# Section 193 IPC: Affidavit: Since no malafide intention is in the statement mere suspicion or inaccurate statement in the affidavit does not attract the offence of perjury

- Link: https://section1.in/section-193-ipc-affidavit-since-no-malafide-intention-is-in-the-statement-mere-suspicion-or-inaccurate-statement-in-the-affidavit-does-not-attract-the-offence-of-perjury/
- Published: 2024-08-28T20:04:39+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Direction of the Hon’ble High Court to file complaint against the appellant for filing false affidavit](https://section1.in/section-193-ipc-affidavit-since-no-malafide-intention-is-in-the-statement-mere-suspicion-or-inaccurate-statement-in-the-affidavit-does-not-attract-the-offence-of-perjury/#direction-of-the-honble-high-court-to-file-complaint-against-the-appellant-for-filing-false-affidavit)
 * [Based on the order of the High Court complaint under section 193 IPC preferred before CJM](https://section1.in/section-193-ipc-affidavit-since-no-malafide-intention-is-in-the-statement-mere-suspicion-or-inaccurate-statement-in-the-affidavit-does-not-attract-the-offence-of-perjury/#based-on-the-order-of-the-high-court-complaint-under-section-193-ipc-preferred-before-cjm)
 * [Appellant argued that mere denial of averments in the pleadings would not constitute offence of perjury](https://section1.in/section-193-ipc-affidavit-since-no-malafide-intention-is-in-the-statement-mere-suspicion-or-inaccurate-statement-in-the-affidavit-does-not-attract-the-offence-of-perjury/#appellant-argued-that-mere-denial-of-averments-in-the-pleadings-would-not-constitute-offence-of-perjury)
 * [Question of law: Whether the contents of the affidavit constitutes offence of perjury?](https://section1.in/section-193-ipc-affidavit-since-no-malafide-intention-is-in-the-statement-mere-suspicion-or-inaccurate-statement-in-the-affidavit-does-not-attract-the-offence-of-perjury/#question-of-law-whether-the-contents-of-the-affidavit-constitutes-offence-of-perjury)
 * [Section 191 IPC](https://section1.in/section-193-ipc-affidavit-since-no-malafide-intention-is-in-the-statement-mere-suspicion-or-inaccurate-statement-in-the-affidavit-does-not-attract-the-offence-of-perjury/#section-191-ipc)
 * [Section 193 IPC](https://section1.in/section-193-ipc-affidavit-since-no-malafide-intention-is-in-the-statement-mere-suspicion-or-inaccurate-statement-in-the-affidavit-does-not-attract-the-offence-of-perjury/#section-193-ipc)
 * [Section 195(b)(1) Cr.P.C](https://section1.in/section-193-ipc-affidavit-since-no-malafide-intention-is-in-the-statement-mere-suspicion-or-inaccurate-statement-in-the-affidavit-does-not-attract-the-offence-of-perjury/#section-195b1-crpc)
 * [Previous judgments on this point](https://section1.in/section-193-ipc-affidavit-since-no-malafide-intention-is-in-the-statement-mere-suspicion-or-inaccurate-statement-in-the-affidavit-does-not-attract-the-offence-of-perjury/#previous-judgments-on-this-point)
 * [Referred to in Himanshu Kumar (supra); Narendra Kumar Srivastava v. State of Bihar & Ors](https://section1.in/section-193-ipc-affidavit-since-no-malafide-intention-is-in-the-statement-mere-suspicion-or-inaccurate-statement-in-the-affidavit-does-not-attract-the-offence-of-perjury/#referred-to-in-himanshu-kumar-supra-narendra-kumar-srivastava-v-state-of-bihar-amp-ors)
 * [Since no malafide intention is in the statement mere suspicion or inaccurate statement in the affidavit does not attract the offence of perjury](https://section1.in/section-193-ipc-affidavit-since-no-malafide-intention-is-in-the-statement-mere-suspicion-or-inaccurate-statement-in-the-affidavit-does-not-attract-the-offence-of-perjury/#since-no-malafide-intention-is-in-the-statement-mere-suspicion-or-inaccurate-statement-in-the-affidavit-does-not-attract-the-offence-of-perjury)
 * [Case quashed](https://section1.in/section-193-ipc-affidavit-since-no-malafide-intention-is-in-the-statement-mere-suspicion-or-inaccurate-statement-in-the-affidavit-does-not-attract-the-offence-of-perjury/#case-quashed)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/section-193-ipc-affidavit-since-no-malafide-intention-is-in-the-statement-mere-suspicion-or-inaccurate-statement-in-the-affidavit-does-not-attract-the-offence-of-perjury/#party)
 * [Further Study ](https://section1.in/section-193-ipc-affidavit-since-no-malafide-intention-is-in-the-statement-mere-suspicion-or-inaccurate-statement-in-the-affidavit-does-not-attract-the-offence-of-perjury/#further-study%c2%a0)

