# Section 202 cr.p.c: In cases where jurisdiction is involved as per section 202 cr.p.c Magistrates must wait till the report is received and thereafter summon the accused

- Link: https://section1.in/section-202-cr-p-c-in-cases-where-jurisdiction-is-involved-as-per-section-202-cr-p-c-magistrates-must-wait-till-the-report-is-received-and-thereafter-summon-the-accused/
- Published: 2024-02-25T21:50:44+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Factual aspects](https://section1.in/section-202-cr-p-c-in-cases-where-jurisdiction-is-involved-as-per-section-202-cr-p-c-magistrates-must-wait-till-the-report-is-received-and-thereafter-summon-the-accused/#factual-aspects)
 * [Challenge is against the dismissal of quash petition against the compliant filed](https://section1.in/section-202-cr-p-c-in-cases-where-jurisdiction-is-involved-as-per-section-202-cr-p-c-magistrates-must-wait-till-the-report-is-received-and-thereafter-summon-the-accused/#challenge-is-against-the-dismissal-of-quash-petition-against-the-compliant-filed)
 * [Consideration of submissions](https://section1.in/section-202-cr-p-c-in-cases-where-jurisdiction-is-involved-as-per-section-202-cr-p-c-magistrates-must-wait-till-the-report-is-received-and-thereafter-summon-the-accused/#consideration-of-submissions)
 * [Section 202 cr.p.c explained in detail](https://section1.in/section-202-cr-p-c-in-cases-where-jurisdiction-is-involved-as-per-section-202-cr-p-c-magistrates-must-wait-till-the-report-is-received-and-thereafter-summon-the-accused/#section-202-crpc-explained-in-detail)
 * [Magistrate called for report under section 202 cr.p.c after evidence (sworn) was over](https://section1.in/section-202-cr-p-c-in-cases-where-jurisdiction-is-involved-as-per-section-202-cr-p-c-magistrates-must-wait-till-the-report-is-received-and-thereafter-summon-the-accused/#magistrate-called-for-report-under-section-202-crpc-after-evidence-sworn-was-over)
 * [Police did not file the report under section 202 cr.p.c](https://section1.in/section-202-cr-p-c-in-cases-where-jurisdiction-is-involved-as-per-section-202-cr-p-c-magistrates-must-wait-till-the-report-is-received-and-thereafter-summon-the-accused/#police-did-not-file-the-report-under-section-202-crpc)
 * [Magistrate ought to have waited till the report was received but summoned the accused](https://section1.in/section-202-cr-p-c-in-cases-where-jurisdiction-is-involved-as-per-section-202-cr-p-c-magistrates-must-wait-till-the-report-is-received-and-thereafter-summon-the-accused/#magistrate-ought-to-have-waited-till-the-report-was-received-but-summoned-the-accused)
 * [Remand is warranted](https://section1.in/section-202-cr-p-c-in-cases-where-jurisdiction-is-involved-as-per-section-202-cr-p-c-magistrates-must-wait-till-the-report-is-received-and-thereafter-summon-the-accused/#remand-is-warranted)
 * [Dispute is civil nature and no allegation that the accused company was involved in transaction between 2nd accused and 1st respondent-complaint](https://section1.in/section-202-cr-p-c-in-cases-where-jurisdiction-is-involved-as-per-section-202-cr-p-c-magistrates-must-wait-till-the-report-is-received-and-thereafter-summon-the-accused/#dispute-is-civil-nature-and-no-allegation-that-the-accused-company-was-involved-in-transaction-between-2nd-accused-and-1st-respondentcomplaint)
 * [Quash set-aside and allowed the appeal](https://section1.in/section-202-cr-p-c-in-cases-where-jurisdiction-is-involved-as-per-section-202-cr-p-c-magistrates-must-wait-till-the-report-is-received-and-thereafter-summon-the-accused/#quash-setaside-and-allowed-the-appeal)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/section-202-cr-p-c-in-cases-where-jurisdiction-is-involved-as-per-section-202-cr-p-c-magistrates-must-wait-till-the-report-is-received-and-thereafter-summon-the-accused/#party)
 * [Further study](https://section1.in/section-202-cr-p-c-in-cases-where-jurisdiction-is-involved-as-per-section-202-cr-p-c-magistrates-must-wait-till-the-report-is-received-and-thereafter-summon-the-accused/#further-study)

