# Subject Study on Sanction

- Link: https://section1.in/subject-study-on-sanction/
- Published: 2025-01-02T12:55:10+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Cognizance taken without sanction does not prevent ED to seek cognizance again after obtaining the necessary sanction](https://section1.in/subject-study-on-sanction/#cognizance-taken-without-sanction-does-not-prevent-ed-to-seek-cognizance-again-after-obtaining-the-necessary-sanction)
 * [Plea of alibi gone wrong for murder case also defence on lack of sanction won’t work ](https://section1.in/subject-study-on-sanction/#plea-of-alibi-gone-wrong-for-murder-case-also-defence-on-lack-of-sanction-wont-work%c2%a0)
 * [Discharge: P.C Act: Even taking the entire material as correct the only suspicion which is the speed of sanctioning the proposal was a mere suspicion not enough to frame the charge](https://section1.in/subject-study-on-sanction/#discharge-pc-act-even-taking-the%c2%a0entire-material-as-correct-the-only-suspicion-which-is-the-speed-of-sanctioning-the-proposal-was-a-mere-suspicion-not-enough-to-frame-the-charge)
 * [No discharge after framing of charges: MLA is not a person who can be removed with the sanction of the government](https://section1.in/subject-study-on-sanction/#no-discharge-after-framing-of-charges-mla-is-not-a-person-who-can-be-removed-with-the-sanction-of-the-government)
 * [Sanction: Manufacturing or fabrication of public documents and records cannot be a part of the official duty of a public servant hence sanction not required](https://section1.in/subject-study-on-sanction/#sanction-manufacturing-or-fabrication-of-public-documents-and-records-cannot-be-a-part-of-the-official-duty-of-a-public-servant-hence-sanction-not-required)
 * [Section197 Cr.P.C: Sanction is required only to take cognizance by courts and not to file final reports](https://section1.in/subject-study-on-sanction/#section197-crpc-sanction-is-required-only-to-take-cognizance-by-courts-and-not-to-file-final-reports)
 * [All about sanction and approver](https://section1.in/subject-study-on-sanction/#all-about-sanction-and-approver)
 * [Sanction: How sanctioning authority shall examine the case presented before him?](https://section1.in/subject-study-on-sanction/#sanction-how-sanctioning-authority-shall-examine-the-case-presented-before-him)
 * [Supreme court explained the yardstick for sanction](https://section1.in/subject-study-on-sanction/#supreme-court-explained-the-yardstick-for-sanction)
 * [Whether sanction is necessary at the stage of direction under section 156(3) Cr.P.C? Case referred to larger bench](https://section1.in/subject-study-on-sanction/#whether-sanction-is-necessary-at-the-stage-of-direction-under-section-1563-crpc-case-referred-to-larger-bench)
 * [PC Act: Sections 7, 13(1)(d)(i) and (ii): Presumption can also be drawn for smaller bribe amounts further accused has not proved that rs.2000 bribe amount was a legal fee or repayment of loan](https://section1.in/subject-study-on-sanction/#pc-act-sections-7-131di-and-ii-presumption-can-also-be-drawn-for-smaller-bribe-amounts-further-accused-has-not-proved-that-rs2000-bribe-amount-was-a-legal-fee-or-repayment-of-loan)

### **󠀁[Cognizance taken without sanction does not prevent ED to seek cognizance again after obtaining the necessary sanction](http://localhost:8080/section1/cognizance-taken-without-sanction-does-not-prevent-ed-to-seek-cognizance-again-after-obtaining-the-necessary-sanction/)󠁿**

Factual Aspect: This appeal addresses the quashing of a complaint filed by the Enforcement
Directorate (ED) against a public servant due to the absence of the required sanction.
Consideration of Submissions: In accordance with Section 197(1) of the Criminal 
Procedure Code (CrPC) and the Indian Penal Code (IPC), government servants can only
be prosecuted with prior sanction for actions carried out in the course of their
official duties. Several important points arise: 1. The accused has the opportunity
to present the lack of sanction as a defense after cognizance has been taken. 2.
It is essential that the actions described in the complaint are linked to the performance
of their official responsibilities. Notably, no provisions within the Prevention
of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) are in conflict with Section 197(1) CrPC. While the
cognizance taken by the Special Court lacks validity due to the absence of sanction,
this situation opens the door for the ED to seek cognizance again in the future,
provided they obtain the necessary sanction. This path forward allows for adherence
to legal requirements while ensuring accountability.