**Appeal against the dismissal of bail cancellation application**

2. Impugned in the present appeal is the final order dated 1st October 2022, passed
by the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital in Bail Cancellation Application No.
24/2022, whereby, although the said application was dismissed, it was observed that
James Kunjwal, the present appellant had intentionally filed a false affidavit before
the High Court and as such, a direction was issued to the Registrar (Judl.) of the
High Court to file a complaint against him. This, in a nutshell, forms the basis
for this **[appeal](http://localhost:8080/section1/conviction-sudden-provocation/)**.

##### **Direction of the Hon’ble High Court to file complaint against the appellant for filing false affidavit**

4. The order dated 1st October, 2022 of the learned Single Judge, while dismissing
the bail cancellation application, made reference to the conflict of facts in the
affidavits filed by the complainant and the present appellant. While the complainant
submitted in her affidavit that certain events took place, the present appellant
denied the same with certain explanations. It was further noted that the State’s
affidavit supported the position of the present respondent. Despite the said contradiction
having been brought to the notice of the present appellant, he “did not assist the
Court in finding the truth about the incident of 24.07.2022”. It was, as such, concluded
that the appellant had intentionally filed a false affidavit before the Court. Accordingly,
in the penultimate paragraph of the [judgment](http://localhost:8080/section1/writing-judgment-is-an-art/),
issued the following directions:

> “28. The above narration establishes that the respondent no.2 intentionally filed
> false affidavit before the Court, Therefore, this Court requests Registrar, Judicial
> of this Court to file a complaint against the respondent no.2 in, the court of
> competent jurisdiction for filing a false affidavit.”

##### **Based on the order of the High Court complaint under section 193 IPC preferred before CJM**

5. Pursuant to such an Order by the High Court, a complaint under **[Section 193 of the IPC was filed](http://localhost:8080/section1/section-420-ipc-the-contention-that-since-charge-sheet-has-been-filed-the-present-appeal-is-to-be-dismissed-was-rejected/)**
before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Nainital bearing the following particulars–
Criminal Complaint No.2991 of 2022, titled as State Through Registrar (Judicial),
Hon’ble High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital v. James Kunjwal.

##### **Appellant argued that mere denial of averments in the pleadings would not constitute offence of perjury**

6. By way of the special leave petition it is urged that mere denial of the averments
in the pleadings would not **[constitute the offence](http://localhost:8080/section1/wrong-a-wrongful-contract-may-constitute-both-civil-wrong-and-criminal-offence/)**
of perjury. Further, it was urged that a Court is not “bound” to make a complaint
under Section 195(1)(b), Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, unless it is of the opinion
that it is expedient in the interest of justice to do so. Reliance is placed on 
a Constitution Bench judgment of this Court in **Iqbal Singh Marwah v. Meenakshi
Marwah [(2005) 4 SCC 370]**.

##### **Question of law: Whether the contents of the affidavit constitutes offence of perjury?**

9. Hence, in the attending facts, the short question that falls for consideration
of this Court is whether the contents of the affidavit filed before the High Court,
as taken note of in the impugned order, constitutes an offence under Section 193
IPC, as defined in Section 191 IPC?