##### Factual aspects

##### Challenge is against the dismissal of quash petition against the compliant filed

1)The appellant in Criminal Appeal no.776 of 2024 is the accused no.2 in the complaint
filed by the 1st respondent complainant under Section 200 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 (for short, ‘the Cr.P.C’) alleging the commission of offences under
Sections 420, 406, 467, 468 and 472 read with Section 120B of the Indian Penal Code,
1860 (for short, ‘the IPC’) and Section 13 of the Essential Commodities Act, 1955.
The appellants in Criminal Appeal no.777 of 2024 are the accused nos.1, 4 and 5 
in the same Complaint. The appellants in these two appeals filed a petition under
Section 482 of the Cr.P.C before the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh
for quashing the said complaint and for quashing the summoning order dated 16^(th)
July 2013 passed on the said complaint. The High Court, by the impugned judgment
dated 25th August 2014, dismissed the said petition.

**2. **On 23rd September 2002, under the Liquified Petroleum Gas (LPG) Distributorship
Agreement (for short, ‘the Distributorship Agreement’), the accused no.1 – M/s.Energy
Infrastructure (India) Limited (for short, ‘the accused company’) appointed the 
2nd respondent accused no.7 (Arun Sharma, Proprietor of M/s.Arshya Max Agencies)
as a distributor for distribution of LPG cylinders in the areas of Panchkula and
Chandigarh. The 2nd respondent, on behalf of the accused company, purported to execute
a Point of Sale agreement on 7th March 2003 (for short, ‘the POS agreement’) by 
which he purported to appoint the 1st Respondent complainant as a sales outlet (
Point of Sale) in the town of Dhanas to sell MaxGas to the consumers. By the POS
agreement, the 2nd respondent agreed to pay a flat rate commission per cylinder 
sold by the 1st respondent complainant. A demand draft in the sum of Rs.74,900/was
issued in favour of the accused company by the 1^(st) respondent complainant.

**3. **The accused company addressed a letter dated 3^(rd) March 2004 to the 2nd
respondent alleging serious lapses in customer services rendered by the 2nd respondent,
which allegedly caused a big dent in the reputation of the accused company. Various
instances of lapses in service were set out in the said letter. The accused company
also stated that the 2nd respondent had illegally supplied the cylinders to the 
1^(st) Respondent complainant beyond the assigned territory in Punjab. It was specifically
stated in the said letter that the name of the 1st respondent complainant was not
reflected in the records of the accused company as a Point of Sale. The accused 
company alleged that, thus, the 2nd respondent had committed a breach of the Distributorship
Agreement. Another allegation in the said letter was that a cheque issued by the
2nd respondent had been dishonoured.

**5. **The learned Judicial Magistrate, First Class, Chandigarh, from 17th November
2004 onwards, recorded the statements of the 1st respondent complainant and other
witnesses. After examining the witnesses, on 15th December 2011, the learned Magistrate
held that for proper adjudication of the case, it was necessary to send the complaint
to the jurisdictional police station for investigation in accordance with Section
202 of the Cr.PC. According to the case made out by the appellant, a report under
Section 202 of the Cr.PC was never submitted by the Police, and without waiting 
for the said report, the learned Magistrate passed the summoning order on 16th July
2013 for the offences punishable under Sections 420, 406, 467, 468 and 472 read 
with Section 120B of the IPC and Section 13 of the Essential Commodities Act, 1955.
By the impugned judgment and order dated 25^(th) August 2014, the High Court dismissed
the quashing petition by holding that disputed questions of fact were involved in
the petition, which can be dealt with only after recording evidence.

