# Weekly Digest December’2024 (last volume)

- Link: https://section1.in/weekly-digest-december2024-last-volume/
- Published: 2025-01-02T11:26:06+00:00
- Author: section1

Contents

 * [Supreme Court Invalidates State Government’s Scheduled Caste Notification, Upholding Constitutional Authority ](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-december2024-last-volume/#supreme-court-invalidates-state-governments-scheduled-caste-notification-upholding-constitutional-authority%c2%a0)
 * [Pakistan to Gujarat Border Narcotics: NIA Act is offence centric and not accused centric: Cancellation of bail upheld](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-december2024-last-volume/#pakistan-to-gujarat-border-narcotics-nia-act-is-offence-centric-and-not-accused-centric-cancellation-of-bail-upheld)
 * [High Court cannot damage the career of judicial officer by way of observations if the trial court did not follow specific format given by High Court](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-december2024-last-volume/#high-court-cannot-damage-the-career-of-judicial-officer-by-way-of-observations%c2%a0if-the-trial-court-did-not-follow-specific-format-given-by-high-court)
 * [Duty of the registry is to control litigants who files synopsis that runs 128 pages](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-december2024-last-volume/#duty-of-the-registry-is-to-control-litigants-who-files-synopsis-that-runs-128-pages)
 * [Supreme Court Mandates Immediate Redistribution of Surplus Land in Landmark Judgment ](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-december2024-last-volume/#supreme-court-mandates-immediate-redistribution-of-surplus-land-in-landmark-judgment%c2%a0)
 * [Appeal against acquittal: In appeal against acquittal presumption of innocence is fortified and appellate Court not to take contrary view if trial court’s view is plausible](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-december2024-last-volume/#appeal-against-acquittal-in-appeal-against-acquittal-presumption-of-innocence-is-fortified-and-appellate-court-not-to-take-contrary-view-if-trial-courts-view-is-plausible)
 * [Witness saw accused with blood-stained shirt but did not see him together with the deceased cannot be a proof for last seen theory](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-december2024-last-volume/#witness-saw-accused-with-bloodstained-shirt-but-did-not-see-him-together-with-the-deceased-cannot-be-a-proof-for-last-seen-theory)
 * [Quashing FIR based on settlement in special statute like PC Act would impact the society at large ](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-december2024-last-volume/#quashing-fir-based-on-settlement-in-special-statute-like-pc-act-would-impact-the-society-at-large%c2%a0)
 * [Company is the drawer of the cheque and the authorised signatory is merely a limb that signs the cheque](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-december2024-last-volume/#company-is-the-drawer-of-the-cheque-and-the-authorised-signatory-is-merely-a-limb-that-signs-the-cheque)
 * [Suicide instigation should put in such position that the victim has no other option but to commit suicide](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-december2024-last-volume/#suicide-instigation-should-put-in-such-position-that-the-victim-has-no-other-option-but-to-commit-suicide)
 * [After the accident vehicle caused the accident dragged in high speed about 15 feet hence the act of rash and negligence proved](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-december2024-last-volume/#after-the-accident-vehicle-caused-the-accident-dragged-in-high-speed-about-15-feet-hence-the-act-of-rash-and-negligence-proved)
 * [Parents visiting right is modified keeping the child’s well-being and health](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-december2024-last-volume/#parents-visiting-right-is-modified-keeping-the-childs-wellbeing-and-health)
 * [Petitioner should not be found fault for presenting words from ‘Manusmriti’ that degrade women](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-december2024-last-volume/#petitioner-should-not-be-found-fault-for-presenting-words-from-manusmriti-that-degrade-women)
 * [As per Section 323 of Cr.P.C the Magistrate before signing judgment may commit the case if the same has to try by court of Sessions](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-december2024-last-volume/#as-per-section-323-of-crpc-the-magistrate-before-signing-judgment-may-commit-the-case-if-the-same-has-to-try-by-court-of-sessions)
 * [In the light of investigation order freezing the account without quantifying the amount and period cannot be passed by the police](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-december2024-last-volume/#in-the-light-of-investigation-order-freezing-the-account-without-quantifying-the-amount-and-period-cannot-be-passed-by-the-police)
 * [High Court would be justified in quashing the proceedings if the allegations taken in its entirety do not prima facie constitute a case against the accused](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-december2024-last-volume/#high-court-would-be-justified-in-quashing-the-proceedings-if-the-allegations-taken-in-its-entirety-do-not-prima-facie-constitute-a-case-against-the-accused)