##### **Section 191 IPC**

10. **[Section 191 IPC which defines the offence](http://localhost:8080/section1/even-in-a-case-where-the-final-report-of-the-police-under-section-173-is-accepted-and-the-accused-persons-are-discharged-the-magistrate-has-the-power-to-take-cognizance-of-the-offence-on-a-complaint/)**,
reads as under :-

> “191. Giving false evidence. Whoever, being legally bound by an oath or by an 
> express provision of law to state the truth, or being bound by law to make a declaration
> upon any subject, makes any** [statement](http://localhost:8080/section1/statement-cognizance-committal-evidence-on-handwriting-explained/)**
> which is false, and which he either knows or believes to be false or does not 
> believe to be true, is said to give false evidence. Explanation 1.— A statement
> is within the meaning of this section, whether it is made verbally or otherwise.
> Explanation 2.— A false statement as to the belief of the person attesting is 
> within the meaning of this section, and a person may be guilty of giving false
> evidence by stating that he believes a thing which he does not believe, as well
> as by stating that he knows a thing which he does not know.”

##### **Section 193 IPC**

Section 193 IPC, under which the appellant is sought to be prosecuted is extracted
below for reference.

> “193. Punishment For False Evidence. Whoever intentionally gives false evidence
> in any stage of a judicial proceeding, or fabricates false evidence for the purpose
> of being used in any stage of a judicial proceeding, shall be punished with imprisonment
> of either description for a term which may extend to seven years, and shall also
> be liable to fine; and whoever intentionally gives or fabricates false evidence
> in any other case, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for
> a term which may extend to three years, and shall also be liable to fine. Explanation
> 1. – A trial before a Court-martial is a judicial proceeding.
> Explanation 2. – An investigation directed by law preliminary to a proceeding 
> before a Court of Justice, is a stage of a judicial proceeding, though that investigation
> may not take place before a Court of Justice.”

##### **Section 195(b)(1) Cr.P.C**

11. Section 195(b)(1) of Cr.P.C. (**[relevant portion](http://localhost:8080/section1/hostile-witness-contradiction-public-prosecutor-has-to-confront-relevant-portions-to-the-witness-and-contradict-as-required-by-section-145-iea/)**
reproduced hereinbelow) provides that no Court shall take cognizance of an offence
committed under Sections 193 to 196, 199, 200, 205-211; except on the complaint 
in writing of the Court or by an officer of the Court, duly authorized. Section 
340 mentions the procedure in respect of the prosecution as delineated under Section
195.

> “195. Prosecution for contempt of lawful authority of public servants, for offences
> against public justice and for offences relating to documents given in evidence.—
> (1) No Court shall take cognizance—
> (a) ……
> (b) (i) of any offence punishable under any of the following sections of the Indian
> Penal Code (45 of 1860), namely, sections 193 to 196 (both inclusive), 199, 200,
> 205 to 211 (both inclusive) and 228, when such offence is alleged to have been
> committed in, or in relation to, any proceeding in any Court, or
> (ii) …..
> (iii) of any **[criminal conspiracy](http://localhost:8080/section1/title-understanding-section-120b-of-the-indian-penal-code-ipc-criminal-conspiracy-and-its-implications/)**
> to commit, or attempt to commit, or the abetment of, any offence specified in 
> sub-clause (i) or sub-clause (ii)…
> (2) …
> (3) …
> (4) …”

##### **Previous judgments on this point**

12. The proper approach in cases where Section 193 is in play, it has been held 
by this Court in **Dr. S.P. Kohli, Civil Surgeon, Ferozepur v. High Court of Haryana
Through Registrar [(1979) 1 SCC 212]** as under:

> “16. It is true that what the courts have to see before issuing the process against
> the accused is whether there is evidence in support of the allegations made by
> the complainant to justify the initiation of proceedings against the accused and
> not whether the evidence is sufficient to warrant his conviction, but this does
> not mean that the courts should not prima facie be of the opinion that there are
> sufficient and reasonable grounds for setting the machinery of **[criminal law](http://localhost:8080/section1/basics-of-criminal-law-part-3-criminal-jurisprudence/)**
> in motion against the accused. The moment this guiding [principle](http://localhost:8080/section1/a-must-have-judgment-how-to-appreciate-confession-circumstantial-evidence/)
> is overlooked, the prosecution degenerates itself into persecution which often
> is fraught with evil consequences.”
> (Emphasis supplied)

