# The Juvenile Justice Care and Protection Of Children Act, 2000 – An Analysis (Having Deep Connection With Juvenile Justice (Care And Protection Of Children) Act, 2015)

- Link: https://section1.in/the-juvenile-justice-care-and-protection-of-children-act-2000-an-analysis-having-deep-connection-with-juvenile-justice-care-and-protection-of-children-act-2015/
- Published: 2023-11-24T15:48:15+00:00
- Author: section1

This article is my simple and humble endeavor to apprise the legislature and all
other authorities  concerned of the lurking and resultant danger and the menace 
to the society in the JUVENILE JUSTICE CARE AND PROTECTION OF CHILDREN ACT 2000 
hereinafter called Act.

Through the avowed intention of the legislature is to provide protection, treatment
and rehabilitation of neglected or delinquent juvenile , there is every likelihood
that the hardened and habitual criminals misusing and taking advantage of the provision
of the Act to achieve their unlawful purpose and gains detrimental to the interest,
safety and welfare of the society in general and juveniles in particular.

Section 2(k) defines ‘Juveniles’ or ‘child’ as a person who has not completed the
eighteenth year of age. Under 2(l) Juvenile in conflict with law means a juvenile
who is alleged to have committed an offence. One of the basic distinctions between
the Juvenile Justice Act, 1986 and the Act, 2000 is the distinction between male
and female juveniles on the basis of age has not been maintained. The age limit 
is eighteen year for male and female.

It is now set at rest by the Hon’ble supreme court that the reckoning date for determination
of age of a juvenile offender is the date of commission of offence and not the date
when he is produced before the court/competent authority. Section 16 of the act 
prohibit the imposition of sentence of death or life imprisonment to a juvenile 
which is not in conformity with general criminal law even if the offence committed
is a heinous as murder, rape,  robbery and so on. The proviso to the said section
reads that where a juvenile who has attained the age of sixteen years has committed
an offence and if the board is satisfied that the offence committed is so serious
in nature or that his conduct and behavior have been so violent or unpredictable
that it would not be in his interest or in the other juvenile to send him to special
home, the may order the juvenile in conflict with law to be kept in such a place
of safety and in such a manner as it thick fully and shall report the case for the
order of the state government. The subsection (2) empowers the state government,
on receipt of such report from the board to make necessary arrangements to keep 
such juvenile under protective custody in a place as it thinks conductive for his
rehabilitation process. The procedure contemplated under the said sub section obviously
relates to a juvenile who has attained the age of sixteen but is still a juvenile
in conflict with law i.e who has not completed his eighteenth year of age.

The is silent as regards the procedure to be followed in the case of juvenile who
is no longer juvenile in conflict with law i.e who has completed the age of eighteen
at the time when judgement is pronounced finding him guilty of an offence. Whether
the Madras Borstal school Act which provides for detention of adolescent offenders
upto the age of twenty one, would be applicable to them is another question to be
answered.

Therefore, we have to resort to judicial decision for the courses to be followed
as the following decisions rendered under Juvenile Justice care and Protection Act
1986 could also very well be followed as the Act,2000 is nothing but a substitution
for the former act only with slight distinctions and modifications in **Bhoopram
vs State of Uttar Pradesh reported in (1989)3 supreme court cases 1**, the accused
who had not completed the age of sixteen on the date of commission of offence under
section 302 Indian penal code and having crossed the maximum age of detention in
an approved school, the Hon’ble supreme court has found that the only course is 
to sustain his conviction but quash the sentence and release him forthwith. The 
Division bench of the Honble Calcutta High court in **Nishi Roy vs State of West
Bengal reported in 2006(1) crimes  466 **has while dealing with a juvenile delinquent
found guilty of an offence under section 302 of the Indian penal code, has enunciated,
following its own earlier decision in the case of Prem Das @ Prema, that a delinquent
cannot be sentenced for detention for a period of more than three years or beyond
the age of eighteen years, however heinous crime he might have committed. In **Gurpreet
Singh vs state of Punjab reported in 2005(4) crimes 230**, the Hon’ble Supreme court
has reiterated the proposition in the aforesaid Bhoopram’s case and held if it is
found that the accused was a juvenile on such date and continues to be so, he shall
be sent to a juvenile home. But in case it finds that on the date of the occurrences,
he was a juvenile but on the date this court is passing final order upon the report
received from the trail court, he no longer continues to be a juvenile, the sentence
imposed against him would be liable to be set aside.

The teenagers in the group of sixteen to eighteen years are very well grown up physically
as well as mentally and there is every likelihood that some of the teenagers, knowing
the privileged position of offenders under the Act , could themselves become professional
offenders or that the seasoned or professional criminals could employ them as hirelings
for their illegal purpose or gain.

Engaging or employing children below ten year by the professional criminals for 
petty offences such as pick pocketing theft, chain snatching etc., at the bus stands
in the cities is becoming a common a sight nowadays.

Unless the legislative authorities take appropriate measures to eradicate the menace,
the entire safety and interest of the society would be at a stake at the hands of
the teenagers in the age group of seventeen and eighteen, who would be tempted and
prone to commit even offences punishable with capital punishment knowing that they
would be let free if the case against them is kept pending by their abstention or
even otherwise till attain majority.

With all humility, I am of the opinion that the only way obliterate the menace hidden
in the act is the reduction of age of the juvenile in conflict with law to sixteen
year instead of the present eighteen years by way of an amendment of section 2(l)
of the act.

**localhost:8080/section1/ note:**

When this article had been written “THE JUVENILE JUSTICE (CARE AND PROTECTION OF
CHILDREN) ACT, 2000” was in force which does not contain provision for ‘life sentence’
for the juvenile who was in conflict with law. But later on when the JUVENILE JUSTICE(
CARE AND PROTECTION OF CHILDREN) ACT, 2015 has been enacted, the lawmakers has carefully
inserted the special provision “section 21. Order that may not be passed against
a child in conflict with law” must be read with section 433A of Cr.P.C. So, by reading
the latest enactment on juvenile offenders who are conflict with law, it seems the
wish of this article’s author has come true.

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