### 󠀁[**Plea of alibi gone wrong for murder case also defence on lack of sanction won’t work**](http://localhost:8080/section1/plea-of-alibi-gone-wrong-for-murder-case-also-defence-on-lack-of-sanction-wont-work/)󠁿 

The case revolves around police officials from Murar Police Station, Gwalior, who
allegedly forged an arrest to protect Ashok Dixit, an accused in a murder case. 
The investigation led to the suspension of the involved officials and the filing
of a charge sheet against them. The High Court quashed the proceedings due to the
lack of sanction under Section 197 CrPC, which protects public servants from prosecution
without government approval. The complainant has appealed against this quash order,
questioning whether the CJM, Firozabad, could take cognizance of the charge sheets
without the required sanction.  The appellant, Om Prakash Yadav, lodged an FIR for
murder against several individuals, including Ashok Dixit, after witnessing the 
killing of his brother and the injury of his nephew. On the same day, another FIR
was registered against Ashok Dixit for carrying illegal liquor, allegedly to create
an alibi. The charge sheet in the murder case was submitted before the CJM, Firozabad,
while the investigation into the liquor case continued, implicating several police
officials in the forgery.  The appeals arise from a common judgment by the High 
Court of Allahabad, which quashed the proceedings of two cases pending before the
CJM, Firozabad. The primary issue is whether the CJM could take cognizance of the
charge sheets without the required sanction under Section 197 CrPC. The case highlights
the complexities of legal procedures and the protection afforded to public servants
under the law.

### **󠀁[Discharge: P.C Act: Even taking the entire material as correct the only suspicion which is the speed of sanctioning the proposal was a mere suspicion not enough to frame the charge](https://section1.in/subject-study-on-sanction/ P.C Act: Even taking the entire material as correct the only suspicion which is the speed of sanctioning the proposal was a mere suspicion not enough to frame the charge)󠁿**

The CBI filed a final report (charge sheet) under the IPC and PC Act for a loss 
of ₹436 crores to the bank due to the accused company. Allegations suggest the bank
incurred an undue loss while the company gained. The trial court dismissed the discharge
application, but the Hon’ble High Court allowed it.  The Apex Court reviewed the
submissions and found no allegations against the respondent regarding the SBLC sanction.
The only suspicion about the speed of the proposal’s sanction was insufficient for
framing charges. The Supreme Court determined that no offence was made out against
the respondent and upheld the discharge order.

### 󠀁[**No discharge after framing of charges: MLA is not a person who can be removed with the sanction of the government**](http://localhost:8080/section1/no-discharge-after-framing-of-charges-mla-is-not-a-person-who-can-be-removed-with-the-sanction-of-the-government/)󠁿

Suo-Motu revision was taken by the Hon’ble Madras High Court against the discharge
order on the second discharge application – Suo-Motu Crl.R.C No: 1559 of 2023.

### **󠀁[Sanction: Manufacturing or fabrication of public documents and records cannot be a part of the official duty of a public servant hence sanction not required](https://section1.in/subject-study-on-sanction/ Manufacturing or fabrication of public documents and records cannot be a part of the official duty of a public servant hence sanction not required)󠁿**

Head note: Challenge – Facts – Quash preferred – Quash dismissed by the Hon’ble 
High Court – Charge sheet filed against the accused – Respondent/accused again approached
High court and set aside the charge sheet and other order – Question involved: Whether
sanction required to prosecute respondent no.2? – Section 197 Cr.P.C – Sanction 
explained – a view can be taken that manufacturing of such documents or fabrication
of records cannot be a part of the official duty of a public servant – Parties.

### 󠀁[**Section197 Cr.P.C: Sanction is required only to take cognizance by courts and not to file final reports**](http://localhost:8080/section1/sanction-is-required-only-to-take-cognizance-by-courts-and-not-to-file-final-reports-before-such-courts-investigation-officer-has-to-sent-for-sanction-only-after-filing-the-final-report-before-the-c/)󠁿

Section197 Cr.P.C: Sanction is required only to take cognizance by courts and not
to file final reports. Investigation officer has to sent for sanction only after
filing the final report before the concerned court.

### **󠀁[All about sanction and approver](http://localhost:8080/section1/all-about-sanction-and-approver/)󠁿**

Pardon & Approver.

### **󠀁[Sanction: How sanctioning authority shall examine the case presented before him?](https://section1.in/subject-study-on-sanction/ How sanctioning authority shall examine the case presented before him?)󠁿**

Understanding the process of examining cases by sanctioning authorities. Learn the
steps involved.

