# Section 364 IPC and section 302 IPC by no stretch of imagination can be construed as similar offences hence High Court is correct in reversing the conviction of section 364 though charged for section 302 IPC

- Link: https://section1.in/section-364-ipc-and-section-302-ipc-by-no-stretch-of-imagination-can-be-construed-as-similar-offences-hence-high-court-is-correct-in-reversing-the-conviction-of-section-364-though-charged-for-section/
- Published: 2026-03-21T15:26:52+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Appeal](https://section1.in/section-364-ipc-and-section-302-ipc-by-no-stretch-of-imagination-can-be-construed-as-similar-offences-hence-high-court-is-correct-in-reversing-the-conviction-of-section-364-though-charged-for-section/#appeal)
    - [State preferred appeal against the High Court acquitted the accused](https://section1.in/section-364-ipc-and-section-302-ipc-by-no-stretch-of-imagination-can-be-construed-as-similar-offences-hence-high-court-is-correct-in-reversing-the-conviction-of-section-364-though-charged-for-section/#state-preferred-appeal-against-the-high-court-acquitted-the-accused)
 * [Case of the prosecution](https://section1.in/section-364-ipc-and-section-302-ipc-by-no-stretch-of-imagination-can-be-construed-as-similar-offences-hence-high-court-is-correct-in-reversing-the-conviction-of-section-364-though-charged-for-section/#case-of-the-prosecution)
    - [Accused took the deceased to watch a movie, but found out the next day as a dead body with gunshot wounds](https://section1.in/section-364-ipc-and-section-302-ipc-by-no-stretch-of-imagination-can-be-construed-as-similar-offences-hence-high-court-is-correct-in-reversing-the-conviction-of-section-364-though-charged-for-section/#accused-took-the-deceased-to-watch-a-movie-but-found-out-the-next-day-as-a-dead-body-with-gunshot-wounds)
    - [Since the accused took the deceased from his house and the body found next day morning is sufficient to convict the accused for the offence punishable under section 364 IPC](https://section1.in/section-364-ipc-and-section-302-ipc-by-no-stretch-of-imagination-can-be-construed-as-similar-offences-hence-high-court-is-correct-in-reversing-the-conviction-of-section-364-though-charged-for-section/#since-the-accused-took-the-deceased-from-his-house-and-the-body-found-next-day-morning-is-sufficient-to-convict-the-accused-for-the-offence-punishable-under-section-364-ipc)
    - [Section 364 IPC is not a minor offence compared to section 302 IPC](https://section1.in/section-364-ipc-and-section-302-ipc-by-no-stretch-of-imagination-can-be-construed-as-similar-offences-hence-high-court-is-correct-in-reversing-the-conviction-of-section-364-though-charged-for-section/#section-364-ipc-is-not-a-minor-offence-compared-to-section-302-ipc)
 * [Analysis](https://section1.in/section-364-ipc-and-section-302-ipc-by-no-stretch-of-imagination-can-be-construed-as-similar-offences-hence-high-court-is-correct-in-reversing-the-conviction-of-section-364-though-charged-for-section/#analysis)
    - [High Court came to a conclusion that section 364 IPC cannot be said to be a lesser offence in relation to section 302 IPC within the meaning of section 222 Cr.P.C](https://section1.in/section-364-ipc-and-section-302-ipc-by-no-stretch-of-imagination-can-be-construed-as-similar-offences-hence-high-court-is-correct-in-reversing-the-conviction-of-section-364-though-charged-for-section/#high-court-came-to-a-conclusion-that-section-364-ipc-cannot-be-said-to-be-a-lesser-offence-in-relation-to-section-302-ipc-within-the-meaning-of-section-222-crpc)
    - [What is minor offence not defined under the Code but explained by Hon’ble Supreme Court](https://section1.in/section-364-ipc-and-section-302-ipc-by-no-stretch-of-imagination-can-be-construed-as-similar-offences-hence-high-court-is-correct-in-reversing-the-conviction-of-section-364-though-charged-for-section/#what-is-minor-offence-not-defined-under-the-code-but-explained-by-honble-supreme-court)
    - [Section 364 IPC and section 302 IPC by no stretch of imagination can be construed as similar offences hence High Court is correct in reversing the conviction of section 364 though charged for section 302 IPC](https://section1.in/section-364-ipc-and-section-302-ipc-by-no-stretch-of-imagination-can-be-construed-as-similar-offences-hence-high-court-is-correct-in-reversing-the-conviction-of-section-364-though-charged-for-section/#section-364-ipc-and-section-302-ipc-by-no-stretch-of-imagination-can-be-construed-as-similar-offences-hence-high-court-is-correct-in-reversing-the-conviction-of-section-364-though-charged-for-section)
 * [Conclusion](https://section1.in/section-364-ipc-and-section-302-ipc-by-no-stretch-of-imagination-can-be-construed-as-similar-offences-hence-high-court-is-correct-in-reversing-the-conviction-of-section-364-though-charged-for-section/#conclusion)
    - [No evidence of accused kidnapped the deceased forcefully further PW.2 gave a statement that the some other persons murdered his brother on hearsay](https://section1.in/section-364-ipc-and-section-302-ipc-by-no-stretch-of-imagination-can-be-construed-as-similar-offences-hence-high-court-is-correct-in-reversing-the-conviction-of-section-364-though-charged-for-section/#no-evidence-of-accused-kidnapped-the-deceased-forcefully-further-pw2-gave-a-statement-that-the-some-other-persons-murdered-his-brother-on-hearsay)
 * [Reference](https://section1.in/section-364-ipc-and-section-302-ipc-by-no-stretch-of-imagination-can-be-construed-as-similar-offences-hence-high-court-is-correct-in-reversing-the-conviction-of-section-364-though-charged-for-section/#reference)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/section-364-ipc-and-section-302-ipc-by-no-stretch-of-imagination-can-be-construed-as-similar-offences-hence-high-court-is-correct-in-reversing-the-conviction-of-section-364-though-charged-for-section/#party)

