# The Tamil Nadu Rent Act, 2017 Needs Constitutional Correction

- Link: https://section1.in/the-tamil-nadu-rent-act-2017-needs-constitutional-correction/
- Published: 2025-12-08T07:18:48+00:00
- Author: Reshma Azath

Contents

 * [1. Introduction](https://section1.in/the-tamil-nadu-rent-act-2017-needs-constitutional-correction/#1-introduction)
 * [2. The Legitimacy of the Tamil Nadu Regulation of Rights and Responsibilities of Landlords and Tenants Act, 2017](https://section1.in/the-tamil-nadu-rent-act-2017-needs-constitutional-correction/#2-the-legitimacy-of-the-tamil-nadu-regulation-of-rights-and-responsibilities-of-landlords-and-tenants-act-2017)
 * [3.         Can an Act truly protect tenants when Section 4 requires strict registration of tenancy agreements, yet Section 21(2)(a) enables eviction without one, and does this inconsistency violate the equality clause under Article 14?](https://section1.in/the-tamil-nadu-rent-act-2017-needs-constitutional-correction/#3-%c2%a0%c2%a0%c2%a0%c2%a0%c2%a0%c2%a0%c2%a0-can-an-act-truly-protect-tenants-when-section-4-requires-strict-registration-of-tenancy-agreements-yet-section-212a-enables-eviction-without-one-and-does-t)
 * [4. Conclusion](https://section1.in/the-tamil-nadu-rent-act-2017-needs-constitutional-correction/#4-conclusion)

#### **1. Introduction**

**            **The right to residence is a fundamental right ensured by the Indian
Constitution. It forms an integral part of the right to life and personal liberty,
as outlined in Article 21 of the Constitution. It is further reinforced by the freedom
of movement and residence guaranteed under Article 19(1)(e), which provides that
every citizen has the right “to reside and settle in any part of the territory of
India.” This constitutional guarantee ensures not only freedom of physical movement
but also stability and security in one’s living arrangements. Although the Constitution
does not expressly define the term ‘residence,’ it is understood as an umbrella 
concept that flows from personal liberty and the freedom to choose one’s place of
living.  In the context of tenancy and rental housing, the right to residence acquires
special significance. In Tamil Nadu, tenancy relations are now governed by the Tamil
Nadu Regulation of Rights and Responsibilities of Landlords and Tenants Act, 2017(
hereinafter referred to as the Rent Act, 2017), which aims to modernise rental governance
and balance the interests of both parties. The Rent Act, despite its aims for transparency
and fair eviction, exhibits significant constitutional vulnerabilities. Its provisions,
even with mandated written agreements and eviction grounds, inadequately safeguard
the fundamental right to residence and fail to establish genuine parity between 
parties. Through the lens of constitutional principles, the Rent Act, 2017, however,
falls short in its particular impact on basic living conditions and its operation
with arbitrary discrimination. A key issue lies in the mandatory written tenancy
agreement, which presumes equal bargaining power between landlords and tenants. 
However, in reality, the negotiation process with tenants, predominantly low-income
or socially vulnerable groups, is often unable to negotiate terms on an equal footing.
The legal protections are contracts rather than protective statutory safeguards;
the right to residence becomes precarious and easily overridden by unequal negotiations.
The procedures for eviction under the Act, though outwardly structured, lack the
robust safeguards necessary to prevent arbitrary displacement. Furthermore, silence
on crucial aspects such as rent ceilings and safeguards for vulnerable tenants creates
a regulatory vacuum that disproportionately benefits economically stronger landlords.
The imbalance not only compromises the goal of equitable housing but also contradicts
the constitutional mandate to protect weaker tenants when their fundamental rights,
such as the right to residence, are at stake. This article raises the issue that
the Rent Act itself mandates the existence of a registered written agreement between
the landlord and the tenant as a prerequisite for instituting legal proceedings 
before the court. However, the Act becomes self-contradictory, as Section 21(2)(
a) permits the landlord to initiate proceedings for repossession of the premises
even in the absence of such a registered agreement, which is a violation of Article
14 of the Constitution.