##### Consideration of submissions

##### Section 202 cr.p.c explained in detail

**8. **In this case, there is no dispute that some of the accused, including three
of the appellants, were residing outside the territorial jurisdiction of the Court
of the learned Magistrate before whom the complaint was filed by the 1^(st) respondent–
complainant. Subsection (1) of Section 202 of the Cr.PC was amended with effect 
from 23rd June 2006 by the Act No.25 of 2005. Subsection (1) of Section 202 of the
Cr.PC, as amended, reads thus:

> > **“202. Postponement of issue of process.—**
> > (1) Any Magistrate, on receipt of a complaint of an offence of which he is authorised
> > to take cognizance or which has been made over to him under section 192, may,
> > if he thinks fit, **and shall, in a case where the accused is residing at a 
> > place beyond the area in which he exercises his jurisdiction, **postpone the
> > issue of process against the accused, and either inquire into the case himself
> > or direct an investigation to be made by a police officer or by such other person
> > as he thinks fit, for the purpose of deciding whether or not there is sufficient
> > ground for proceeding:
> > Provided that no such direction for investigation shall be made,—
> > (a) where it appears to the Magistrate that the offence complained of is triable
> > exclusively by the Court of Session; or
> > (b) where the complaint has not been made by a Court, unless the complainant
> > and the witnesses present (if any) have been examined on oath under section 
> > 200.**”**

**(emphasis added)**

The portion starting from “and” and ending with “his jurisdiction” was added with
effect from 23rd June 2006. The requirement of postponing the issue of the process
was introduced on 23rd June 2006 which is applicable only when one of the accused
stays outside the jurisdiction of the court. The said requirement is held to be 
mandatory. The mandatory requirement of postponing the issue of the process because
the accused was residing at a place beyond the area where the learned Magistrate
exercises his jurisdiction was not applicable when the complaint was filed in 2004.
The mandate introduced with effect from 23rd June 2006 was not applicable on the
date of filing of the complaint. We are not examining whether the amended provision
will apply to a complaint filed before 23rd June 2006 in which the order of issue
of process has been passed after 23rd June 2006.

##### Magistrate called for report under section 202 cr.p.c after evidence (sworn) was over

> **9) **We may note here that when the order dated 15^(th) December 2011, calling
> for the report from the concerned Police Station under Section 202 of the Cr.PC
> was passed, the learned Magistrate had already recorded the evidence of the 1st
> respondent complainant and two witnesses–S.C.Mahto (CW1) and Rajiv Kumar (CW3).
> Therefore, after recording the evidence of the three witnesses, the learned Magistrate
> was not satisfied that the material on the record of the complaint, including 
> the testimony of the three witnesses, was sufficient to pass the summoning order.
> That is why the learned Magistrate had called for the report under Section 202
> of the Cr.PC.

##### Police did not file the report under section 202 cr.p.c

**10) **Initially, some controversy was raised as the order dated 17th December 
2012, passed by the learned Magistrate, records that a report was received. Therefore,
we called for a soft copy of the record of the complaint. The record reveals that
the report referred to in the order dated 17th December 2012 was submitted by the
Police, seeking two more months to file the report. It is an admitted position that
on record of the complaint, the report made by the Police under Section 202 of the
Cr.PC was not received. In any case, Shri Kanwardeep Kaur, IPS, Senior Superintendent
of Police, Union Territory of Chandigarh, in the affidavit filed on 24^(th) October
2023, categorically stated that the Police did not file the report under Section
202 of the Cr.PC till 16th July 2013, when the summoning order was issued by the
learned Magistrate.

##### Magistrate ought to have waited till the report was received but summoned the accused

> **11) **After recording the evidence of the three witnesses and perusing the documents
> on record, the learned Magistrate passed the order calling for the report under
> Section 202 of the Cr.PC. He postponed the issue of the process. The learned Magistrate
> ought to have waited until the report was received. He had an option of conducting
> an inquiry contemplated by subsection (1) of Section 202 of the Cr.PC himself 
> due to the delay on the part of the Police in submitting the report. But, he did
> not exercise the said option. For issuing the order of summoning, the learned 
> Magistrate could not have relied upon the same material which was before him on
> 15^(th) December 2011 when he passed the order calling for the report under Section
> 202 of the Cr.PC. The reason is that, obviously, he was not satisfied that the
> material was sufficient to pass the summoning order. It is not the case of the
> 1^(st) respondent complainant that when the learned Magistrate passed the order
> dated 16th July 2013, there was some additional material on record. At least, 
> the order of the learned Magistrate does not say so. The order does not even consider
> the earlier order dated 15th December 2011 calling for the report under subsection(
> 1) of Section 202 of the Cr.PC. The order issuing process has drastic consequences.
> Such orders require the application of mind. Such orders cannot be passed casually.
> Therefore, in our view, the learned Magistrate was not justified in passing the
> order to issue a summons.