#### **Appeal**

##### **State preferred appeal against the High Court acquitted the accused**

1. State is questioning the correctness of the Judgment of the High Court of Judicature
at Allahabad rendered in Criminal Appeal No.3739 of 2009 dated 04.03.2009, whereunder
the appellant came to be acquitted who had been convicted by the Additional Sessions
Judge, Fast Track Court No. – 1 in Sessions Trial No.209 of 2001 on 27.06.2006 for
the offence punishable under Section 364 of IPC by reversing the said finding of
the Trial Court.

#### **Case of the prosecution**

##### **Accused took the deceased to watch a movie, but found out the next day as a dead body with gunshot wounds**

2. The gravamen of the prosecution case is: appellant had come to the house of the
complainant Shri Puran on 25.11.1998 and took Dinesh son of the complainant from
his home on the pretext of watching a movie and he never returned. It was stated
that his dead body was found the next morning with gun shot wounds and based on 
a written report lodged by the father of the deceased, an FIR came to be registered
for the offence punishable under Section 302 of IPC against the appellant and three
others. **On the basis of chargesheet material and after accused pleaded not guilty
the Sessions Judge framed the charge against the accused persons on 12.09.2003**.

##### **Since the accused took the deceased from his house and the body found next day morning is sufficient to convict the accused for the offence punishable under section 364 IPC**

3. To drive home the guilt of the accused persons the prosecution examined its witnesses
and learned Sessions Judge on appreciation of evidence by Judgment dated 27.06.2006
convicted the appellant, Accused no.2 for the offence punishable under Section 364
of IPC and acquitted all other accused of the charge under Section 302 of IPC. It
was held that though prosecution failed to prove the charge of murder under Section
302 of IPC, the fact that the accused took the deceased from his house and the body
was found next day morning had been fully established and this was sufficient to
convict the appellant for the offence punishable under Section 364 of IPC. It came
to be further held that since no enmity was there between deceased Ram Swaroop and
the appellant, the act of luring the deceased by the appellant was sufficient to
convict the appellant under Section 364 of IPC.

##### **Section 364 IPC is not a minor offence compared to section 302 IPC**

4. On appeal being filed the High Court by the impugned Judgment dated 04.03.2009
allowed the appeal primarily on the ground that no charge under Section 364 of IPC
was framed and held convicting the accused for the said charge without prior notice
would cause serious prejudice and had violated the fair trial norms. It was further
held that Section 364 of IPC is not a minor offence compared to Section 302 of IPC
and they involve distinct legal ingredients and cannot be interchanged as permitted
under Section 222 of Cr.P.C. It was further held that in the absence of any motive
attributed to the appellant, on the sole circumstances of deceased had gone with
the appellant cannot sustain conviction under Section 364 of IPC.

