# Timely Quash order

- Link: https://section1.in/timely-quash-order/
- Published: 2025-09-10T07:01:47+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

    - [Crl.O.P No. 24853 of 2025](https://section1.in/timely-quash-order/#crlop-no-24853-of-2025)
    - [Crl.O.P No. 24866 of 2025](https://section1.in/timely-quash-order/#crlop-no-24866-of-2025)
 * [Both petitions make serious allegations](https://section1.in/timely-quash-order/#both-petitions-make-serious-allegations)
 * [Contention of the petitioner](https://section1.in/timely-quash-order/#contention-of-the-petitioner)
    - [District Judge contacted SP to change Judge’s PSO for sending anonymous complaint against the judge](https://section1.in/timely-quash-order/#district-judge-contacted-sp-to-change-judges-pso-for-sending-anonymous-complaint-against-the-judge)
    - [The PSO is added as an accused in a FIR by an suo motu order of the District Judge](https://section1.in/timely-quash-order/#the-pso-is-added-as-an-accused-in-a-fir-by-an-suo-motu-order-of-the-district-judge)
    - [Before externment order under section 10 of SC/ST Act can be passed either there must be a complaint or a police report](https://section1.in/timely-quash-order/#before-externment-order-under-section-10-of-scst-act-can-be-passed-either-there-must-be-a-complaint-or-a-police-report)
    - [Remand order for not to arrest the accused cannot lie inasmuch as arrest is the prerogative of the police](https://section1.in/timely-quash-order/#remand-order-for-not-to-arrest-the-accused-cannot-lie-inasmuch-as-arrest-is-the-prerogative-of-the-police)
    - [Manner in which impugned orders were passed probabilise the prima facie of the allegations made in the affidavits](https://section1.in/timely-quash-order/#manner-in-which-impugned-orders-were-passed-probabilise-the-prima-facie-of-the-allegations-made-in-the-affidavits)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/timely-quash-order/#party)

##### **Crl.O.P No. 24853 of 2025**

Crl.O.P.No.24853 of 2025 has been filed by one Lokeshwaran Ravi, challenging the
_suo motu _order of the learned Principal District and Sessions Judge, Kancheepuram,
dated 04.09.2025, in Crime No.283 of 2025 on the file of the Walajabad Police Station,
externing him and other accused in Crime No.283 of 2025 under Section 10 of the 
Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 (“
SC/ST Act” for brevity).

##### **Crl.O.P No. 24866 of 2025**

2.Crl.O.P.No.24866 of 2025 has been filed by the State represented by the Superintendent
of Police, Deputy Superintendent of Police, and Inspector of Police of Walajabad
Police Station, challenging the _suo motu _order of the learned Principal District
and Sessions Judge, Kancheepuram, dated 08.09.2025, in Crime No.283 of 2025 on the
file of the Walajabad Police Station, ordering remand of Mr.M.Sankar Ganesh, Deputy
Superintendent of Police, Kancheepuram, under Section 4 of the SC/ST Act.

#### **Both petitions make serious allegations**

3.Both these Criminal Original Petitions are moved today after obtaining leave of
this Court, making serious allegations against the learned Principal District and
Sessions Judge, Kancheepuram, that the entire orders are a result of personal motive
and in order to wreck vengeance against his then Personal Security Officer (PSO),
namely Lokeshwaran Ravi, who is the petitioner in Crl.O.P.No.24853 of 2025.

4.Originally there were two complaints filed before the Walajabad Police Station,
one by T.Sivakumar, S/o.Kalimuthu and another by Mrs.Parvathi, W/o.Murugan. The 
crux of the allegations in both the complaints are that there was some altercation
between two groups, one group consisting of the then PSO of the learned Principal
District and Sessions Judge, namely Lokeshwaran Ravi, his father-in-law and others,
and the other group consisting of Parvathi and their family members. It is the allegation
that the father-in-law of the PSO owned a Bakery and on 25.07.2025, when the said
Parvathi’s husband and others came to the Bakery to purchase some Bakery items, 
there arose some altercation between the two groups, which resulted in filing of
complaints by both sides before the Walajabad Police Station and accordingly, two
CSRs, viz., C.S.R.Nos.1121 of 2025 and 1122 of 2025 were registered by the Police
on 25.07.2025. On enquiry, since both sides agreed to settle the matter amicably,
on the basis of the statements recorded from the parties, both the complaints have
been closed on 28.07.2025. Both the CSRs were disposed of on the same day.