### **󠀁[Supreme Court Invalidates State Government’s Scheduled Caste Notification, Upholding Constitutional Authority ](http://localhost:8080/section1/supreme-court-invalidates-state-governments-scheduled-caste-notification-upholding-constitutional-authority/)󠁿**

The case of Union of India vs. Rohit Nandan revolves around the appeal by the Union
of India against a ruling by the Patna High Court that had allowed Rohit Nandan’s
writ petition challenging the dismissal of his Original Application by the Central
Administrative Tribunal. The High Court’s decision had favored Nandan, granting 
him recognition under the Scheduled Caste category. However, the Supreme Court overturned
this ruling, restoring the Tribunal’s dismissal and clarifying that Nandan could
not continue to benefit from an illegal certification as a member of the Scheduled
Caste. The Court emphasized the importance of adhering to legal classifications 
established by appropriate procedures. This case highlights the complexities surrounding
caste classifications and the judicial interpretation of constitutional protections
for Scheduled Castes.

### **󠀁[Pakistan to Gujarat Border Narcotics: NIA Act is offence centric and not accused centric: Cancellation of bail upheld](http://localhost:8080/section1/pakistan-to-gujarat-border-narcotics-nia-act-is-offence-centric-and-not-accused-centric-cancellation-of-bail-upheld/)󠁿**

In a significant ruling, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India addressed the complexities
surrounding bail cancellation in the case of Ankush Vipan Kapoor against the National
Investigation Agency (NIA). The petitioner, Ankush Vipan Kapoor, filed a Special
Leave Petition (Crl.) No. 2819 of 2024, challenging the order of the Punjab and 
Haryana High Court that canceled his bail in relation to FIR No. 20/2020. This case
sheds light on critical issues of law concerning the powers of investigative agencies,
the rights of the accused, and the judicial process in serious criminal allegations.
Present FIR pertains to 500 kgs narcotics smuggling and distribution illicitly transported
from Pakistan to Gujarat  The backdrop of this judgment involves serious charges
under the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act and the Unlawful
Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA), where the NIA argued for the cancellation of
Kapoor’s bail based on the need for custodial interrogation. The agency’s position
was predicated on the belief that the investigation revealed connections between
multiple FIRs, showcasing a broader network of organized drug trafficking. During
the proceedings, the Supreme Court weighed the arguments presented by senior counsel
for the petitioner against the assertions made by the NIA and the Union of India,
emphasizing the intricate relationship between different offenses being investigated.
This judgment serves as a notable precedent regarding the balance of justice and
the presumption of innocence in cases involving serious allegations. The Court’s
decision not only addresses the legal remedies available to the accused but also
underscores the judiciary’s role in ensuring that the rights of individuals are 
not compromised during the investigative process. As the implications of this ruling
unfold, it marks a crucial point in the dialogue surrounding criminal law, procedural
justice, and the operational dynamics of the NIA in handling high-profile cases 
of national concern.

### **󠀁[High Court cannot damage the career of judicial officer by way of observations if the trial court did not follow specific format given by High Court](http://localhost:8080/section1/high-court-cannot-damage-the-career-of-judicial-officer-by-way-of-observations-if-the-trial-court-did-not-follow-specific-format-given-by-high-court/)󠁿**

The Supreme Court of India, ruled in favor of Ayub Khan, a District and Sessions
Judge in Rajasthan, who had appealed against an adverse observations and directions
issued by the Hon’ble High Court for not following its prescribed format ( a particular
form) in a bail order. The Supreme Court emphasized that while the High Court can
set principles for granting bail, it cannot mandate the format of bail orders, and
non-compliance should not be treated as indiscipline or contempt. Consequently, 
the Supreme Court expunged the adverse remarks and set aside the High Court’s directions,
thereby protecting the judicial discretion of trial courts and ensuring that judicial
officers are not unfairly penalized for procedural non-compliance.  