#### **2. The Legitimacy of the Tamil Nadu Regulation of Rights and Responsibilities of Landlords and Tenants Act, 2017**

2.1       People often say that _“the whole world is one roof and we are all tenants.”_
This idea is shared everywhere, but in reality, every individual desires to own 
a separate home. Even though the property right was removed from the list of fundamental
rights, the real purpose behind that change has not been achieved. Everyone has 
still not received the basic needs and equal opportunities promised in the Preamble
under **Socialism****. **This persistent disparity underscores the ongoing struggle
for social justice, where fundamental entitlements such as adequate housing remain
elusive for a significant portion of the population, despite international recognition
of such rights. The UN’s Universal Declaration of Human Rights, adopted in 1948,
asserts social security as an inalienable human right; however, implementing such
declarations globally faces significant challenges due to a lack of political will
and administrative capacity. In the context, the state allowed the rent system.

2.2       The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India holds in Kewal Singh v. Lajwanti (1980)
1 SCC 290 that this type of legislation was termed as a social reform to protect
the tenants from capricious and frivolous eviction and thus conferring the status
of a statutory tenant who could not be evicted, except under the conditions specified
therein and by following the procedures prescribed by the Rent Control Act.

2.3          Irani vs. State of Madras, (1962) 1 MLJ (SC) 92, held that the fundamental
purpose of rent control legislation is twofold, (i) to prevent unreasonable evictions
and (ii) to regulate rent—and that these two objects are inseparably connected. 
An eviction becomes unreasonable where the landlord seeks to exploit the shortage
of accommodation by letting the premises at an exorbitant rent or by securing an
extortionate premium. The Court further noted that such unlawful premiums are often
realised clandestinely; therefore, control of eviction is indispensable to the effective
control of rent. Conversely, where there is no possibility of the landlord being
able to extract illegal rent or a premium, an eviction may not be unreasonable. 
Indeed, there may arise cases where the tenant attempts to misuse the statutory 
protection for unfair advantage, and in such circumstances, the government is within
its competence to exempt the premises from the operation of the act.

2.4       Balaji v. Principal Secretary to Government, W.P. No. 3985 of 2020 (Madras
HC Apr. 23, 2024), held that the constitutional validity of the Rent Act, 2017, 
has been extensively contested before the Madras High Court in a batch of writ petitions
filed by landlords and tenants. The petitioners argue that several provisions of
the Act are repugnant to central laws, particularly the Transfer of Property Act,
1882, the Registration Act, 1908, the Specific Relief Act, 1963, and succession 
laws. They contend that the Act imposes an arbitrary contractual regime, eliminates
statutory tenancy protections, and infringes vested rights guaranteed under Articles
14, 19, and 21 of the Constitution. The objections include mandatory written tenancy
agreements, registration requirements, expanded grounds for eviction, and the alleged
absence of presidential assent under Article 254 when the act occupies the Concurrent
List. The State defends the legislation as a necessary reform aligning with the 
Model Tenancy Act and argues that its legislative competence is traceable to Entry
18 of the State List, thereby excluding the question of repugnancy. It maintains
that the Act seeks to modernise tenancy relations, streamline dispute resolution,
and restore contractual balance without violating fundamental rights. The Court 
identifies core constitutional questions relating to legislative competence, repugnancy,
arbitrariness, and consistency with central enactments, which form the basis for
adjudicating the validity of the Act.

2.4       In Kewal Singh v. Lajwanti, (1980) 1 SCC 290, the Supreme Court acknowledged
rent regulations as a social reform tool designed to protect tenants from exploitation
and arbitrary eviction. In contrast, the 2017 Act diverges from this paradigm by
placing a greater focus on market-based efficiency rather than the socio-economic
vulnerabilities of tenants.