### **󠀁[Supreme court explained the yardstick for sanction](http://localhost:8080/section1/supreme-court-explained-yardstick-for-sanction/)󠁿**

Supreme court explained the yardstick for sanction

### **󠀁[Whether sanction is necessary at the stage of direction under section 156(3) Cr.P.C? Case referred to larger bench](http://localhost:8080/section1/whether-sanction-is-necessary-at-the-stage-of-direction-under-section-1563-cr-p-c-case-referred-to-larger-bench/)󠁿**

Whether sanction is necessary at the stage of direction under section 156(3) Cr.
P.C? Case referred to larger bench

### **󠀁[PC Act: Sections 7, 13(1)(d)(i) and (ii): Presumption can also be drawn for smaller bribe amounts further accused has not proved that rs.2000 bribe amount was a legal fee or repayment of loan](http://localhost:8080/section1/pc-act-sections-7-131di-and-ii-presumption-can-also-be-drawn-for-smaller-bribe-amounts-further-accused-has-not-proved-that-rs-2000-bribe-amount-was-a-legal-fee-or-repayment-of-loan/)󠁿**

This judgment outlines the State’s appeal against a High Court decision that acquitted
the accused under the Prevention of Corruption (PC) Act. **Overview of Allegations**
The case centers on the accused, a treasury assistant, who allegedly requested a
bribe to facilitate the encashment of a leave salary bill. This demand was captured
on tape, leading to the registration of a First Information Report (FIR) under Sections
13(1)(d) and 13(2) of the PC Act. Subsequently, a trap was organized based on this
information, resulting in the recovery of the bribe from the accused after a thorough
investigation was conducted. A final report was compiled, and charges were duly 
framed under the PC Act. **Trial Proceedings**  During the trial, the prosecution
presented a robust case by examining 12 witnesses and introducing 30 documents along
with 10 material objects. Notably, the accused did not provide any defense evidence.
The trial court ultimately found the accused guilty of offenses under Sections 7
and 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. 
The accused subsequently appealed this conviction in the High Court, which led to
an acquittal. As a result, the state has pursued this appeal. **Constructive Analysis**
The analysis reviews the key components of Sections 7 and 13 of the PC Act, alongside
Section 6 of the General Clauses Act. It emphasizes that a presumption under Section
20 can only be warranted when the prosecution establishes beyond a reasonable doubt
that the accused intentionally accepted money knowing it to be a bribe. A Constitution
Bench has clarified the process for drawing inferences regarding offenses under 
Sections 7 and 13 of the PC Act in cases devoid of direct or primary evidence. Importantly,
the examination revealed no procedural irregularities in granting sanction for prosecution.**
Witness Contributions** The informant (P.W.1) played a significant role by recording
the demand for illegal gratification on tape and supplying this evidence to the 
Lokayukta police. Following the tape recording, phenolphthalein-coated currency 
notes were presented to P.W.3, whose hands tested positive, validating the evidence.
After receiving the bribe, the accused was arrested, and a seizure Mahazar was prepared
along with the collection of pertinent materials. The corroborative testimonies 
from P.W.2 and P.W.3 reinforced P.W.1’s account. Additionally, P.W.4 confirmed that
the accused had responsibilities related to receiving and verifying the surrender
leave salary bill. P.W.5 provided insights into the sodium carbonate solution test
conducted by the Investigating Officer (I.O.). Supportive testimony was also provided
by the hotel owner, while P.W.7 confirmed that the informant prepared the surrender
leave salary bill. Furthermore, P.W.12, the I.O., detailed the tape recording and
the events of the trap proceedings. **Conclusion** The absence of oral or documentary
evidence from the accused in the defense phase brought clarity to the prosecution’s
case. The Apex Court upheld the findings regarding the demand and acceptance of 
the bribe. The accused was unable to substantiate, during cross-examination, that
the alleged bribe constituted a legal fee or loan repayment. Notably, the accused
did not indicate any loan dealings with the complainant in his Section 313 Cr.P.
C. statement. The presumption under Section 20 parallels Section 118 of the Negotiable
Instruments Act, 1881, shifting the responsibility to the accused to show evidence
of innocence regarding the charged offenses. In applying the “two-view theory” to
this case, the conclusion has been reached that the criminal appeal is justified
in being allowed. This case exemplifies the ongoing efforts to combat corruption
and reinforce accountability within public service.
