# Section 27 IEA: I.O did not narrate the exact words spoken by the accused while making a disclosure statement

- Link: https://section1.in/section-27-iea-i-o-did-not-narrate-the-exact-words-spoken-by-the-accused-while-making-a-disclosure-statement/
- Published: 2024-04-21T20:56:06+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Challenge against the appeal dismissed by the Hon’ble High Court of M.P](https://section1.in/section-27-iea-i-o-did-not-narrate-the-exact-words-spoken-by-the-accused-while-making-a-disclosure-statement/#challenge-against-the-appeal-dismissed-by-the-honble-high-court-of-mp)
 * [FIR on Robbery and assault but did not identify the assailant](https://section1.in/section-27-iea-i-o-did-not-narrate-the-exact-words-spoken-by-the-accused-while-making-a-disclosure-statement/#fir-on-robbery-and-assault-but-did-not-identify-the-assailant)
 * [Appellant arrested on suspicion and articles were recovered from him and identified by the informant](https://section1.in/section-27-iea-i-o-did-not-narrate-the-exact-words-spoken-by-the-accused-while-making-a-disclosure-statement/#appellant-arrested-on-suspicion-and-articles-were-recovered-from-him-and-identified-by-the-informant)
 * [Final report and conclusion of Trial and Appeal](https://section1.in/section-27-iea-i-o-did-not-narrate-the-exact-words-spoken-by-the-accused-while-making-a-disclosure-statement/#final-report-and-conclusion-of-trial-and-appeal)
 * [Trial court conviction on recovery](https://section1.in/section-27-iea-i-o-did-not-narrate-the-exact-words-spoken-by-the-accused-while-making-a-disclosure-statement/#trial-court-conviction-on-recovery)
 * [I.O did not narrate the exact words spoken by the accused while making a disclosure statement](https://section1.in/section-27-iea-i-o-did-not-narrate-the-exact-words-spoken-by-the-accused-while-making-a-disclosure-statement/#io-did-not-narrate-the-exact-words-spoken-by-the-accused-while-making-a-disclosure-statement)
 * [Prosecution did not lead any evidence to show that the recovered articles were sealed at the time of recovery](https://section1.in/section-27-iea-i-o-did-not-narrate-the-exact-words-spoken-by-the-accused-while-making-a-disclosure-statement/#prosecution-did-not-lead-any-evidence-to-show-that-the-recovered-articles-were-sealed-at-the-time-of-recovery)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/section-27-iea-i-o-did-not-narrate-the-exact-words-spoken-by-the-accused-while-making-a-disclosure-statement/#party)
 * [Further study](https://section1.in/section-27-iea-i-o-did-not-narrate-the-exact-words-spoken-by-the-accused-while-making-a-disclosure-statement/#further-study)

##### **Challenge against the appeal dismissed by the Hon’ble High Court of M.P**

2. This appeal is directed against the judgment dated 21st December, 2022 passed
by the learned Single Judge of the Madhya Pradesh High Court Bench at Indore in 
Criminal Appeal No. 1427 of 1999 whereby, the appeal preferred by the appellant 
under Section 374 (2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 was dismissed. By 
way of the said appeal, the appellant had challenged the judgment dated 20th October,
1999 passed by the learned First Additional Sessions Judge, Mandsaur, M.P. in S.
T. No. 34 of 1999 whereby, the appellant was convicted for the **[offences punishable](https://section1.in/custody-death-or-station-death-if-the-death-takes-place-inside-the-police-station-the-accused-persons-should-be-punished-for-the-offence-under-section-302-ipc/)**
under Sections 394 read with Section 397 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter
being referred to as ‘IPC’) and sentenced to undergo seven years rigorous imprisonment
with a fine of Rs. 1,000/- and, in default of payment of fine, to undergo further
rigorous imprisonment of three months.

##### **FIR on Robbery and assault but did not identify the assailant**

3. The substratum of the prosecution story is that on 12th December, 1998 at about
10:30 am, while the complainant Bhagu Bai was proceeding to her field, a person 
came from behind, closed her eyes, assaulted her with a knife and snatched away 
the silver anklet, a silver necklace and a silver bracelet which were worn by her.
After committing the crime and injuring the complainant in the process, the assailant
ran away from the spot. The complainant stated in the First Information Report (
FIR) that she was not able to see or identify the assailant.

##### **Appellant arrested on suspicion and articles were recovered from him and identified by the informant**

4. Be that as it may, the appellant was arrested on 14th December, 1998 on the basis
of suspicion. It is alleged that upon being interrogated by the police, the accused
appellant made a confession/disclosure** [statement which was recorded](https://section1.in/observation-of-honble-high-court-that-once-the-police-recorded-statements-of-the-doctor-and-pw-4-the-statements-of-pw-4-and-the-doctor-before-the-court-became-meaningless-is-contrary-to-sect/)**
as Memorandum (Exhibit P-11). It is further stated that **[acting on the said disclosure statement](https://section1.in/fact-discovered-and-recovery-mahazar-witnesses/),**
the Investigating Officer(PW-12) recovered the silver articles allegedly looted 
by the accused after assaulting the complainant. These articles were seized vide
panchnama (Exhibit P-12). The prosecution further claimed that the articles so seized
at the instance of the accused were got identified at the hands of the complainant
before an Executive Magistrate.

##### **Final report and conclusion of Trial and Appeal**

5. **[Charge sheet was filed](https://section1.in/section-420-ipc-the-contention-that-since-charge-sheet-has-been-filed-the-present-appeal-is-to-be-dismissed-was-rejected/)**
against the accused appellant for the above offences and the case was committed 
to the Sessions Court for trial. The accused was charged and tried for the offences
mentioned above.