#### **Analysis**

##### **High Court came to a conclusion that section 364 IPC cannot be said to be a lesser offence in relation to section 302 IPC within the meaning of section 222 Cr.P.C**

8. Having heard the learned Counsels appearing for the parties, we deem it proper
to note that the charge framed against the appellant was for the offence punishable
under Section 302. While appreciating the evidence tendered by the prosecution, 
the learned Trial Judge took note of Section 362 of IPC to jump to a conclusion 
that accused Ram Swaroop – Appellant, who had arrived at the house of the deceased
and had called the deceased to accompany him on the pretext of watching a movie 
would fall within the ambit of committing the “abduction of deceased Dinesh” or 
in other words, the accused had exercised deceit upon deceased for the purpose of
securing him from his house with the object and motive of committing murder of the
deceased. Hence, the learned Trial Judge held the charge under Section 364 as proved
and established, though charge under Section 302 of IPC is sustainable. **The Appellate
Court found that admittedly no charge had been framed under Section 364 of IPC and
took note of Section 221 and 222 of Cr.P.C. which enables the Criminal Court to 
convict the accused of an offence which is not included in the charge, by holding
the primary condition for application of Section 221 is that the Court should have
felt at the time of framing of the charge as to which of the several acts (which
may be proved) will constitute the offence on account of the nature of the acts 
or series of acts alleged against the accused. It held that in such a case the Section
permits to convict the accused of the offence of which he is shown to have committed
though he was not charged with it. By relying upon the Judgment of Shamnsaheb M.
Multtani (supra), it arrived at a conclusion that the offence under Section 364 
of IPC cannot be said to be a lesser offence in relation to the offence under Section
302 of IPC to be brought within the meaning of Section 222 of Cr.P.C**.

##### **What is minor offence not defined under the Code but explained by Hon’ble Supreme Court**

> 9. The expression “minor offence” found in Section 222 is not defined under the
> Code, it can be discerned from the context which is not merely that the prescribed
> punishment is less than the major offence. **In other words, if the two offences
> are cognate offences and the main ingredients are common, the offence punishable
> with lesser sentence can be considered as a minor offence with reference to the
> other offence. **This Court in Shamnsaheb M. Multtani (supra) has held as under:-

“16. What is meant by “a minor offence” for the purpose of Section 222 of the Code?
Although the said expression is not defined in the Code it can be discerned from
the context that the test of minor offence is not merely that the prescribed punishment
is less than the major offence. The two illustrations provided in the section would
bring the above point home well. Only if the two offences are cognate offences, 
wherein the main ingredients are common, the one punishable among them with a lesser
sentence can be regarded as minor offence vis-à-vis the other offence.

17. The composition of the offence under Section 304-B IPC is vastly different from
the formation of the offence of murder under Section 302 IPC and hence the former
cannot be regarded as minor offence vis-à-vis the latter. However, the position 
would be different when the charge also contains the offence under Section 498-A
IPC (husband or relative of husband of a women subjecting her to cruelty). As the
word “cruelty” is explained as including, inter alia, “harassment of the woman where
such harassment is with a view to coercing her or any person related to her to meet
any unlawful demand for any property or valuable security or is on account of failure
by her or any person related to her to meet such demand””.

##### **Section 364 IPC and section 302 IPC by no stretch of imagination can be construed as similar offences hence High Court is correct in reversing the conviction of section 364 though charged for section 302 IPC**

    ```wp-block-verse
    10. The composition of the offence under Section 304-B is vastly different from the offence of murder indicated under Section 302 IPC and hence the former cannot be regarded as a minor offence vis-a-vis the latter. Section 222(1) of the Code deals with a case where a person is charged with an offence consisting of several particulars. The Section permits the Court to convict the accused of the minor offence though he was not charged with it. Sub section (2) deals with a similar, but slightly different situation. When a person is charged with an offence and facts are proved which reduces it to a minor offence he may be convicted of the minor offence although he is not charged with it. As noticed hereinabove, the expression “minor offence” is not defined under the Code, as to whether the act of abduction/ kidnapping defined under Section 364 can be construed as a minor offence would be the question. Section 364 of the IPC would indicate that if a person kidnaps or abducts any person in order that such person may be murdered or may be so disposed of as to be put in danger of being murdered would be punishable with imprisonment for life or rigorous imprisonment for a term which may extend to 10 years. This provision when compared with Section 302 would clearly indicate that they are separate and distinct offences and by no stretch of imagination can be construed as cognate offences. As such, we are of the considered view that the High Court was fully justified and correct in reversing the finding of the learned Trial Judge in convicting the appellant for the offence punishable under Section 364 though charged for 302 of IPC.
    ```

#### **Conclusion**

##### **No evidence of accused kidnapped the deceased forcefully further PW.2 gave a statement that the some other persons murdered his brother on hearsay**

11. We also note with benefit that there is no whisper either in the complaint or
in the chargesheet or in the evidence tendered on behalf of the prosecution namely
the deposition of PW-1 and PW-2 that is father and brother of the deceased indicating
that the appellant had forcefully taken the deceased from the house or the deceased
having been abducted by the appellant. In fact, PW-2 admits in his deposition that
he had given the statement that appellant, Satish and Ramesh had committed the murder
of his brother, on the basis of hearsay. These factors cumulatively persuade us 
to reject the contentions raised by the learned Counsel appearing for the Appellant.