### **󠀁[Duty of the registry is to control litigants who files synopsis that runs 128 pages](http://localhost:8080/section1/duty-of-the-registry-is-to-control-litigants-who-files-synopsis-that-runs-128-pages/)󠁿**

The Supreme Court of India granted Deepti Sharma leave to appeal, condoning delays
in filing. Deepti Sharma, who obtained a divorce decree on grounds of cruelty in
2016, challenged a 2019 order from the Allahabad High Court’s Division Bench. This
order, passed under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC), was initially
directed by the Supreme Court to be heard by a single judge but was instead decided
by a Division Bench due to the Supreme Court’s earlier directive.  The High Court
had set aside a Family Court order from May 27, 2019, which dismissed Deepti Sharma’s
Section 125 CrPC petition for non-prosecution, and restored the petition for a fresh
hearing. The Supreme Court found no reason to interfere with the High Court’s order,
which was in favor of Deepti Sharma, and dismissed the civil appeal, directing the
Family Court to adjudicate the matter afresh.  The Supreme Court also noted that
other related cases, including contempt petitions and a criminal case, were pending
in the High Court and requested their expedited resolution. The appellant’s extensive
128-page synopsis was deemed excessive, and the court emphasized the need for concise
submissions in future cases.

### **󠀁[Supreme Court Mandates Immediate Redistribution of Surplus Land in Landmark Judgment](http://localhost:8080/section1/supreme-court-mandates-immediate-redistribution-of-surplus-land-in-landmark-judgment/)󠁿** 

Supreme Court Mandates Immediate Redistribution of Surplus Land in Landmark Judgment.

### **󠀁[Appeal against acquittal: In appeal against acquittal presumption of innocence is fortified and appellate Court not to take contrary view if trial court’s view is plausible](http://localhost:8080/section1/appeal-against-acquittal-in-appeal-against-acquittal-presumption-of-innocence-is-fortified-and-appellate-court-not-to-take-contrary-view-if-trial-courts-view-is-plausible/)󠁿**

The case is a criminal appeal filed under Section 374 (2) of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973, to set aside the judgment in S.C.No.153 of 2011 delivered by the
Principal District Sessions Judge, Thiruvannamalai District. The appellant, the 
defacto complainant, alleged that the first accused and his wife attacked him and
their father, leading to the father’s death. The trial court acquitted the accused
due to insufficient evidence and lack of corroboration from independent witnesses.
The appellant argued that the trial court erred by not giving due credence to his
testimony as an injured witness. However, the High Court upheld the trial court’s
decision, stating that the trial court’s view was legally plausible and there was
no ground to interfere with the acquittal.

### **󠀁[Witness saw accused with blood-stained shirt but did not see him together with the deceased cannot be a proof for last seen theory](http://localhost:8080/section1/witness-saw-accused-with-blood-stained-shirt-but-did-not-see-him-together-with-the-deceased-cannot-be-a-proof-for-last-seen-theory/)󠁿**

This judgment is a criminal appeal (Crl.A.No.232 of 2019) decided by the High Court
of Judicature at Madras concerning the appellant, Aravindan, who was convicted in
S.C.No.69 of 2017 for murder under Section 302 IPC. The case arises from an incident
on 13.06.2016, wherein the deceased, Chinnasamy, was killed by the appellant during
a quarrel while under the influence of alcohol. Following the incident, an FIR was
lodged by the deceased’s son, leading to the investigation and arrest of the accused.
The prosecution presented evidence, including witness statements and a confession
made by the accused. The court highlights the importance of both circumstantial 
evidence and eye witness testimonies (PWs 6, 7, and 8). It scrutinizes the credibility
of these witnesses, noting that PW-7, the son-in-law of the deceased, and the other
witnesses did not report the incident to the police or inform the deceased’s family,
raising questions about their reliability. The court refers to established legal
principles regarding the sufficiency of circumstantial evidence. It emphasizes that
the evidence presented must be compelling enough to exclude any reasonable doubt
regarding the guilt of the accused. The court insists that all links in the chain
of evidence must be established to substantiate a conviction. The sheer delay in
forwarding statement recorded under section 161 Crpc was flagged as indicative of
potential issues with the integrity of the prosecution’s case. Given the doubts 
raised about the reliability of the evidence and the failure of the prosecution 
to meet the requisite legal standards, the court suggests that the accused should
not be convicted based on the evidence submitted and finally acquitted the accused
by setting aside the sentence.

