# Section 306 IPC: Suicide: Break ups and expressing emotions through words do not constitute instigation to commit suicide but suicides depend on the victim’s mental state

- Link: https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/
- Published: 2024-11-30T12:30:45+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Facts](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#facts)
    - [Appeal against the conviction of offences under sections 417 and 306 IPC by the Hon’ble High Court](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#appeal-against-the-conviction-of-offences-under-sections-417-and-306-ipc-by-the-honble-high-court)
    - [Appellant did not marry the girl as he promised since the girl committed suicide](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#appellant-did-not-marry-the-girl-as-he-promised-since-the-girl-committed-suicide)
    - [Girl consumed poison and died in the hospital after giving statements (dying declaration) to witnesses](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#girl-consumed-poison-and-died-in-the-hospital-after-giving-statements-dying-declaration-to-witnesses)
    - [Mother (P.W-1) of the deceased lodged FIR under sections 306 r/w 34 IPC](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#mother-pw1-of-the-deceased-lodged-fir-under-sections-306-rw-34-ipc)
    - [After Trial the Sessions court acquitted the appellant that there is no charge against appellant in her dying declaration](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#after-trial-the-sessions-court-acquitted-the-appellant-that-there-is-no-charge-against-appellant-in-her-dying-declaration)
    - [Reason for acquittal is that only the deceased was in love with appellant and not vice versa](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#reason-for-acquittal-is-that-only-the-deceased-was-in-love-with-appellant-and-not-vice-versa)
    - [Hon’ble High Court has convicted the accused](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#honble-high-court-has-convicted-the-accused)
 * [Analysis](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#analysis)
    - [Two dying declarations in this case](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#two-dying-declarations-in-this-case)
    - [Dying declaration recorded by PSI (police)](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#dying-declaration-recorded-by-psi-police)
    - [Dying declaration recorded by Taluka Executive Magistrate](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#dying-declaration-recorded-by-taluka-executive-magistrate)
    - [Dying declaration was endorsed by the doctor](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#dying-declaration-was-endorsed-by-the-doctor)
    - [Dying declarations revealed there is no allegation of physical relationship and indicated only the deceased was in love with the accused](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#dying-declarations-revealed-there-is-no-allegation-of-physical-relationship-and-indicated-only-the-deceased-was-in-love-with-the-accused)
    - [No allegation of appellant instigated deceased to consume poison or had any physical relationship](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#no-allegation-of-appellant-instigated-deceased-to-consume-poison-or-had-any-physical-relationship)
 * [Discussion on offence](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#discussion-on-offence)
    - [Abetment of suicide: Section 306 IPC](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#abetment-of-suicide-section-306-ipc)
    - [Abetment is an essential element for punishing under section 306 IPC](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#abetment-is-an-essential-element-for-punishing-under-section-306-ipc)
    - [Abetment: section 107 IPC](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#abetment-section-107-ipc)
    - [Instigation to do a particular thing is necessary](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#instigation-to-do-a-particular-thing-is-necessary)
    - [Instigation explained](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#instigation-explained)
    - [Uttering words in emotions is not instigation and not amount to intentionally inciting other party to do any act of suicide](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#uttering-words-in-emotions-is-not-instigation-and-not-amount-to-intentionally-inciting-other-party-to-do-any-act-of-suicide)
    - [Courts observed that differences in domestic life are quite common in society and commission of suicides are largely depends upon the mental state of the victim](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#courts-observed-that-differences-in-domestic-life-are-quite-common-in-society-and-commission-of-suicides-are-largely-depends-upon-the-mental-state-of-the-victim)
 * [Judgments discussed](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#judgments-discussed)
 * [Break ups of relationship would not constitute instigation](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#break-ups-of-relationship-would-not-constitute-instigation)
 * [No direct evidence to prove appellant instigated or provoked the deceased to commit suicide](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#no-direct-evidence-to-prove-appellant-instigated-or-provoked-the-deceased-to-commit-suicide)
 * [Breach of promise to marry is a simple case of broken relationship does not constitute offence](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#breach-of-promise-to-marry-is-a-simple-case-of-broken-relationship-does-not-constitute-offence)
    - [Party](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-suicide-break-ups-and-expressing-emotions-through-words-do-not-constitute-instigation-to-commit-suicide-but-suicides-depend-on-the-victims-mental-state/#party)

#### **Facts**

##### **Appeal against the conviction of offences under sections 417 and 306 IPC by the Hon’ble High Court**

1. The accused-appellant was charged under Sections 417, 376 and 306 of the Indian
Penal Code. The trial court acquitted him of all the above offences, but on appeal
by the State of Karnataka to the High Court, he was convicted for the offences under
Sections 417 and 306 IPC. However, the acquittal under Section 376 IPC was maintained.
He was awarded sentence of 1 year under Section 417 IPC with a fine of Rs.5,000/-;
and with a sentence of 4 years for the offence under Section 306 IPC with a fine
of Rs.20,000/-. Basically, the conviction of the accused-appellant is for the offences
of cheating and for abetment of suicide only.