**Referred to in Himanshu Kumar & Ors. v. State of Chhattisgarh & Ors [2022 SCC 
OnLine SC 884]**

13. When prosecution should be sanctioned under this Section by Courts has been 
expounded on by a Bench of three learned Judges in Chajoo Ram v. Radhey Shyam & 
Anr [(1971) 1 SCC 774]

> “7. The prosecution for perjury should be sanctioned by courts only in those cases
> where the perjury appears to be deliberate and conscious and the conviction is
> reasonably probable or likely. No doubt giving of false evidence and filing false
> affidavits is an evil which must be effectively curbed with a strong hand but 
> to start prosecution for perjury too readily and too frequently without due care
> and caution and on inconclusive and doubtful material defeats its very purpose.
> Prosecution should be ordered when it is considered expedient in the interests
> of justice to punish the delinquent and not merely because there is some inaccuracy
> in the statement which may be innocent or immaterial. There must be prima facie
> case of deliberate falsehood on a matter of substance and the court should be 
> satisfied that there is reasonable foundation for the charge…”
> (Emphasis supplied)

##### Referred to in Himanshu Kumar (supra); Narendra Kumar Srivastava v. State of Bihar & Ors [(2019) 3 SCC 318]

14. In this regard we may also notice the pronouncement in R.S. Sujatha v. State
of Karnataka [(2011) 5 SCC 689], referred to in Aarish Asgar Qureshi v. Fareed Ahmad
Qureshi [(2019) 18 SCC 172] wherein it was observed:

> “9. Both these judgments were referred to and relied upon with approval in R.S.
> Sujatha v. State of Karnataka [R.S. Sujatha v. State of Karnataka, (2011) 5 SCC
> 689 : (2011) 2 SCC (Cri) 757] (at paras 15 and 16). This court, after setting 
> down the law laid down in these two judgments concluded : (SCC pp. 694-95, para
> 18) “18. Thus, from the above, it is evident that the inquiry/contempt proceedings
> should be initiated by the court in exceptional circumstances where the court 
> is of the opinion that perjury has been committed by a party deliberately to have
> some beneficial order from the court. There must be grounds of a nature higher
> than mere surmise or suspicion for initiating such proceedings. There must be 
> distinct evidence of the commission of an offence by such a person as mere suspicion
> cannot bring home the charge of perjury. More so, the court has also to determine
> as on facts, whether it is expedient in the interest of justice to inquire into
> the offence which appears to have been committed.”
> (Emphasis supplied)

**Three essential factors for the [application of section](http://localhost:8080/section1/application-under-section-531-2-a-bnss-2023-my-view/)
193 IPC**

15. The three essential factors which can be said to be sine qua non for the application
of Section 193 IPC as held in **[Bhima Razu Prasad v. State Rep. by Deputy Supdt. of Police, CBI/SPE/ACU-II](https://api.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2020/14906/14906_2020_39_1501_26894_Judgement_12-Mar-2021.pdf)**[(
2021) 19 SCC 25] are:

> (1) false statement made on oath or in affidavits;
> (2) that such statements be made in a judicial proceeding; or
> (3) such statement be made before an authority that has been expressly deemed 
> to be a ‘Court’.

16. What we may conclude from a perusal of the above-noticed judicial pronouncements
is that:-

> (i) The Court should be of the prima facie opinion that there exists sufficient
> and reasonable ground to initiate proceedings against the person who has allegedly
> made a false statement(s);
> (ii) Such proceedings should be initiated when doing the same is “expedient in
> the interests of justice to punish the delinquent” and not merely because of inaccuracy
> in statements that may be innocent/immaterial;
> (iii) There should be “deliberate falsehood on a matter of substance”;
> (iv) The Court should be satisfied that there is a reasonable foundation for the
> charge, with distinct evidence and not mere suspicion;
> (v) Proceedings should be initiated in exceptional circumstances, for instance,
> when a party has perjured themselves to beneficial orders from the Court.

17. The statement made by the appellant, that has been deemed to be befitting the
offence of giving false evidence before the Court, which is known commonly as perjury,
was more in the nature of denial of the statements made in the affidavits of the
complainant herein.