### **󠀁[Quashing FIR based on settlement in special statute like PC Act would impact the society at large](http://localhost:8080/section1/quashing-fir-based-on-settlement-in-special-statute-like-pc-act-would-impact-the-society-at-large/)󠁿** 

The case involves allegations against the appellants related to fraud and cheating
concerning a loan of Rs. 25 Crores obtained from SICOM Ltd. in 2013. The complaint,
lodged by respondent no. 3 with the Central Bureau of Investigation, claims that
the appellants diverted funds from the loan account and changed building plans without
bank consent, which resulted in the collateral’s reduced value. Initially valued
at Rs. 107.7 Crores in 2014, the property’s value plummeted to Rs. 3.45 Crores when
it was revalued in 2018 after the account was designated as a Non-Performing Asset.
The FIR was registered against the appellants on 24.07.2022, and a chargesheet was
filed on 31.12.2021. The appellants sought to quash the FIR and chargesheet through
a Writ Petition which was ultimately rejected by the High Court. Thereafter Hon’ble
Supreme Court dismisses the appeal stating that the quashing of FIR for settlement
in special statute like PC Act would affect the society at large. 

### **󠀁[Company is the drawer of the cheque and the authorised signatory is merely a limb that signs the cheque](http://localhost:8080/section1/company-is-the-drawer-of-the-cheque-and-the-authorised-signatory-is-merely-a-limb-that-signs-the-cheque/)󠁿**

The main legal issue addressed in this case revolves around the maintainability 
of a complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, particularly
concerning the lack of the company’s involvement as an accused party. The High Court
emphasized that, without the company being arraigned as an accused and the necessary
compliance with the requirements for vicarious liability under Section 141, the 
accused could not be convicted as the sole accused. This highlighted the importance
of having the principal offender, in this case, the company part of the proceedings
for the complaint to be considered valid. The conclusion reached in this case is
that the appeal is to be dismissed, and the judgment of the High Court is upheld.
The court affirmed that the findings of lower courts regarding the accused’s liability
under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act were correct. It emphasized 
the necessity of a clear showing of liability and compliance with legal provisions,
confirming that the proceedings followed the appropriate legal framework. The High
Court’s ruling signifies the importance of adhering to the established legal principles
to sustain a claim under the Negotiable Instruments Act. 

### **󠀁[Suicide instigation should put in such position that the victim has no other option but to commit suicide](http://localhost:8080/section1/a-gap-of-over-a-month-would-be-a-sufficient-time-to-dissolve-the-proximate-link-between-the-two-acts-instigation-and-suicide/)󠁿**

The appellants were accused of abetting the suicide of Jyoti Nagre, who committed
suicide by hanging herself on March 20, 2015. The appellants were charged under 
Sections 306 and 34 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). The case revolved around the
allegations of mental and physical torture by the appellants, which led to the deceased’s
suicide. The trial court and the High Court had dismissed the appellants’ plea for
discharge from the charges. The Supreme Court, however, found that there was a significant
time gap between the alleged instigation and the act of suicide, which weakened 
the prosecution’s case. The Apex Court highlighted the importance of establishing
a clear connection between the act of instigation and the act of suicide. The Court
concluded that the appellants’ words and actions did not directly result in the 
deceased’s suicide, as there was no immediate instigation or abetment involved. 
As a result, the Supreme Court upheld the appeal, overturned the decisions of the
lower courts, and discharged the appellants from all charges.

### **󠀁[After the accident vehicle caused the accident dragged in high speed about 15 feet hence the act of rash and negligence proved](http://localhost:8080/section1/after-the-accident-vehicle-caused-the-accident-dragged-in-high-speed-about-15-feet-hence-the-act-of-rash-and-negligence-proved/)󠁿**

In our considered opinion, the Petitioner has miserably failed to raise a reasonable
doubt to probabalise the version narrated by him. The High Court and the Courts 
below are right in concluding that the act of the Petitioner was a rash and negligent
one and have thereby rightly convicted the accused Petitioner.

