# Complaint: Validity of second complaint

- Link: https://section1.in/validity-of-second-compliant/
- Published: 2023-06-25T14:52:46+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

5. The factum of registration of the FIR and arrest of the appellant in that case
was telecasted and published in the TV and print media by the respondents.

6. The appellant having felt that the action of the respondents amounted to criminal
defamation, filed a Criminal Complaint under Sections 499 and 500 IPC etc. which
was, however, dismissed by the learned Judicial Magistrate on 28.04.2015 by passing
the following Order:

“Heard perused, it is alleged by the Petitioner that the Respondents broadcasted
and published defamation against the Petitioner. On perusal of the available material
which is revealed that the content of the Petitioner falls in the Fourth exception
of U/s 499 of IPC. Hence, there is no prima facie case made out against the Respondents
for the alleged offences. Hence, this Petition stands is dismissed.

8. Thereafter, the appellant filed second Criminal complaint, i.e, S.T.C 45/2017
in the Court of Judicial Magistrate at Tiruchendur which too was under the same 
provisions as was his first complaint.

9. It is hardly in dispute that the second complaint was replica of the first complaint
with each and every averments being identical except that in the second complaint,
the appellant added one more paragraph No. 11, incorporating the factum of filing
Criminal Revision before the High Court; rejection thereof and further claiming 
that he had filed a second complaint “as per the order of the Hon’ble Madurai Bench
of the Madras High Court”.

10. In the second complaint, learned Judicial Magistrate summoned the respondents
which prompted them to file a Petition under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. before the
High Court, seeking quashing of the said complaint primarily on the ground that 
the second complaint on the same set of facts and circumstances was not maintainable.
Vide impugned Judgment and Order dated 30.08.2019, the High Court allowed the petition
filed by the respondents and consequently, the second complaint filed by the appellant
has been quashed.

xxx

14. There can be no quarrel that in view of the decisions of this Court in “Pramantha
Nath Talukdar v. Saroj Ranjan Sarkar” AIR 1962 Supreme Court 876” and “Shivshankar
Singh vs. State of Bihar and Another” (2012) 1 SCC 130, the second complaint can
be maintainable in exceptional circumstances, depending upon the manner in which
the first complaint came to be dismissed. To say it differently, if the first complaint
was dismissed without venturing into the merits of the case or on a technical ground
and/or by returning a reasoning which can be termed as perverse or absurd in law,
and/or when the essential foundation of second complaint is based upon such set 
of facts which were either not in existence at the time when the first complaint
was filed or the complainant could not have possibly lay his hands to such facts
at that time, an exception can be made to entertain the second complaint.

15. These principles, however, in our considered view, are not attracted to the 
facts circumstances of the case in hand. When the first complaint was filed primarily
under Sections 499 and 500 IPC, the Judicial Magistrate was well within his jurisdictional
competence to find out whether a prima facie case for summoning the accused was 
made out or not.

16. This essentially involved application of judicial mind to reach a definite conclusion
as to whether or not the accused be summoned. In the instant case, the learned Judicial
Magistrate having found that the allegations made by the appellant were in the teeth
of fourth exception to Section 499 IPC, he declined to issue process to the respondents.
Such dismissal cannot be said to be without application of judicial mind. The application
of judicial mind and arriving at an erroneous conclusion are two distinct things.
The Court even after due application of mind may reach to an erroneous conclusion
and such an order is always justiciable before a superior Court. Even if the said
Order is set aside, it does not mean that the trial court did not apply its mind.

18. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant then relies upon the Judgment of
this Court in “Subramanian Swamy Vs. Union of India” (2016) 7 SCC 221, to urge that
the onus was on the respondents to establish that the appellant’s first complaint
was barred by fourth exception to Section 499 of IPC.

19. It appears to us that such a contention was available to the appellant before
the High Court in Criminal Revision filed by him challenging the order of dismissal
of his first complaint. The appellant instead of withdrawing the Criminal Revision,
ought to have invited an order on merits including on the contention sought to be
raised now. As stated earlier, even if the order of learned Judicial Magistrate 
while dismissing the first complaint was erroneous in law, it does not amount to
nonapplication of mind by
 the trial court.

PARTY: B.R.K.AATHITHAN vs. SUN GROUP & ANR – Crl.Apl Nos: 2080_2083 of 2022 – 29th
November 2022.

**[https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2020/618/618_2020_11_48_40173_Judgement_29-Nov-2022.pdf](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2020/618/618_2020_11_48_40173_Judgement_29-Nov-2022.pdf)**

**[B.R.K.AATHITHAN-vs.-SUN-GROUP-second-complaint](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/B.R.K.AATHITHAN-vs.-SUN-GROUP-second-complaint-1.pdf)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