##### **Since no malafide intention is in the statement mere suspicion or inaccurate statement in the affidavit does not attract the offence of perjury**

18. We are of the view that, in the present facts, a denial simpliciter cannot meet
the threshold, as described in the judgments above, particularly when no malafide
intention/deliberate attempt can be understood from the statement made by the appellant
in the affidavit. As has already been observed, mere suspicion or inaccurate statements
do not attract the offence under the Section. It cannot be disputed that the statements
made in the affidavit were only to state his version of events and/or deny the version
put forth by the complainant.

20. We find that at least three of the possible scenarios, as discussed supra, in
which a **[court would be justified in invoking these powers](http://localhost:8080/section1/cr-p-c-1973-notes-no-6-general-introduction-to-inquiries-and-trials-part-4-criminal-courts-powers-administration/)**
on the face of it appear to be unmet, prosecution, therefore, would be unjust. We
say so for the reason that the respondent in her counter affidavit filed before 
this Court makes no particular allegation nor does she provide any of the material
that was allegedly placed before the competent prosecuting authorities or the Court.
She only alleges untruth on the part of the appellant 8/12/2024stating that the 
Court was correct in initiating proceedings against him for making the false statement.
She further makes certain statements that fall outside the scope of the present 
adjudication and pertain to the trial of the main offence pending before the court
of competent jurisdiction.

##### **Case quashed**

21. Consequent to the above discussion, we **[set aside](http://localhost:8080/section1/habeas-corpus-unexplained-delay-in-disposing-the-representation-made-by-the-detenu-is-sufficient-to-set-aside-the-order-of-detention/)**
the direction of the High Court of Uttarakhand in regard to registering a complaint
against the present appellant. Any proceedings arising therefrom shall stand** [quashed](http://localhost:8080/section1/murder-case-quashed-husband-tried-to-molest-own-daughter-in-the-course-of-saving-daughter-mother-killed-husband-therefore-offence-falls-under-general-exception-chapter/).**
The appeal is, accordingly allowed. Before parting with the matter, it stands clarified
that the decision in this appeal shall have no bearing on the criminal case pending
against the appellant which shall proceed on its own merits as per law.

##### **Party**

**James Kunjwal … Appelant(S) versus State of Uttarakhand & Anr. … Respondent(S)–
Criminal Appeal No………. of 2024 (Arising out of SLP(Crl.) No.9783/2023) – August 
13, 2024 – 2024 INSC 601 [3 judge bench].**

**[https://www.sci.gov.in/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php?action=get_court_pdf&diary_no=165762023&type=j&order_date=2024-08-13&from=latest_judgements_order](https://www.sci.gov.in/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php?action=get_court_pdf&diary_no=165762023&type=j&order_date=2024-08-13&from=latest_judgements_order)**

**[Janmes Kunjwal vs. State of Uttarakhand 165762023_2024-08-13](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/Janmes-Kunjwal-vs.-State-of-Uttarakhand-165762023_2024-08-13.pdf)**

##### Further Study 

 * **[Affidavit: Court cannot convert complaint into a 156(3) cr.p.c petition without following procedures](http://localhost:8080/section1/court-cannot-convert-complaint-into-a-1563-cr-p-c-petition-without-following-procedures/)**
 * **[Protest petition: When the Magistrate does not treat the protest petition as a complaint and rejects it then the complainant can file a fresh complaint](http://localhost:8080/section1/protest-petition-when-the-magistrate-does-not-treat-the-protest-petition-as-a-complaint-and-rejects-it-then-the-complainant-can-file-a-fresh-complaint/)**
 * **[False promise to marry: Marrying without witness does not imply a fraudulent marriage and having sex thereafter was the consensual one.](http://localhost:8080/section1/false-promise-to-marry-marrying-without-witness-does-not-imply-a-fraudulent-marriage-and-having-sex-thereafter-was-the-consensual-one/)**
 * **[Quash: Courts must be vigilant on identifying false complaints](http://localhost:8080/section1/quash-courts-must-be-vigilant-on-identifying-false-complaints/)**
 * **[Appeal against acquittal: Explained](http://localhost:8080/section1/appeal-against-acquittal/)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