### **󠀁[Parents visiting right is modified keeping the child’s well-being and health](http://localhost:8080/section1/parents-visiting-right-is-modified-keeping-the-childs-well-being-and-health/)󠁿**

The Supreme Court judgment revolves around a custody dispute between Sugirtha and
Gowtham. The couple married on September 9, 2021, and had a daughter on June 6, 
2022. Following allegations of cruelty and domestic violence, Sugirtha filed for
divorce in June 2023. The Family Court granted Gowtham visitation rights, requiring
Sugirtha to bring their daughter to Karur every Sunday. Sugirtha appealed, arguing
that the 300-kilometer round trip from Madurai to Karur was too burdensome and posed
a threat to the child’s health and safety. The Madras High Court dismissed Sugirtha’s
appeal but modified the visitation schedule to allow visits in Karur for two months
and then alternate weekends. The Supreme Court acknowledged Gowtham’s right to visitation
but prioritized the child’s health and well-being. It modified the visitation location
to Madurai and set specific guidelines for the visits, ensuring that the child’s
health and best interests were not compromised. The Supreme Court’s decision aims
to balance Gowtham’s visitation rights with the child’s best interests and health.
The court emphasized that while the father has the right to visit his child, it 
should not come at the cost of the child’s health and well-being. The judgment reflects
the court’s effort to ensure that the child’s welfare remains paramount in custody
disputes.

### **󠀁[Petitioner should not be found fault for presenting words from ‘Manusmriti’ that degrade women](http://localhost:8080/section1/petitioner-should-not-be-found-fault-for-presenting-words-from-manusmriti-that-degrade-women/)󠁿**

The court quashed the private complaint against Thol. Thirumavalavan, who was accused
of making derogatory remarks about Hindu women in a YouTube video, stating that 
his speech was based on the book “Manu Smriti” and did not constitute hate speech
or any of the alleged offences under Sections 120-B, 295-A, 298, 500, 509 of IPC
and Section 67 of the Information Technology Act. The court found no evidence to
support the allegations and concluded that the petitioner did not intend to degrade
the reputation of Indian women.

### **󠀁[As per Section 323 of Cr.P.C the Magistrate before signing judgment may commit the case if the same has to try by court of Sessions](http://localhost:8080/section1/as-per-section-323-of-cr-p-c-the-magistrate-before-signing-judgment-may-commit-the-case-if-the-same-has-to-try-by-court-of-sessions/)󠁿**

The Hon’ble High court dismissed the petition to quash the criminal case against
K. Kalyanasundaram, proprietor of M/s. Emkay Bio Products, who was the accused of
manufacturing substandard drugs [“not of standard quality”].  Complaint lodged was
under Section 32 of the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940 for the alleged contravention
of Sections 18(a)(i) r/w Section 17-B (d) punishable under Section 27(c) of the 
Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940. The court found that the drugs, tested by both the
Government Analyst and the Central Drugs Laboratory, did not meet the required standards.
The petitioner’s arguments about cognizance, procedural delays and storage conditions
affecting the drug quality were not accepted, and the court ruled that these issues
should be addressed during the trial. Consequently, the criminal proceedings will
continue in the Sessions Court.

### **󠀁[In the light of investigation order freezing the account without quantifying the amount and period cannot be passed by the police](http://localhost:8080/section1/in-the-light-of-investigation-order-freezing-the-account-without-quantifying-the-amount-and-period-cannot-be-passed-by-the-police/)󠁿**

Writ petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying to issue
a Writ of Mandamus, directing the fifth respondent to dispose of the petitioner’s
representation dated 23.07.2024 by defreezing the petitioner’s account bearing Account
No: 50100456613718 and IFSC Code: HDFC0004221 and releasing the entire amount of
Rs.9,69,580/- plus the amount of Rs.2,48,835/- held by the fifth respondent.

### **󠀁[High Court would be justified in quashing the proceedings if the allegations taken in its entirety do not prima facie constitute a case against the accused](http://localhost:8080/section1/high-court-would-be-justified-in-quashing-the-proceedings-if-the-allegations-taken-in-its-entirety-do-not-prima-facie-constitute-a-case-against-the-accused/)󠁿**

This Hon’ble Supreme Court judgment addresses an appeal challenging the High Court’s
dismissal of an application for quashing an FIR in a matrimonial dispute/cruelty.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court emphasized the need for specificity in allegations, noting
that vague accusations against family members without concrete evidence can lead
to misuse of legal processes, resulting in unnecessary harassment of innocent parties.
The Court highlighted the principle that generalized claims in domestic disputes
should not result in criminal prosecution, especially when family members have not
been residing in the matrimonial home. Consequently, the appeal was considered in
light of these principles, aiming to protect individuals from unjust implications
in such cases and Hon’ble Supreme Court quashed the case.

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