#### **Reference **

**Judgments involved or cited**

 * Criminal Appeal No. 3739 of 2009 (High Court of Judicature at Allahabad): The
   impugned judgment dated 04.03.2009, which acquitted the respondent by reversing
   the Trial Court’s conviction.
 * Sessions Trial No. 209 of 2001 (Additional Sessions Judge, Fast Track Court No.
   1): The original trial judgment dated 27.06.2006, which convicted the appellant
   under Section 364 of the IPC.
 * _Rafiq Ahmad alias Rafi vs. State of Uttar Pradesh_ (2011) 8 SCC 300: Cited by
   the Appellant’s counsel to support the proposition that an accused can be convicted
   of a lesser offence even if charged with a “bigger” offence.
 * _Sangaraboina Sreenu vs. State of Andhra Pradesh_ (1997) 5 SCC 348: Relied upon
   by the Trial Court but noted by the Appellant’s counsel as having been overruled.
 * _Dalbir Singh vs. State of U.P._ (2004) 5 SCC 334: Cited as the authority that
   overruled the _Sangaraboina Sreenu_ judgment.
 * _Shamnsaheb M. Multtani vs. State of Karnataka_ (2001) 2 SCC 577: Relied upon
   by the Respondent and the High Court to argue that Section 364 is not a “minor
   offence” relative to Section 302 and that the two are not cognate.

**Acts and Sections**

Indian Penal Code (IPC)

 * Section 302: Punishment for murder. This was the original charge framed against
   the appellant.
 * Section 364: Kidnapping or abducting in order to murder. The Trial Court convicted
   the appellant under this section despite no formal charge being framed for it.
 * Section 362: Defines “abduction”. This section was used by the Trial Judge to
   conclude that luring the deceased away on the pretext of watching a movie constituted
   abduction.
 * Section 498-A: Husband or relative of husband of a woman subjecting her to cruelty.
   This was cited within the _Shamnsaheb M. Multtani_ judgment to illustrate how
   different offenses are composed.
 * Section 304-B: Dowry death. Cited as an example of an offense with a “vastly 
   different” composition compared to Section 302.

Code of Criminal Procedure (Cr.P.C.)

 * Section 221: Addresses cases where it is doubtful which offense has been committed;
   it allows a court to convict an accused of an offense they are shown to have 
   committed, even if not charged with it.
 * Section 222: Governs when a person charged with one offense can be convicted 
   of a “minor” or “cognate” offense.
    - Section 222(1): Permits conviction for a minor offense when the particulars
      of the major charge include the minor one.
    - Section 222(2): Allows conviction for a minor offense if the proved facts 
      reduce the major offense to a minor one.

#### **Party**

    ```wp-block-verse
    The State of Uttar Pradesh (Appellant) vs. Ram Swaroop @ Barkat (Respondent) - Criminal Appeal No. 443 of 2012 - 2026 INSC 256 - March 18th, 2026 – Hon’ble Mr. Justice Aravind Kumar and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih.
    ```

[The State of U.P vs. Ram Swaroop @ Barkat 356522009_2026-03-18](https://section1.in/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/The-State-of-U.P-vs.-Ram-Swaroop-@-Barkat-356522009_2026-03-18.pdf)
[Download](https://section1.in/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/The-State-of-U.P-vs.-Ram-Swaroop-@-Barkat-356522009_2026-03-18.pdf)

### Further Study

 * [Double Jeopardy and Same Offence – Explained](https://section1.in/double-jeopardy-and-same-offence-explained/)
 * [Kidnapping: Except kidnapping prosecution did not prove the demand and threat hence section 364A IPC would not attract](https://section1.in/kidnapping-except-kidnapping-prosecution-did-not-prove-the-demand-and-threat-hence-section-364a-ipc-would-not-attract/)
 * [Section 364A IPC Modified to 363 IPC](https://section1.in/section-364-a-ipc-modified-to-363-ipc/)
