused persons entered into a criminal
conspiracy to cheat the consortium of 17 banks led by Union Bank of India, and in
pursuance to the said criminal conspiracy, the said accused persons/entities induced
the consortium banks to sanction huge loans aggregating to Rs. 42,000 crores approx.
and thereafter they siphoned off and misappropriated a significant portion of the
said funds by falsifying the books of account of DHFL and deliberately and dishonestly
defaulted on repayment of the legitimate dues of the said consortium banks, and 
thereby caused a wrongful loss of Rs. 34,000 crores to the consortium lenders during
the period January, 2010 to December, 2019.

##### Arrest & custody

4.The respondent no. 1- Kapil Wadhawan and respondent no. 2 Dheeraj Wadhawan came
to be arrested by the appellant-CBI in connection with the said FIR on 19.07.2022
and were remanded to judicial custody on 30.07.2022.

5.After carrying out the investigation, a chargesheet for the offences under Section
120B r/w Section 206, 409, 411, 420, 424, 465, 468 and 477A of IPC and Section 13(
2) r/w 13(1)(d) of PC Act came to be filed by the CBI against 75 persons/entities
including the respondent nos. 1 and 2 on 15.10.2022.

##### Application filed under section 167(2) crpc on the ground chargesheet was incomplete

6.Respondent nos. 1 and 2 filed an application under Section 167(2) of Cr.P.C. on
29.10.2022 before the Special Court seeking statutory bail on the ground that the
chargesheet filed by the CBI was incomplete and no final report as defined under
Section 173(2) Cr.P.C. was filed within the statutory period provided under Section
167(2) Cr.P.C., or in the alternative seeking their release from judicial custody
in view of lack of jurisdiction of the court as there was no approval under Section
17A of the PC Act as amended in 2018.

##### Special court by a separate order took cognizance on the offence

7.The Special Court vide the order dated 26.11.2022 held that the Special Court 
had the jurisdiction to deal with the matter and the bar under Section 17A of the
PC Act was not applicable to the facts of the case. By a separate order dated 26.11.2022,
the Special Court took the cognizance of the alleged offences against all the 75
accused and issued production warrants against the present respondent nos. 1 and
2 (A-1 and A-2) as also against accused no. 7. The Special Court also issued warrants/
summons against the other accused.

##### Thereafter Special court granted bail under section 167(2) crpc

8.Thereafter, the Special Court vide the order dated 03.12.2022 holding that the
investigation was incomplete and the chargesheet filed was in piecemeal, further
held that the respondent nos. 1 and 2 (A-1 and A-2) were entitled to the statutory
bail under Section 167(2) Cr.P.C.

##### Hon’ble High Court dismissed the petition filed by the appellant (CBI)

9.The appellant-CBI, being aggrieved by the said order dated 03.12.2022 passed by
the Special Court filed a petition being Crl.M.C. No. 6544 of 2022 before the High
Court under Section 482 r/w Section 439(2) of Cr.P.C. The High Court vide the impugned
order dated 30.05.2023 dismissed the said petition and upheld the order dated 03.12.2022
passed by the Special Court.

##### Analysis

13.In the instant appeal, the main question that falls for our consideration is,
whether the respondents were entitled to the benefit of the statutory right conferred
under the proviso to sub section 2 of Section 167 Cr.P.C, on the ground that the
investigation qua some of the accused named in the FIR was pending, though the report
under sub-section (2) of Section 173 (Chargesheet) against respondents along with
the other accused was filed within the prescribed time limit and though the cognizance
of the offence was taken by the special court before the consideration of the application
of the respondents seeking default bail under Section 167 (2) Cr.P.C.?

15.There cannot be any disagreement with the well settled legal position that the
right of default bail under Section 167(2) Cr.P.C. is not only a statutory right
but is a right that flows from Article 21 of the Constitution of India. It is an
indefeasible right, nonetheless it is enforceable only prior to the filing of the
challan or the chargesheet, and does not survive or remain enforceable on the challan
being filed, if already not availed of. Once the challan has been filed, the question
of grant of bail has to be considered and decided only with reference to the merits
of the case under the provisions relating to grant of bail to the accused after 
the filing of the challan. The Constitution Bench in Sanjay Dutt vs. State through
CBI, Bombay (II) [(1994) 5 SCC 410], while considering the provisions of Section
20(4) (bb) of the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 read
with Section 167 (2) Cr.P.C. had very pertinently held that:-

“.48…………………………”

16.In Suresh Kumar Bhikamchand Jain Vs. State of Maharashtra & Anr. ((2013) 3 SCC
77), the appellant-accused had sought default bail under Section 167(2) on the ground
that though the chargesheet was filed within the stipulated time, the cognizance
was not taken by the court, for want of sanction to prosecute the accused. . The
court dispelling the claim of the accused held:-

“.17…………………..”

18.In the instant case as transpiring from the record, the respondents (A1 and A2)
were arrested in connection with the FIR in question on 19.07.2022, and the report(
the chargesheet) running into about 900 pages under Section 173(2) was filed by 
the CBI against the respondents along with other 73 accused on 15.10.2022. In the
said report it was stated in Para no. 66 that: –

> “66. With regard to ascertaining roles of remaining FIR named accused persons 
> namely Sh. Sudhakar Shetry, M/s Amaryllis Realtors & M/s Gulmarg Realtors, remaining
> CAs (who had audited balance sheets of e-DHFL & Shell companies and who had facilitated
> the promoters), ultimate beneficiaries/end use of diverted funds through shell
> companies & other Wadhawan Group Companies, the DHFL officials, insider share 
> trading of DHFL shares, bank officials, NHB officials and other connected issues,
> further investigation u/s 173 (8) of Cr. PC is continuing.
> List of additional witnesses and additional documents will be filed as and when
> required.
> It is, therefore, humbly prayed that the aforesaid accused persons may be summoned
> and be tried in accordance with the provisions of law.”