##### **Appellant did not marry the girl as he promised since the girl committed suicide**

2. A girl named Suvarna, aged about 21 years, was in love with the accused-appellant
for the past 8 years i.e. she was in love with him since the age of 13 years. It
is alleged that the accused-appellant had promised to marry her but when he refused,
she consumed poison and committed suicide.

##### **Girl consumed poison and died in the hospital after giving statements (dying declaration) to witnesses**

3. It is alleged that the accused-appellant, Kamruddin Dastagir Sanadi, had promised
to marry the deceased before the jamaat (panchayath) but 4 months prior to the incident,
he had left the village and started living at Kakati, Karnataka. The deceased came
to Kakati in the evening of 18.08.2007 and when the accused-appellant clearly refused
to marry her, she left. The deceased spent the whole night at the bus stand at Kakati
and in the morning consumed poison which she had brought with her from Gadhinglaj.
One Badshaha (PW- 3 5), relative of the accused-appellant, found her lying at the
bus stand and took her to hospital at about 08:50 am on 19.08.2007. PSI Kakati (
PW-15) recorded the statement of the deceased between 3 pm and 4 pm & thereafter
sent a requisition to the Executive Magistrate to record the deceased’s dying declaration.
The dying declaration of the deceased was recorded by the Taluka Executive Magistrate,
Belgaum (PW-11) in the presence of the doctor (PW-12) between 04.50 pm and 05.20
pm. Thereafter, she died in the hospital on the same day itself i.e. on 19.08.2007.

##### **Mother (P.W-1) of the deceased lodged FIR under sections 306 r/w 34 IPC**

4. The mother of the deceased (PW-1) lodged an FIR on 20.08.2007 under Section 306
read with Section 34 IPC at the Police Station, Kakati, Circle Belgaum Rural District,
Karnataka against the accused-appellant and his uncle, alleging that the accused-
appellant had deceived her daughter by promising to marry her and then refusing 
it, which led to the commission of suicide by her in frustration.

##### **After Trial the Sessions court acquitted the appellant that there is no charge against appellant in her dying declaration**

5. After investigation, a chargesheet was drawn and submitted charging the accused-
appellant under Sections 417, 376 and 306 IPC. The accused-appellant was arrested
on 20.08.2007 and later released on bail during the trial. The IInd Additional Sessions
Judge, Belgaum, vide judgment and order dated 13.04.2010 acquitted the accused-appellant
of all the charges as there was no allegation in the dying declaration that the 
accused-appellant ever had any sexual intercourse with the deceased on the pretext
of promise to marry her or ever had any physical relationship with her. Her only
allegation was that she consumed poison as he refused to marry her. There was no
allegation that the accused appellant instigated her to consume poison or to commit
suicide.

##### **Reason for acquittal is that only the deceased was in love with appellant and not vice versa**

6. Moreover, the statement of mother of the deceased (PW-1) revealed that it was
only the deceased who was in love with the accused-appellant and not the other way
around. The deceased had impressed upon her mother to convince the accused-appellant
to marry her as she was in love with him. The mother of the deceased (PW-1) nowhere
stated that the accused-appellant was in love with her daughter. No other evidence
was there to prove that any physical relationship was established by the accused-
appellant with the deceased except that he had agreed to marry her before the panchayath,
which was not proved.

7. Thus, in the facts and circumstances of the case coupled with the fact that there
was no evidence to suggest that the accused-appellant had instigated or aided the
deceased in consuming poison and committing suicide, the trial court acquitted the
accused-appellant.

##### **Hon’ble High Court has convicted the accused**

8. On appeal by the State of Karnataka, the High Court convicted the accused-appellant
under Sections 417 and 306 IPC. Thus, the present appeal.

9. Learned counsel for the parties were heard at length and ease.

#### **Analysis**

##### **Two dying declarations in this case**

12. The deceased left behind two dying declarations which are on record. Exh.P17
is the dying declaration recorded by PSI, Kakati (PW-15) whereas Exh.P10 is another
dying declaration recorded later by the Taluka Executive Magistrate, Belgaum (PW-
11) in the presence of the doctor (PW-12) in the hospital between 04:50 pm to 05:
20 pm on 19.08.2007.

