# Test Identification parade (TIP) is not a substantive  piece of evidence and it hits under section 162 Cr.P.C

- Link: https://section1.in/test-identification-parade-tip-is-not-a-substantive-piece-of-evidence-it-is-hit-u-s-162-cr-p-c/
- Published: 2023-04-17T15:00:30+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Test Identification Parade (TIP) was not conducted immediately after the arrest but with a delay casts a serious doubt on the credibility of TIP](https://section1.in/test-identification-parade-tip-is-not-a-substantive-piece-of-evidence-it-is-hit-u-s-162-cr-p-c/#test-identification-parade-tip-was-not-conducted-immediately-after-the-arrest-but-with-a-delay-casts-a-serious-doubt-on-the-credibility-of-tip)
 * [Legality of TIP](https://section1.in/test-identification-parade-tip-is-not-a-substantive-piece-of-evidence-it-is-hit-u-s-162-cr-p-c/#legality-of-tip)
 * [Hovering presence of the police during the TIP vitiated the entire process](https://section1.in/test-identification-parade-tip-is-not-a-substantive-piece-of-evidence-it-is-hit-u-s-162-cr-p-c/#hovering-presence-of-the-police-during-the-tip-vitiated-the-entire-process)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/test-identification-parade-tip-is-not-a-substantive-piece-of-evidence-it-is-hit-u-s-162-cr-p-c/#party)

##### **Test Identification Parade (TIP) was not conducted immediately after the arrest but with a delay casts a serious doubt on the credibility of TIP**

48. Returning to the facts of the present case, we have already noted that Accused
Nos. 1-16 were arrested on 13.07.2000. Instead of filing an application for conducting
a TIP at the earliest, the IO (PW-84) filed a remand application, pursuant to which
the Accused were remanded to police custody. There is strong evidence that the Accused
were shown to the witnesses during their police custody period. The fact that an
application for conducting a TIP was filed on 23.07.2000, i.e., the very next day
after the police custody period ended, leads to the inevitable conclusion that the
Accused were taken into police custody to facilitate their easy identification during
the TIP. Otherwise, we see no reason why an application for conducting a TIP was
not filed immediately after the arrest of the Accused. In such circumstances, we
firmly believe that the delay in holding the TIP coupled with other circumstances
has cast a serious doubt on the credibility of the TIP witnesses.

##### **Legality of TIP**

49. Re: Legality of the TIP and the presence of the IO during the conduct of the
TIP:A three-judge bench of this Court in**[ Chunthuramv. State of Chhattisgarh](https://webapi.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2009/35346/35346_2009_39_1501_24473_Judgement_29-Oct-2020.pdf)**[(
2020) 10 SCC 733], by relying on Ramkishan Mithanlal Sharma v. State of Bombay [(
1955) 1 SCR 903], has held that any identification made by witnesses in a TIP in
the presence of a police officer tantamount to statements made to the police officer
under Section 162 Cr.P.C. The Court held:

> “The infirmities in the conduct of the test identification parade would next bear
> scrutiny. The major flaw in the exercise here was the presence of the police during
> the exercise. When the dentifications are held in police presence, the resultant
> communications tantamount to statements made by the identifiers to a police officer
> in course of investigation and they fall within the ban of Section 162 of the 
> Code.”

50. The evidence of IO (PW-84) about the conduct of the Test Identification Parade
may be noted: –

> “(Q). Did you make any arrangement to prevent the witness and the accused from
> seeing each other inside the jail?
>  (A). I did not think it as something needed.”

51. Further, when a question regarding the presence of the IO (PW-84) was put to
JMFC (PW-47), he stated that:

> “…in the parade conducted on 31.07.2000, 31 non-suspects were selected. The civilian
> were produced by the IO. On that date also Dy. SP and CI were present in the premises
> of the jail……”

53. Having considered the statement of the JMFC (PW-47) and the evidence of the 
IO (PW-84) together, we are of the view that the presence of the Investigating Officer
at the time of the TIP cannot be ruled out. The Investigating Officer has stated
that he has not taken any steps to ensure that the accused and the witnesses do 
not see each other. It is rather surprising to note that Investigating Officer thinks
that such a measure is not necessary.

##### **Hovering presence of the police during the TIP vitiated the entire process**

56. In view of the evidence available on record, we are of the opinion that the 
conduct of the TIP, coupled with the hovering presence of the police during the 
conduct of the TIP vitiated the entire process. The Trial Court as well as the High
Court have committed a serious error in relying on the evidence of the TIP witnesses
for convicting and sentencing the Appellants. We are of the opinion that the conviction
and sentencing are not sustainable. In view of these lapses on the part of the prosecution,
it is not necessary for us to consider various other grounds raised by the Appellants.

57. Conclusion: Having considered the matter in detail and having noted the various
discrepancies in the manner in which both the TIPs were conducted, we believe that
the prosecution has not established its case beyond reasonable doubt. Apart from
the TIPs, we find no other evidence put forth by the prosecution to prove the guilt
of the Accused for offences under Sections 143, 147, 148 IPC and 3(2)(e) of PDPP
Act r/w 149 of the IPC.

##### **Party**

GIREESAN NAIR & ORS. ETC vs STATE OF KERALA – Criminal Appeal Nos. 1864-1865 of 
2010 -NOVEMBER 11, 2022 – [2022] 8 S.C.R. 599.

**[https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2010/7351/7351_2010_13_1501_39632_Judgement_11-Nov-2022.pdf](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2010/7351/7351_2010_13_1501_39632_Judgement_11-Nov-2022.pdf)**

**[Gireesan-Nair-vs.-State-of-Kerala](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/Gireesan-Nair-vs.-State-of-Kerala-1.pdf)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
