# Weekly Digest: November 1-8′ 2024

- Link: https://section1.in/weekly-digest-november-1-8-2024/
- Published: 2024-11-08T13:02:27+00:00
- Author: section1

Contents

 * [Extra-Judicial confession: VAO is total stranger and no necessity for the accused to trust him to confess](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-november-1-8-2024/#extrajudicial-confession-vao-is-total-stranger-and-no-necessity-for-the-accused-to-trust-him-to-confess)
 * [Cognizance taken without sanction does not prevent ED to seek cognizance again after obtaining the necessary sanction](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-november-1-8-2024/#cognizance-taken-without-sanction-does-not-prevent-ed-to-seek-cognizance-again-after-obtaining-the-necessary-sanction)
 * [Court Martial Murder Case: Armed Forces Tribunal: Order of acquittal enhances the presumption of innocence](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-november-1-8-2024/#court-martial-murder-case-armed-forces-tribunal-order-of-acquittal-enhances-the-presumption-of-innocence)
 * [Sale is not a Contract](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-november-1-8-2024/#sale-is-not-a-contract)
 * [No onerous bail conditions: Condition imposed by the Hon’ble High Court directing the accused to demolish the wall of the complainant at accused’s cost tantamount to deprivation of civil rights rather than to ensure the accused’s presence during trial](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-november-1-8-2024/#no-onerous-bail-conditions-condition-imposed-by-the-honble-high-court-directing-the-accused-to-demolish-the-wall-of-the-complainant-at-accuseds-cost-tantamount-to-deprivation-of-civil-rights-rather-th)
 * [Closure report & PMLA: Closure report filed in predicate offence deserves to be challenged to continue proceedings under PMLA hence though the ED is neither aggrieved person nor victim it may approach the High Court as ED is connected to the issue](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-november-1-8-2024/#closure-report-amp-pmla-closure-report-filed-in-predicate-offence-deserves-to-be-challenged-to-continue-proceedings-under-pmla-hence-though-the-ed-is-neither-aggrieved-person-nor-victim-it-may-approac)
 * [Subject Study on Examination of Witness](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-november-1-8-2024/#subject-study-on-examination-of-witness)

### 󠀁[Extra-Judicial confession: VAO is total stranger and no necessity for the accused to trust him to confess](http://localhost:8080/section1/extra-judicial-confession-vao-is-total-stranger-and-no-necessity-for-the-accused-to-trust-him-to-confess/)󠁿

Prayer-Consideration-List of witnesses and their roles in the case-Deceased died
of asphyxia due to drowning and the external injuries could have caused when the
body was taken out of well-Witnesses hardly establish the motive-Brothers-in-law
of deceased though seen the deceased with the appellants did not make any effort
to complaint-P.W-1 is stranger to A3 and no necessity for A3 to trust and confess
to P.W-1-Prosecution has not proved that the accused attacked the deceased with 
stones-Hon’ble Madras High Court acquitted the accused.

### 󠀁[Cognizance taken without sanction does not prevent ED to seek cognizance again after obtaining the necessary sanction](http://localhost:8080/section1/court-martial-murder-case-armed-forces-tribunal-order-of-acquittal-enhances-the-presumption-of-innocence/)󠁿

**Factual Aspect**: This appeal addresses the quashing of a complaint filed by the
Enforcement Directorate (ED) against a public servant due to the absence of the 
required sanction. **Consideration of Submissions**: In accordance with Section 
197(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC) and the Indian Penal Code (IPC), government
servants can only be prosecuted with prior sanction for actions carried out in the
course of their official duties. Several important points arise: 1. The accused 
has the opportunity to present the lack of sanction as a defense after cognizance
has been taken. 2. It is essential that the actions described in the complaint are
linked to the performance of their official responsibilities. Notably, no provisions
within the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) are in conflict with Section
197(1) CrPC. While the cognizance taken by the Special Court lacks validity due 
to the absence of sanction, this situation opens the door for the ED to seek cognizance
again in the future, provided they obtain the necessary sanction. This path forward
allows for adherence to legal requirements while ensuring accountability.