##### **Dying declaration recorded by PSI (police)**

13. The dying declaration of the deceased duly recorded by PSI, Kakati states that
the deceased was a 21 year old girl studying in MA 1st year. She was in love with
the accused- 7 appellant who had left the village 4 months back and had started 
residing at Kakati, Belgaum. Allegedly about 8 days before the incident, he had 
called on her phone and asked her to come to Kakati. She reached Kakati in the evening
of 18.08.2007 and met him at Avanti Hotel. She asked him to marry her but he refused
to marry and left. She, thereafter, went to the bus stop and consumed poison which
she had brought with her from Gadhinglaj.

##### **Dying declaration recorded by Taluka Executive Magistrate**

14. The dying declaration recorded later by Taluka Executive Magistrate (PW-11),
Belgaum, on 19.08.2007 states that she was aged about 21 years and was residing 
with her mother, elder sister and younger brother and was studying in MA 1st year.
She was having an affair with the accused-appellant since last 8 years. Their affair
came to the knowledge of the elder persons of both the families and all of them 
decided to perform the marriage. The accused-appellant agreed to marry her in front
of the elders of the village. He left the village about 4 months ago and when she
made inquiries about him, she came to know that he was residing at Kakati. She went
to Kakati and searched him and made a phone call. Then she met him at Avanti Hotel
and asked him to marry her but he refused. Thereafter, she consumed poison which
she had brought in a bottle from Gadhinglaj. She was shifted to the hospital for
treatment by a relative of the accused-appellant named Badshaha Nazir Pathan (PW-
5) of Kakati.

##### **Dying declaration was endorsed by the doctor**

15. The aforesaid statement was made in Marathi and a translated copy was put on
record. The doctor had certified that the patient was fully conscious and fit to
give statement. The Executive Magistrate, Belgaum, has recorded that the deceased
had a frustrated mentality.

##### **Dying declarations revealed there is no allegation of physical relationship and indicated only the deceased was in love with the accused**

16. The dying declaration of the deceased reveals that there is no allegation of
any physical relationship between the accused appellant and the deceased or that
the accused-appellant had ever entered into any physical relationship or had sexual
intercourse with the deceased under the pretext of marriage. The dying declaration
indicates that it was the deceased who was in love with the accused-appellant and
wanted to marry him. When the accused-appellant had left the village, it was the
deceased who made search about him and came to know that he was residing in Kakati.
She herself traced him out at Kakati and went after him. She called him and when
they met, he refused to marry her and thus, as her sentiments were hurt, she consumed
poison leading to her death.

##### **No allegation of appellant instigated deceased to consume poison or had any physical relationship**

17. There is no allegation by her that the accused-appellant had instigated her 
to consume poison or to commit suicide. No other evidence in this regard has been
adduced. Even the mother of the deceased (PW-1) in her statement revealed that it
was the deceased who was in love with the accusedappellant and that she wanted her
mother to convince him to marry her. The said witness though may have stated that
the deceased entered into physical relationship with her daughter but the same otherwise
does not stand proved or corroborated, not even by the dying declarations. As regards
the promise to marry alleged to have been made by the accused-appellant, it is said
that the same was made before the village elders in context with which Najaruddin
Mohammad Malik (PW-3) and Kashim Babalal Sankeshwar (PW-4) were examined. Both these
witnesses have stated that they had provided a written document regarding the panchayath
proceedings to the deceased and her mother but no such document was produced by 
PW-1 to prove that the accused-appellant had actually ever promised or agreed to
marry her daughter. There is allegation but no evidence to prove that the accused-
appellant was also in love with the deceased or that he was in touch with her in
any manner. The allegation that both of them were talking to each other on phone
is without any substance as no evidence was produced in the form of call records
of either of them to establish that the accused-appellant used to call the deceased
and talk to her and to establish that he was also in love with her. There is no 
evidence to even establish that the accused-appellant entered into any physical 
relationship with the deceased on the pretext of marrying her. So, the evidence 
fails to prove any physical relationship between the two, promise to marry on the
part of the accused-appellant and that he was instrumental in instigating the deceased
to consume poison or to commit suicide.

#### **Discussion on offence**

##### **Abetment of suicide: Section 306 IPC**

18. Section 306 IPC defines abetment of suicide which reads as under:

> “306. If any person commits suicide, whoever abets the commission of such suicide,
> shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may
> extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine.”

##### **Abetment is an essential element for punishing under section 306 IPC**

19. It provides for the punishment for abetting the commission of suicide. Therefore,‘
abetment’ of suicide is an essential element for punishing a person for an offence
under Section 306 IPC.