##### Two different standpoints of the Special court on deciding default bail

19.The Special Court thereafter had taken cognizance of the alleged offences as 
per the order dated 26.11.2022. It appears that earlier the Special Court had rejected
the application of the respondents (accused) seeking statutory bail under Section
167(2) Cr.P.C., however at that, time the issue was whether qua the offences against
the respondents, period of sixty days or ninety days was 15 applicable for grant
of mandatory bail due to non-filing of chargesheet by the investigating agency, 
and it was held by the Special Court that the period of ninety days was applicable
in case of the respondents, in which the chargesheet could be filed by the CBI. 
The respondents thereafter filed another application under Section167(2) after the
cognizance of the offences was taken by the Special Court, on the ground that the
chargesheet filed against them was an incomplete chargesheet.

##### CBI having kept the investigation pending for other accused is to be considered the present chargesheet as incomplete

20.The bone of contention raised by the learned Senior Counsels for the Respondents
in this appeal is that the appellant – CBI having kept the investigation open qua
other respondents as stated in Para 66 of the chargesheet, the ingredients of Section
173 Cr.P.C. could not be said to have been complied with and therefore the report/
chargesheet under Section 173 could not be said to be a complete chargesheet. It
is immaterial whether cognizance has been taken by the court or not. According to
them the chargesheet filed against the respondents and others was a subterfuge or
ruse to defeat the indefeasible right of the respondents conferred under Section
167(2) Cr.P.C.

Quoting K. Veeraswami vs. Union of India and Others [para.76 on the said judgment]
reported in (1991) 3 SCC 655 the Hon’ble Supreme court has held as follows:

##### Final report explained: Final report is complete if it is accompanied with all the documents section 173(5) crpc

22.In view of the above settled legal position, there remains no shadow of doubt
that the statutory requirement of the report under Section 173 (2) would be complied
with if the various details prescribed therein are included in the report. The report
under Section 173 is an intimation to the court that upon investigation into the
cognizable offence, the investigating officer has been able to procure sufficient
evidence for the court to inquire into the offence and the necessary information
is being sent to the court. The report is complete if it is accompanied with all
the documents and statements of witnesses as required by Section 175 (5). As settled
in the afore-stated case, it is not necessary that all the details of the offence
must be stated.

##### Further investigation pending against other accused and non-production of documents while filing charge sheet would not vitiate the chargesheet

23.The benefit of proviso appended to sub-section (2) of Section 167 of the Code
would be available to the offender only when a chargesheet is not filed and the 
investigation is kept pending against him. Once however, a chargesheet is filed,
the said right ceases. It may be noted that the right of the investigating officer
to pray for further investigation in terms of sub-section (8) of Section 173 is 
not taken away only because a chargesheet is filed under sub-section (2) thereof
against the accused. Though ordinarily all documents relied upon by the prosecution
should accompany the chargesheet, nonetheless for some reasons, if all the documents
are not filed along with the chargesheet, that reason by itself would not invalidate
or vitiate the chargesheet. It is also well settled that the court takes cognizance
of the offence and not the offender. Once from the material produced along with 
the chargesheet, the court is satisfied about the commission of an offence and takes
cognizance of the offence allegedly committed by the accused, it is immaterial whether
the further investigation in terms of Section 173(8) is pending or not. The pendency
of the further investigation qua the other accused or for production of some documents
not available at the time of filing of chargesheet would neither vitiate the chargesheet,
nor would it entitle the accused to claim right to get default bail on the ground
that the chargesheet was an incomplete chargesheet or that the chargesheet was not
filed in terms of Section 173(2) of Cr.P.C.

Placing reliance on the judgment Dinesh Dalmia vs. CBI reported in (2007) 8 SCC 
770 for the scope of Section 167(2) vis-à-vis Section 173(8) Cr.P.C Apex court has
held as follows:

##### Accused cannot claim default bail on the ground that the investigation against other accused is pending

> 25.In view of the afore-stated legal position, we have no hesitation in holding
> that the chargesheet having been filed against the respondents-accused within 
> the prescribed time limit and the cognizance having been taken by the Special 
> Court of the offences allegedly committed by them, the respondents could not have
> claimed the statutory right of default bail under Section 167(2) on the ground
> that the investigation qua other accused was pending. Both, the Special Court 
> as well as the High Court having committed serious error of law in disregarding
> the legal position enunciated and settled by this Court, the impugned orders deserve
> to be set aside and are accordingly set aside.

##### **Party**

CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION VERSUS KAPIL WADHAWAN & ANR – CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.
391 OF 2024 (@ SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (Crl.) No. 11775 OF 2023) – JANUARY, 24TH 
2024 – 2024 INSC 58

**[https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2023/31214/31214_2023_13_1501_49727_Judgement_24-Jan-2024.pdf](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2023/31214/31214_2023_13_1501_49727_Judgement_24-Jan-2024.pdf)**

**[CBI vs Kapil Wadhawan anr](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/CBI-vs-Kapil-Wadhawan-anr.pdf)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
