# Discharge: Discharge application cannot be filed after the trial starts

- Link: https://section1.in/stages-when-accused-can-raise-the-issue-of-taking-cognizance-without-sanction-discharge-application-cannot-be-filed-after-the-trial-starts/
- Published: 2023-08-08T06:11:44+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Question of law](https://section1.in/stages-when-accused-can-raise-the-issue-of-taking-cognizance-without-sanction-discharge-application-cannot-be-filed-after-the-trial-starts/#question-of-law)
 * [Discharge cannot be filed during trial](https://section1.in/stages-when-accused-can-raise-the-issue-of-taking-cognizance-without-sanction-discharge-application-cannot-be-filed-after-the-trial-starts/#discharge-cannot-be-filed-during-trial)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/stages-when-accused-can-raise-the-issue-of-taking-cognizance-without-sanction-discharge-application-cannot-be-filed-after-the-trial-starts/#party)
 * [Further study](https://section1.in/stages-when-accused-can-raise-the-issue-of-taking-cognizance-without-sanction-discharge-application-cannot-be-filed-after-the-trial-starts/#further-study)

##### **Question of law**

6. In view of the afore-stated undisputed facts the following questions arise for
consideration before this Court:

> (i) Whether the High Court in exercise of its powers under Section 482 of CrPC
> could have discharged the respondent accused from the charges levelled against
> him for the offences under Section 13(1)(e) punishable under Section 13(2) of 
> the said Act, despite the fact that the accused had not pressed for his second
> application for discharge by submitting the Memo dated 02.12.2014 and despite 
> the fact that after framing of the charge by the Special Court on 23.12.2014, 
> the trial had proceeded further and the prosecution had examined 17 witnesses 
> in support of its case?
> (ii) Whether the High Court in the criminal petition filed under Section 482 of
> the CrPC could reverse the findings recorded by the Special Court with regard 
> to the validity of sanction, ignoring the bar contained in sub-section (3) read
> with subsection (4) of Section 19 of the said Act?

10. Having regard to the afore-stated provisions contained in Section 19 of the 
said Act, there remains no shadow of doubt that the statute forbids taking of cognizance
by the Court against a public servant except with the previous sanction of the Government/
authority competent to grant such sanction in terms of clauses (a), (b) and (c) 
to Section 19(1). It is also well settled proposition of law that the question with
regard to the validity of such sanction should be raised at the earliest stage of
the proceedings, however could be raised at the subsequent stage of the trial also.
In our opinion, the stages of proceedings at which an accused could raise the issue
with regard to the validity of the sanction would be the stage when the Court takes
cognizance of the offence, the stage when the charge is to be framed by the Court
or at the stage when the trial is complete i.e., at the stage of final arguments
in the trial. Such issue of course, could be raised before the Court in appeal, 
revision or confirmation, however the powers of such court would be subject to sub-
section (3) and sub-section (4) of Section 19 of the said Act. It is also significant
to note that the competence of the court trying the accused also would be dependent
upon the existence of the validity of sanction, and therefore it is always desirable
to raise the issue of validity of sanction at the earliest point of time. It cannot
be gainsaid that in case the sanction is found to be invalid, the trial court can
discharge the accused and relegate the parties to a stage where the competent authority
may grant a fresh sanction for the prosecution in accordance with the law.

11. The combined reading of sub-section (3) and (4) of Section 19 makes it clear
that notwithstanding anything contained in the Code, no finding, sentence or order
passed by the Special Judge shall be reversed or altered by a Court in appeal, confirmation
or revision on the ground of, the absence of, or any error, omission or irregularity
in the sanction required under sub-section (1), unless in the opinion of the Court,
a failure of justice has in fact been occasioned thereby. sub-section (4) further
postulates that in determining under subsection (3) whether the absence of, or any
error, omission or irregularity in the sanction has occasioned, or resulted in failure
of 11 justice, the Court shall have regard to the fact whether the objection could
and should have been raised at an earlier stage in the proceedings. The explanation
to sub-section (4) further provides that for the purpose of Section 19, error includes“
competency of the authority to grant sanction”. Thus, it is clear from the language
employed in sub-section (3) of Section 19 that the said sub-section has application
to the proceedings before the Court in appeal, confirmation or revision, and not
to the proceedings before the Special Judge. The said sub-section (3) clearly forbids
the court in appeal, confirmation or revision, the interference with the order passed
by the Special Judge on the ground that the sanction was bad, save and except in
cases where the appellate or revisional court finds that the failure of justice 
had occurred by such invalidity.