##### **Abetment: section 107 IPC**

20. Abetment has been defined under Section 107 IPC and it reads as under:

> “107. Abetment of a thing.- A person abets the doing of a thing, who
> First.- Instigates any person to do that thing; or
> Secondly.- Engages with one or more other person or persons in any conspiracy 
> for the doing of that thing, if an act or illegal omission takes place in pursuance
> of that conspiracy, and in order to the doing of that thing; or
> Thirdly.- Intentionally aids, by any act or illegal omission, the doing of that
> thing.”

##### **Instigation to do a particular thing is necessary**

21. The very first clause of the aforesaid provision lays down that a person, who
abets the doing of a thing, is a person who instigates any person to do that thing.
Therefore, ‘instigation’ to do a particular thing is necessary for charging a person
with abetment.

##### **Instigation explained**

> 22. ‘Instigation’ is to provoke, incite or encourage a person to do an act.

23. This Court has repeatedly observed that abetment involves a mental process of
instigating a person or intentionally aiding a person in doing of a particular thing
and without the positive act on part of the accused there would be no instigation.
It has also been observed that to convict a person for abetment of suicide under
Section 306 IPC, there has to be a clear mens rea on the part of the accused to 
abet such a crime and it requires an active act or a direct act leading to the commission
of suicide.

##### **Uttering words in emotions is not instigation and not amount to intentionally inciting other party to do any act of suicide**

24. In **Ramesh Kumar vs. State of Chhattisgarh [(2001) 9 SCC 618]**, a three Judges
Bench of this Court dealt with a case of suicide by the wife, where the husband 
in anger uttered- ‘You are free to do whatever you wish and go wherever you like’.
Thereafter, the wife committed suicide. The Court, after examining the meaning of
instigation which is an essential element for abetment of suicide, observed that
such words, uttered out of emotion, do not constitute mens rea and do not amount
to intentionally inciting the other party to actually do an act which may result
in the commission of self-killing/suicide.

##### **Courts observed that differences in domestic life are quite common in society and commission of suicides are largely depends upon the mental state of the victim**

25. Even in cases where the victim commits suicide, which may be as a result of 
cruelty meted out to her, the Courts have always held that discord and differences
in domestic life are quite common in society and that the commission of such an 
offence largely depends upon the mental state of the victim. Surely, until and unless
some guilty intention on the part of the accused is established, it is ordinarily
not possible to convict him for an offence under Section 306 IPC.

#### **Judgments discussed**

**M. Mohan vs. State represented by the Deputy Superintendent of Police – (2011)
3 SCC 626 [paras. 44, 45 & 46]**

**Amalendu Pal alias Jhantu vs. State of West Bengal – (2010) 1 SCC 707**

**Prabhu vs. State represented by Inspector of Police & Anr – 2024 SCC Online SC
137**

#### **Break ups of relationship would not constitute instigation**

28. In **Prabhu (supra)** the Court further observed that broken relationships and
heart breaks are part of everyday life and that breaking-up of the relationship 
would not constitute any instigation or abetment of suicide inasmuch as in order
to constitute ‘Instigation’ it must be shown that the accused had by his acts and
omissions or by continued course of conduct created such circumstances that the 
deceased was left with no other option except to commit suicide.

#### **No direct evidence to prove appellant instigated or provoked the deceased to commit suicide**

29. There is no direct evidence adduced by the prosecution to prove that the accused-
appellant has in any way instigated or provoked the deceased to commit suicide. 
The accusedappellant on asking of the deceased had simply refused to marry her which
is not a positive act on his part with any intention to abet the crime of suicide.

#### **Breach of promise to marry is a simple case of broken relationship does not constitute offence**

31. Even assuming, though there is no evidence that the accused-appellant promised
to marry the deceased, that there was such a promise, it is again a simple case 
of a broken relationship for which there is a different cause of action, but not
prosecution or conviction for an offence under Section 306, specially in the facts
and circumstances of the case where no guilty intention or mens rea on the part 
of the accused-appellant had been established.

32. In view of the facts and circumstances of the case, we are of the opinion that
the judgment and order of the High Court dated 15.12.2011 cannot be sustained in
law and is hereby set aside and the accused-appellant stands acquitted as was done
by the trial court.

33. The appeal is allowed with no order as to cost.

##### **Party**

Kamaruddin Dastagir Sanadi …Appellant(S) versus State Of Karnataka Through Sho Kakati
Police …Respondent(S) – Criminal Appeal NO. 551 OF 2012 – 2024 INSC 908

[Kamaruddin Dastagir Sanadi vs. State of Karnataka](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Kamaruddin-Dastagir-Sanadi-vs.-State-of-Karnataka.pdf)
[Download](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Kamaruddin-Dastagir-Sanadi-vs.-State-of-Karnataka.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