##### Remand is warranted

**12) **Therefore, an order of remand is warranted. But, we cannot overlook that
the complaint subject matter of these appeals was filed on 17th July 2004, and the
order of summoning was passed nine years thereafter, i.e. on 13^(th) August 2013.
The complaint is nearly twenty years old; even the summoning order was passed eleven
years ago. Therefore, we allowed the learned senior counsel appearing for the parties
to address us on merits. We may note that the High Court has not recorded cogent
reasons for not entertaining the prayer for quashing the complaint. The only reason
given by the High Court is that there were disputed questions of fact, and therefore,
the controversy can be decided only after evidence is recorded.

##### Dispute is civil nature and no allegation that the accused company was involved in transaction between 2^(nd) accused and 1^(st) respondent-complaint

**15) **In fact, the entire dispute is of a civil nature arising out of a commercial
transaction. Therefore, in our considered view, taking the complaint and documents
relied upon by the 1st respondent–complainant as correct, no case was made in the
complaint or in the evidence of the 1st respondent to proceed against the appellants.
The evidence of CW3 (Rajiv Kumar) shows that he has stated that the 2nd, 5th and
6^(th) respondents in the Criminal Appeal of accused no.2 had approached the 1st
respondent–complainant and had represented that the accused company is a limited
company and accused nos.2 to 4 are its Directors. There is no allegation that the
accused company was involved, in any manner, with the transaction between the 2nd
accused and the 1st respondent–complainant. Hence, continuing the complaint against
the appellants will amount to an abuse of the process of law. Therefore, a case 
is made out for quashing the complaint as against the appellants.

##### Quash set-aside and allowed the appeal

**16) **Hence, the Appeals must succeed. The impugned judgment dated 25th August
2014 is set aside insofar as the appellants are concerned. The complaint bearing
Criminal Complaint no.128 dated 17th July 2004 pending in the Court of Judicial 
Magistrate, 1st Class, Chandigarh is, hereby, quashed only insofar as the appellants
are concerned. The complaint will proceed against the rest of the accused. The other
accused can raise appropriate defences at the time of framing charge or Trial. The
Appeals are partly allowed on the above terms with no order as to costs.

##### **Party**

**Shiv Jatia … Appellant ****versus ****Gian Chand Malick & Ors … Respondents**–**
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.776 OF 2024 – February 23, 2024 – 2024 INSC 142**

[click here to go direct link](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2014/38101/38101_2014_7_1501_50745_Judgement_23-Feb-2024.pdf)

[Shiv-Jatia-vs.-Gian-Chand-Malick-38101_2014_7_1501_50745_Judgement_23-Feb-2024](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/Shiv-Jatia-vs.-Gian-Chand-Malick-38101_2014_7_1501_50745_Judgement_23-Feb-2024.pdf)

##### Further study

 * [Cr.P.C., 1973. Notes no.2: A General Introduction (with powers of police)](http://localhost:8080/section1/cr-p-c-1973-notes-no-2-a-general-introduction-with-powers-of-police/)
 * [Limitation: Court cannot use the judgment decided on the complaint case for police cases](http://localhost:8080/section1/limitation-court-cannot-use-the-judgment-decided-on-the-complaint-case-for-police-cases/)
 * [WHETHER FIR CAN BE REGISTRERED IN ANY POLICE STATION?](http://localhost:8080/section1/whether-fir-can-be-registrered-in-any-police-station/)
 * [COMPLAINT – VALIDITY OF SECOND COMPLIANT](http://localhost:8080/section1/validity-of-second-compliant/)
 * [Cr.P.C., 1973. Notes no.9: Second FIR, General propositions as to FIR, appreciation & Evidentiary value of first information report (Chapter XII – Part.3, 4, 5 & 6)](http://localhost:8080/section1/cr-p-c-1973-notes-no-9-second-fir-general-propositions-as-to-fir-appreciation-evidentiary-value-of-first-information-report-chapter-xii-part-3-4-5-6/)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