### 󠀁[Court Martial Murder Case: Armed Forces Tribunal: Order of acquittal enhances the presumption of innocence](http://localhost:8080/section1/court-martial-murder-case-armed-forces-tribunal-order-of-acquittal-enhances-the-presumption-of-innocence/)󠁿

In the case at hand, the respondent was initially tried and convicted by a General
Court Martial under Section 302 read with Section 149 of the Indian Penal Code (
IPC); However, the Armed Forces Tribunal later acquitted the respondent. The circumstances
leading to the incident involved the deceased allegedly misbehaving towards the 
wife of Accused No. 3, which prompted an inquiry. The deceased was transported in
a gypsy vehicle during which he jumped out and fell into a ditch, resulting in serious
injuries and subsequent death in the hospital. A postmortem examination revealed
antemortem injuries to the skull and brain, and it was admitted in cross-examination
that a hard surface, akin to a floor, could have caused the blunt force trauma. 
Notably, there was no allegation made that the deceased was assaulted before entering
the gypsy. The prosecution claimed that the respondent was seen walking with a bamboo
stick, which was never recovered. The Supreme Court found no evidence to support
the assertion that the respondent had assaulted the deceased, reinforcing the presumption
of innocence following the Tribunal’s order of acquittal.

### 󠀁[Sale is not a Contract](http://localhost:8080/section1/sale-is-not-a-contract/)󠁿

The Supreme Court ruled that a minor can be a transferee of immovable property through
a sale deed, as a sale is not considered a contract. The Court also affirmed that
a minor’s transfer of property upon attaining majority cannot be challenged due 
to their previous minor status.

### 󠀁[No onerous bail conditions: Condition imposed by the Hon’ble High Court directing the accused to demolish the wall of the complainant at accused’s cost tantamount to deprivation of civil rights rather than to ensure the accused’s presence during trial](http://localhost:8080/section1/no-onerous-bail-conditions-condition-imposed-by-the-honble-high-court-directing-the-accused-to-demolish-the-wall-of-the-complainant-at-accuseds-cost-tantamount-to-deprivation-of-civil-righ/)󠁿

This appeal addresses the bail condition set by the Hon’ble High Court, which mandates
the removal of the complainant’s wall at the expense of the accused. An FIR has 
been registered under sections 294, 323, 506, 447, 147, 148, and 458 IPC, alleging
that the appellants forcefully entered the complainant’s property by breaking down
a wall and assaulting his family members. This is the second bail application submitted,
contesting the onerous conditions imposed by the Hon’ble High Court. The onerous
conditions include the direction to remove the wall at the appellants’ expense and
to return possession of the disputed property to the complainant. It is important
to note that conditions imposed must be reasonable and not overly burdensome, as
analyzed in various judgments. The purpose of imposing conditions is to facilitate
the administration of justice and to ensure the presence of the accused. In this
instance, the Hon’ble High Court exceeded its jurisdiction by requiring the demolition
of the wall at the expense of the appellants. Finally Hon’ble Supreme Court set 
aside the order and modified the condition.

### 󠀁[Closure report & PMLA: Closure report filed in predicate offence deserves to be challenged to continue proceedings under PMLA hence though the ED is neither aggrieved person nor victim it may approach the High Court as ED is connected to the issue](http://localhost:8080/section1/closure-report-pmla-closure-report-filed-in-predicate-offence-deserves-to-be-challenged-to-continue-proceedings-under-pmla-hence-though-the-ed-is-neither-aggrieved-person-nor-victim-it-may-appr/)󠁿

**Brief Facts of the Case** Information regarding the sale proceeds of lottery tickets
led to an FIR under the IPC and PMLA. Cash was seized from A1’s house, and a statement
from the stamp vendor was recorded under Section 50 of the PMLA. The case involved
the fabrication of a document (stamp paper) dated prior to the government’s sale
to the vendor.  A Single Judge of the Madras High Court quashed the proceedings 
against A3, which the State challenged with a Special Leave Petition (SLP) accepted
by the Apex Court. The Enforcement Directorate (ED) filed a complaint, but requests
for discharge by A1, A3, and A4 were dismissed by the Principal District Judge of
Chennai. The state police filed a closure report on the IPC offense, accepted by
the Judicial Magistrate. The ED then sought to dispose of the SLP.  **Discussions**
The ED aimed to quash the closure report filed by the state police, asserting the
maintainability of the petition to contest the closure report and the continuation
of proceedings under the PMLA. It was clarified that any party connected to the 
case could approach the High Court.  An analysis of judgments indicated that accepting
the closure report was a mechanical order leading to a miscarriage of justice.  **
Conclusion**  The closure report and the magistrate’s acceptance of it have been
set aside.

### 󠀁[Subject Study on Examination of Witness](http://localhost:8080/section1/subject-study-on-examination-of-witness/)󠁿

Judgments related to Cross-examination including contradiction is being listed.