12. This Court in case of Nanjappa Vs. State of Karnataka [(2015) 14 SCC 186] has
very aptly dealt with the intricacies of Section 19(1) as also Section 19(3) and
19(4) of the said Act as to at what stage the question of validity of sanction accorded
under Section 19(1) of the said Act could be raised, and what are the powers of 
the court in appeal, confirmation or revision under sub-section (3) of Section 19
of the said Act.

13. In State of M.P. vs. Bhooraji and Others [(2001) 7 SCC 679], this Court had 
an occasion to deal with the various aspects contained in Section 465 of CrPC more
particularly to deal with the expression “A failure of justice has in fact been 
occasioned” as contained therein. Since, the provisions contained in Section 19(
3) of the Prevention of Corruption 14 Act and in Section 465(1) of CrPC are pari
materia, the observations made in the said decision would be relevant.

##### Discharge cannot be filed during trial

14. In the instant case, the Special Judge proceeded with the trial, on the second
application for discharge filed by the respondent having not been pressed for by
him. The Special Judge, while dismissing the third application filed by the respondent
seeking discharge after examination of 17 witnesses by the prosecution, specifically
held that the sanction accorded by the government which was a superior authority
to the Karnataka Water Supply Board, of which the respondent was an employee, was
proper and valid. Such findings recorded by the Special Judge could not have been
and should not have been reversed or altered by the High Court in the petition filed
by the respondent challenging the said order of the Special Judge, in view of the
specific bar contained in sub-section (3) of Section 19, and that too without recording
any opinion as to how a failure of justice had in fact been occasioned to the respondent-
accused as contemplated in the said sub-section (3). As a matter of fact, neither
the respondent had pleaded nor the High Court opined whether any failure of justice
had occasioned to the respondent, on account of error if any, occurred in granting
the sanction by the authority.

15. As a matter of fact, such an interlocutory application seeking discharge in 
the midst of trial would also not be maintainable. Once the cognizance was taken
by the Special Judge and the charge was framed against the accused, the trial could
neither have been stayed nor scuttled in the midst of it in view of Section 19(3)
of the said Act. In the instant case, though the issue of validity of sanction was
raised at the earlier point of time, the same was not pressed for. The only stage
open to the respondent-accused in that situation was to raise the said issue at 
the final arguments in the trial in accordance with law.

##### Party

STATE OF KARNATAKA LOKAYUKTA POLICE vs. S. SUBBEGOWDA – CRL APL NO: 1598 OF 2023-
03.08.2023

**[click here to go to direct link](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2019/25627/25627_2019_3_1502_45865_Judgement_03-Aug-2023.pdf)**

[**state of karnataka vs. s.subbegowda**](https://demonew.section1.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/state-of-karnataka-vs.-s.subbegowda.pdf)

##### Further study

>  * **[Section 311 Cr.P.C: Recall may be allowed if no occasion to bring relevant facts at initial deposition](http://localhost:8080/section1/section-311-cr-p-c-recall-may-be-allowed-if-no-occasion-to-bring-relevant-facts-at-initial-deposition/)**
>  * **[Whether Criminal case against police officer can be filed without sanction obtained u/s 197 Cr.P.C?](http://localhost:8080/section1/whether-criminal-case-against-police-officer-can-be-filed-without-sanction-obtained-u-s-197-cr-p-c/)**
>  * **[WHETHER SANCTION IS NECESSARY AT THE STAGE OF DIRECTION UNDER SECTION 156(3) CR.P.C? CASE REFERRED TO LARGER BENCH.](http://localhost:8080/section1/whether-sanction-is-necessary-at-the-stage-of-direction-under-section-1563-cr-p-c-case-referred-to-larger-bench/)**
>  * **[Sanction: Manufacturing or fabrication of public documents and records cannot be a part of the official duty of a public servant hence sanction not required](http://localhost:8080/section1/sanction-manufacturing-or-fabrication-of-public-documents-and-records-cannot-be-a-part-of-the-official-duty-of-a-public-servant-hence-sanction-not-required/)**
>  * **[WHETHER I.O HAS TO FILE FINAL REPORT EVEN AFTER COMES TO THE OPINION THAT THERE IS NO CASE MADE OUT?](http://localhost:8080/section1/whether-i-o-has-to-file-final-report-even-after-comes-to-the-opinion-that-there-is-no-case-made-out/)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