#### **Contention of the petitioner**

##### **District Judge contacted SP to change Judge’s PSO for sending anonymous complaint against the judge**

5. However, it is the contention of the petitioner in Crl.O.P.No.24853 of 2025 that
the learned Principal District and Sessions Judge, under whom he was working, was
under the belief that his PSO (petitioner herein) was responsible for sending some
anonymous complaint against the Judge repeatedly. Therefore, in order to take action
against the PSO, he had contacted the Superintendent of Police to change his PSO.
To substantiate such conversation, the WhatsApp messages have also been filed by
the State in Crl.O.P.No.24866 of 2025. The learned Judge, on coming to know about
the closure of the complaint against his PSO, in order to wreck vengeance, called
the concerned Inspector of Police and orally instructed him to register an FIR as
against his PSO based on the closed CSRs. It is also alleged by the petitioners 
herein that the learned Judge threatened the Inspector of Police that, in the event
of failure to register the FIR, action will be taken against the Inspector of Police
under Section 4 of the SC/ST Act. Pursuant to such direction, an FIR in Crime No.
282 of 2025 came to be registered as against Murugan, Husband of Parvathi for the
offences under Sections 296(b), 115(2), 118(1), 351(3) BNS and Section 3(1) of Tamil
Nadu Public Property (Prevention of Damages and Loss) Act, 1992; and FIR in Crime
No.283 of 2025 came to be registered as against the PSO and his family members for
the offences under Sections 296(b), 115(2) of BNS, Section 4 of Tamil Nadu Prohibition
of Harassment of Women Act, 2002 and Section 3(2)(va) of the SC/ST Act on 20.08.2025.
It is relevant to note that both these FIRs were registered based on the closed 
CSRs. It is also to be noted that, in the FIR registered against the PSO and his
family members, on the basis of the complaint given by Parvathi, an offence under
SC/ST Act has also been included.

6. Thereafter, the learned Principal District and Sessions Judge has passed _suo
motu _order on 04.09.2025 under Section 10 of the SC/ST Act for externment of the
accused persons, including the PSO, his father-in-law and others, in Crime No.283
of 2025. The _suo motu _order dated 04.09.2025 is as follows :

“ …………… “

7. Not stopping with that, the learned Judge has called upon the Deputy Superintendent
of Police, Kancheepuram, to enquire about the implementation of the order passed
by him. Accordingly, the Deputy Superintendent of Police also appeared before the
Principal District and Sessions Judge on 08.09.2025 and it is alleged that the Deputy
Superintendent of Police was made to sit from morning to evening. In the evening,
suddenly the learned Principal District and Sessions Judge, took cognizance of offence
under Section 4 of the SC/ST Act against the Deputy Superintendent of Police and
issued another _suo motu _order as against the Deputy Superintendent of Police remanding
him to judicial custody till 22.09.2025. It is also alleged in the petition that,
based on the warrant, immediately, the Deputy Superintendent of Police was taken
to Sub-Jail, Kancheepuram, by the Court staff in the official car of the learned
Principal District and Sessions Judge. Hence, it is the contention by the petitioners
in both the petitions that both the orders have been passed by the learned Judge
by misusing his power and position as Principal District and Sessions Judge and 
therefore, both the orders are nothing but clear abuse of process of law with a 
motive. Hence, the petitioners seek to set aside both the _suo motu _orders dated
04.09.2025 and 08.09.2025 passed by the learned Principal District and Sessions 
Judge.