#### **3.         Can an Act truly protect tenants when Section 4 requires strict registration of tenancy agreements, yet Section 21(2)(a) enables eviction without one, and does this inconsistency violate the equality clause under Article 14?**

3.1       The Tamil Nadu Rend Act, 2017. Chapter II of the Act deals with Tenancy
under Section 4, after the Act comes into force, no premises can be rented except
through a written tenancy agreement. For tenancies that existed before the Act, 
a written contract must be executed within 575 days from the commencement of the
Act. This agreement must be registered with the Rent Authority, which will either
register it within 30 days and provide a registration number or reject it if it 
does not comply with the Act or Rules. The Rent Authority will also publish details
of the property, the tenancy period, and the parties involved on its website. Section
4A states that if a required agreement is not registered, it does not affect property
rights, confer any powers, or be accepted as evidence in transactions concerning
the property. According to Section 5, the tenancy period is as agreed in the tenancy
agreement. Before the Tenancy ends, the tenant must request renewal or extension.
If the Tenancy is not renewed, the tenant does not vacate, and the landlord does
not demand possession, the Tenancy is deemed renewed on a month-to-month basis for
a maximum of six months, under the same terms and conditions.

3.2       In Muruganandam vs. J. Joseph (CRP NPD Nos. 3056, 3061, 3062, 3063, 3067&
3094 of 2021), the Madras High Court observed that while the Tamil Nadu Regulation
of Rights and Responsibilities of Landlords and Tenants Act, 2017 mandates tenancy
through a written and registered agreement under Section 4, issues arose regarding
tenancies that existed before the commencement of the Act and the effect of Section
4A on unregistered contracts. In these cases, the rent agreements were entered into
before the Act came into effect and had either expired before or after its commencement.
No new written agreement was executed or registered within the 575 days as required
under Section 4(2). The Court clarified that it is not always necessary for a tenancy
to have a registered agreement, and eviction or possession applications cannot be
rejected solely on that ground. Even f or pre-existing or unregistered tenancies,
the Rent Court must examine the merits of the case rather than dismiss applications
on technicalities. Accordingly, the three revision petitions were allowed, with 
a direction to the Rent Court to number and decide the applications, as the question
of a written and registered tenancy instrument did not arise.

3.3       The judgment conclusively held that upon the expiry of the 575-day transitional
period, the temporary protection afforded to pre-existing tenancies stood terminated,
and the execution and registration of a tenancy agreement became mandatory in all
circumstances. Accordingly, with effect from 10.06.2022, every tenancy falling within
the purview of the Tamil Nadu Regulation of Rights and Responsibilities of Landlords
and Tenants Act, 2017 must be supported by a written agreement signed by both parties
and duly registered under the Registration Act, 1908, in strict conformity with 
Sections 4 and 4-A. Consequently, unregistered, informal, unsigned or oral tenancy
arrangements cannot be relied upon to establish tenancy rights or be admitted as
evidence before the Rent Authority, Rent Court or Rent Tribunal. The Court further
emphasized that the legislative object is to eradicate undocumented tenancy practices
and institute a transparent, accountable and traceable tenancy regime; hence, any
tenancy that fails to satisfy the mandatory statutory registration requirement after
the transitional period has lapsed is unenforceable in the eyes of law.

3.4       However, this statutory mandate stands in direct tension with Chapter 
V, Section 21 of the Act, which deals with the repossession of premises by the landlord.
Under Section 21(2)(a), repossession may be sought on the ground that _“the landlord
and tenant have failed to agree as required under sub-section (2) of Section 4.”_
This clause implicitly acknowledges the continued existence of tenancies even where
there is no written or registered agreement, thereby preserving the legal status
of a tenant despite non-compliance with Sections 4 and 4-A. When these provisions
are read together, an internal inconsistency becomes apparent within the legislative
framework, Sections 4 and 4-A impose a mandatory requirement of execution and registration
of a tenancy agreement after the expiry of the transitional period, whereas Section
21(2)(a) recognises the validity of an unregistered tenancy for the purpose of adjudicating
landlord’s claims. Thus, the Act simultaneously demands strict procedural compliance
through compulsory registration and yet accepts the substantive continuation of 
unregistered tenancies, creating a conflict between regulatory formality and the
preservation of tenancy rights.