6. At the conclusion of trial, the trial Court proceeded to convict and sentence
the appellant as above. The High Court, affirmed the conviction and sentence of 
the accused as recorded by the **[trial Court](https://section1.in/suo-moto-guidelines-common-practice-and-procedure-in-criminal-trials-all-over-india/)**
and rejected the appeal filed by the accused vide judgment dated 21st December, 
2022 which is assailed in this appeal.

##### **Trial court conviction on recovery**

8. The learned **[trial Court convicted the appellant by recording](https://section1.in/reversal-of-acquittal-appellate-court-cannot-reverse-the-acquittal-on-fresh-appreciation-of-evidence-and-without-recording-any-illegality-error-of-law-or-of-fact-in-the-trial-court-judgment/)**
the following finding: –

“According to the analysis done by above, it is proved that on the information of
the accused, the jewellery looted from complainant was seized, which was seized 
immediately two days after the incident. Therefore, there is no possibility at all
that these **[ornaments could have come into the possession of the accused](https://section1.in/accused-has-to-explain-the-possession-of-stolen-ornaments/)**
in any other way. As a result, it is proved that it was the accused who took away
these ornaments from the complainant while assaulting her and robbed of.”

##### **I.O did not narrate the exact words spoken by the accused while making a disclosure statement**

12. A bare perusal of the extracted portion of the deposition of the** [Investigating Officer](https://section1.in/in-cross-case-or-case-in-counter-the-i-o-has-to-file-both-the-final-reports-before-the-jurisdictional-magistrate/)**
would reveal that he did not narrate the exact words spoken by the accused at the
time of making the disclosure statement. He also did not state that the accused 
led him to the place where the articles were hidden and rather stated that he took
the accused to the Beed and got recovered the silver ornaments.

13. This Court in the case of [Ramanand alias Nandlal Bharti v. State of Uttar Pradesh](https://section1.in/all-about-extra-judicial-confession/)**[
2022 SCC OnLine SC 1396]** has postulated that for proving a disclosure memo recorded
under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 at the instance of the accused,
the Investigating Officer would be required to state about the contents of the disclosure
memo and in absence thereof, the disclosure memo and the discovery of facts made
in pursuance thereto would not be considered as admissible for want of proper proof.

##### **Prosecution did not lead any evidence to show that the recovered articles were sealed at the time of recovery**

14. As a consequence of the above discussion, we have no hesitation in holding that
the prosecution miserably failed to **[prove the factum of disclosure made by the accused](https://section1.in/juvenile-justice-act-2015-though-offences-pocso-and-murder-have-been-proved-accused-acquitted-based-on-procedural-illegalities/)**
to the Investigating Officer (PW-12) leading to the recovery of the silver articles
allegedly looted by the accused from the complainant. It is also important to **
[note](https://section1.in/cr-p-c-1973-notes-no-6-general-introduction-to-inquiries-and-trials-part-4-criminal-courts-powers-administration/)**
that the prosecution did not lead any evidence to show that the recovered articles
were sealed at the time of recovery or that they were kept secure in the malkhana
of the Police Station till the same were subjected to identification before the 
Executive Magistrate. In addition thereto, it is also relevant that the Executive
Magistrate was not examined in evidence. The complainant Bhagu Bai (PW-3) made a
categorical admission in her cross examination that she could recognize the silver
articles in the test identification proceedings upon being pointed out by the police
officials. Thus, the recovery of the ornaments at the instance of the accused and
the identification thereof has no sanctity in the eyes of law and cannot be relied
upon. No other evidence was led by the prosecution to connect the accused appellant
with the crime.

**[Accused ](https://section1.in/juvenile-justice-act-2015-though-offences-pocso-and-murder-have-been-proved-accused-acquitted-based-on-procedural-illegalities/)
[acquitted](https://section1.in/category/acquittal/)**

##### **Party**

**HANSRAJ …APPELLANT(S) VERSUS STATE OF M.P. …RESPONDENT(S) – CRIMINAL APPEAL NO(
S). OF 2024 (Arising out of SLP (Crl.) No(s). 4626 of 2024) – 2024 INSC 318 – April
19, 2024.**

**[https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2023/16599/16599_2023_3_1503_52325_Judgement_19-Apr-2024.pdf](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2023/16599/16599_2023_3_1503_52325_Judgement_19-Apr-2024.pdf)**

**[Hansraj-vs.-State-of-M.P-16599_2023_3_1503_52325_Judgement_19-Apr-2024](https://section1.in/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/Hansraj-vs.-State-of-M.P-16599_2023_3_1503_52325_Judgement_19-Apr-2024.pdf)**

articles not sealed, disclosure statement, i.o did not speak exact words of accused,
recovery,

##### Further study

 * **[Section 27 Evidence Act: Disclosure statements are per se not an individual evidence without corroboration to secure conviction](https://section1.in/fact-discovered-and-recovery-mahazar-witnesses/)**
 * **[WHETHER STATEMENT or LETTER MADE TO THE INVESTIGATION OFFICER (I.O) DURING THE INVESTIGATION IS ADMISSIBLE? – NO.](https://section1.in/whether-statement-or-letter-made-to-the-investigation-officer-i-o-during-the-investigation-is-admissible-no/)**
 * **[Murder case: Appreciation of evidence – Circumstantial evidence & recovery under section 27 Indian Evidence Act](https://section1.in/appreciation-of-evidence-circumstantial-evidence-recovery-u-s-27-iea/)**
 * **[Court can grant pardon even for other offences (other than IPC) if connected with the present one](https://section1.in/court-can-grant-pardon-even-for-other-offences-if-connected-with-the-present-one/)**
 * **[Murder: Prosecution did not proved the murder case beyond reasonable doubt](https://section1.in/prosecution-not-proved-the-murder-case-beyond-reasonable-doubt/)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