##### **The PSO is added as an accused in a FIR by an suo motu order of the District Judge**

8. As far as the externment order passed by the learned Judge on 04.09.2025 under
Section 10 of the SC/ST Act is concerned, the learned Principal District and Sessions
Judge has exercised _suo motu _powers. According to the learned Judge, the FIR in
Crime No.283 of 2025 was registered on 20.08.2025 and no action has been taken so
far. Therefore, he has passed the order of externment against one Siva Marumagan
and all other accused in Crime No.283 of 2025. It is to be noted that the person
known as “Siva Marumagan” in the impugned order is none other than the then PSO 
who served under the said Judge.

##### **Before externment order under section 10 of SC/ST Act can be passed either there must be a complaint or a police report**

9. Be that as it may. Before passing an order of externment under Section 10 of 
the SC/ST Act, there must be either a complaint or a Police report. Only on satisfaction
of either the compliant or Police report, the Special Court can pass such externment
order. Admittedly, except the FIR received by the Court, no other Police report,
whatsoever, has been filed. Be that as it may. Though the Courts have been vested
with powers under SC/ST Act for passing orders of externment, this Court is of the
view that such externment orders are required only when there is a real atrocity
committed on the members of Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribes, provided such persons
or accused are likely to commit an offence under Chapter-II of the SC/ST Act in 
any area included in scheduled areas or tribal areas as referred to in Article 244
of Constitution of India or any area identified under the provisions of Sub-Clause(
vii) of Clause (2) of Section 21 of SC/ST Act. It is not even verified by the learned
Judge as to whether the said area comes under the scheduled area or tribal area 
or areas identified under Section 21(2)(vii) of the SC/ST Act. Only when the Special
Court is satisfied that the offender is likely to commit similar offence and atrocities
on the vulnerable sections of society, such order of externment is normally warranted.
However, in the given case, on a careful perusal of the very complaints given by
both sides, it is clear that there were mere altercations between the parties while
purchasing some eatables in the Bakery and naturally, one side may not even know
what is the caste of the other side. Such is the nature of the complaints given 
by both sides. When the parties themselves have given statements which resulted 
in closure of the complaints earlier, the allegations raised by the petitioner that
the present FIRs came to be filed later pursuant to the oral direction of the learned
Principal District Judge, appears to be quite probable, however, the same is not
a definite conclusion. Having regard to the nature of the complaints made by either
side, its closure based on the statements of the parties earlier, registration of
FIRs thereafter, passing of the externment order immediately, this Court is of the
view that the order of externment passed against the PSO and other accused under
Section 10 of the SC/ST Act in Crime No.283 of 2025 is totally unwarranted.

##### **Remand order for not to arrest the accused cannot lie inasmuch as arrest is the prerogative of the police**

10. As far as the _suo motu _order passed by the learned Principal District and 
Sessions Judge on 08.09.2025, taking cognizance under Section 4 of the SC/ST Act
and ordering remand of the Deputy Superintendent of Police for not arresting the
accused persons in Crime No.283 of 2025, it is relevant to note that arrest is purely
the discretion of the Investigating Officer. The Court cannot direct that a particular
person should be arrested. However, in the given case, it is to be noted that the
Deputy Superintendent of Police was summoned and he was made as an accused under
Section 4(1) of the SC/ST Act and has been ordered to be remanded to judicial custody
for not taking action against the accused persons in Crime No.283 of 2025.

##### **Manner in which impugned orders were passed probabilise the prima facie of the allegations made in the affidavits**

11. The manner in which the impugned orders are passed _prima facie _would probabilise
the allegations made in the affidavits filed in support of these petitions. Be that
as it may. While taking any action or cognizance as against a public servant under
Section 4 of the SC/ST Act, unless there is a definite recommendation on the administrative
side or a positive finding with regard to the negligent act under the SC/ST Act,
the proceedings cannot be automatically initiated as a matter of right. In this 
regard, the Apex Court in **_State of GNCT of Delhi and others v. Praveen Kumar 
alias Prashanth _**reported in **_(2024) SCC Online SC 1591, _**has held as follows:

**“13.3. **In other words, to set in motion the penal proceedings including taking
cognizance for an offence of commission and omission under section 4(2) of the Act
of 1989, the recommendation of the administrative enquiry is a sine qua non. The
proviso is an inbuilt safeguard to the public servant from initiation of prosecution
by every dissatisfied complainant. On appreciation of offences covered by section
3 and the nature of offences conversely dealt with under section 4 of the Act of
1989, it is noted that a complaint under section 3 presupposes insult, accusation,
victimization, etc. of a member of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes by 
a non-Scheduled Caste/Tribe person. However, the commission or omission by a public
servant is rendered as an offence when the public servant contravenes the duties
spelt in section 4(2) of the Act of 1989 read with the Rules of 1995 and by a recommendation
made to that effect. The test in an enquiry is whether the public servant willfully
neglected the duties required to be performed by the public servant under the Act
of 1989 or not.**”**

12. The above judgment would clearly indicate that, to set in motion the penal proceedings
or even to take cognizance under Section 4 of the SC/ST Act, the recommendation 
of the administrative enquiry is a _sine qua non. _Therefore, merely because the
Deputy Superintendent of Police or other Police officials have not immediately implemented
some directions issued by the learned Judge in the name of externment, it cannot
be said that the Deputy Superintendent of Police or the other Police officials have
committed an offence under Section 4(2) of the SC/ST Act. Considering the said aspect,
the _suo motu _order of the learned Principal District and Sessions Judge, Kancheepuram,
remanding the Deputy Superintendent of Police, is also not warranted.

**District Judge’s remand order quashed**

13. In view of the narrative _supra_, **both these Criminal Original Petitions are
allowed **and the impugned _suo motu _orders passed by the learned Principal District
and Sessions Judge, Kancheepuram, dated 04.09.2025 and 08.09.2025, are set aside.**
Mr.M.Sankar Ganesh, Deputy Superintendent of Police, Kancheepuram, is directed to
be released forthwith. **Consequently, connected miscellaneous petitions are closed.

    ```wp-block-verse
    14. With regard to the nature of allegations made in these petitions as against the learned Principal District and Sessions Judge, Kancheepuram, particularly with regard to the conversations in WhatsApp between the learned Principal District and Sessions Judge and the Superintendent of Police and the specific allegations with regard to coercion to file an FIR and to take action against the PSO and the transfer action against the PSO and the passing of externment order immediately after filing of FIR and the passing of remand order as against the Deputy Superintendent of Police for implementing the externment order immediately, are to be completely probed to find out the truth. This Court is of the view that the independent probing is required in this matter.
    ```

**Direction to the Registrar (Vigilance) to enquire allegations against District
Judge, Kancheepuram**

    ```wp-block-verse
    15.In such view of the matter, the Registrar (Vigilance), High Court, Madras, is directed to conduct an enquiry with regard to the specific allegations made in the affidavits filed in both the Criminal Original Petitions with regard to the motive, bias and misuse of power and conversations between the learned Principal District and Sessions Judge and the Police officials after filing of the complaints dated 25.07.2025 till passing of the last order by the learned Judge. Registry is directed to communicate a copy of this order, along with all the case papers, to the Registrar (Vigilance). The Registrar (Vigilance) shall conduct an enquiry in this regard and file a report before this Court on 23.09.2025 for taking further action.
    ```

#### **Party**

Lokeshwaran Ravi as the petitioner in Crl.O.P.No.24853 of 2025 and The State of 
Tamil Nadu and Parvathy as respondents. In Crl.O.P.No.24866 of 2025, the petitioners
are The State represented by The Superintendent of Police, Kancheepuram, Deputy 
Superintendent of Police, Kancheepuram Sub Division, and The Inspector of Police,
Walajabad Police Station, with Parvathi as the respondent – Crl.O.P.Nos.24853 & 
24866 of 2025 – dated September 9, 2025 – Honourable Mr. Justice N. Sathish Kumar.

[DSP Remand order Quash MHC](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/DSP-Remand-order-Quash-MHC.pdf)
[Download](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/DSP-Remand-order-Quash-MHC.pdf)

**Author’s note**: Advocates may get the order copy from the internet by selecting
the case status.