3.5       This inconsistency becomes even more striking in light of the judgment
of the Madras High Court in C.R.P. No. 2820 of 2022, dated 12.09.2022 (Justice S.
Sounthar), wherein para 14 interprets the proviso to Section 4(2) of the Act of 
2017. The Court held “………_that if the parties fail to execute a written agreement
as mandated under Section 4(2), either party is entitled to file an application 
for termination of tenancy and seek repossession under Section 21(2)(a_)”. This 
interpretation reveals a more profound statutory contradiction, because Chapter 
V of the Act is titled “Repossession of the Premises by the Landlord,” indicating
that only the landlord can seek repossession, yet Section 21(2)(a)-as read in the
judgment—confers the right on “either party,” including the tenant. Thus, while 
the legislative framework makes execution and registration of tenancy agreements
compulsory under Sections 4 and 4-A, Section 21(2)(a) simultaneously recognizes 
the continued existence of unregistered tenancies and even grants a procedural right
to seek termination and repossession to both sides. As a result, the Act creates
uncertainty: it mandates strict registration for the existence of a tenancy, yet
it preserves unregistered tenancies for the purpose of seeking legal remedies, and
it titles the chapter in favor of landlords while wording the provision in favour
of both landlords and tenants. This internal inconsistency blurs the distinction
between procedural non-compliance and substantive tenancy rights, undermining legislative
clarity and predictability.

3.6       The contradiction within the Tamil Nadu Rent Act, 2017, becomes constitutionally
significant when examined through the lens of the tenant’s right to residence, which
forms an integral component of the Right to Life under Article 21 of the Constitution.
While Sections 4 and 4-A introduce a rigid regime of mandatory execution and registration
of tenancy agreements after the expiry of the 575-day transitional period, Section
21(2)(a) simultaneously recognises the survival of unregistered tenancies and allows
repossession based on their non-execution. The judicial interpretation in C.R.P.
No. 2820 of 2022 further reinforces that “either party”—including the tenant—may
seek repossession upon non-execution of a tenancy agreement, even though Chapter
V is titled in favour of the landlord. This mosaic of conflicting provisions creates
an ambiguous legal environment for tenants, where compliance with registration requires
validating tenancy rights. Yet, non-compliance can simultaneously become the basis
for eviction proceedings. Such legislative inconsistency exposes tenants to uncertain
and unequal treatment, enabling eviction without the procedural protections otherwise
guaranteed under Sections 4 and 4-A. In effect, the Act’s structural contradiction
undermines the constitutional guarantee of security of residence, as tenants may
lose possession without the safeguard of a registered tenancy agreement that the
Act itself demands. This situation gives rise to an arbitrary classification under
Article 14, where similarly placed tenants—those without a registered agreement—
may either retain protection or be exposed to eviction depending on the interpretative
application of Section 21(2)(a). Therefore, the statute, in its current form, fails
to provide a stable and predictable framework for tenancy and falls short of upholding
the constitutional promise of dignified housing and protection from arbitrary eviction.
It calls for urgent legislative and constitutional amendments to ensure that internal
statutory inconsistencies do not undermine the right to residence.

#### **4. Conclusion**

The Tamil Nadu Rent Act, 2017, though enacted to modernize tenancy governance, suffers
from fundamental structural inconsistencies that undermine its constitutional legitimacy.
The mandatory requirement of a written and registered tenancy agreement under Sections
4 and 4-A is contradicted by Section 21(2)(a), which simultaneously recognises and
allows action on unregistered tenancies, creating a direct conflict between procedural
compliance and substantive tenancy rights. Judicial interpretations have further
highlighted this inconsistency by permitting “either party” to seek termination 
and repossession despite the Act’s clear mandate for registration. This internal
incoherence not only erodes legislative clarity but also jeopardises the constitutional
right to residence under Article 21, exposing tenants—particularly vulnerable ones—
to arbitrary eviction. The unequal legal consequences arising from the same statutory
non-compliance constitute an unreasonable classification under Article 14, failing
the test of fairness and non-arbitrariness. For an act intended to promote transparency,
accountability, and balanced protection, these contradictions diminish its effectiveness
and compromise the socio-economic safeguards historically embedded in rent control
jurisprudence. To fully align with constitutional principles and ensure housing 
justice, the Act requires urgent legislative correction, harmonisation of its provisions,
and a stronger reaffirmation of tenant protections within the broader framework 
of the right to dignified residence.

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
