# Weekly Digest: November final’ 2024

- Link: https://section1.in/weekly-digest-november-final-2024/
- Published: 2024-11-24T14:48:09+00:00
- Author: section1

Contents

 * [Section 156(3) Cr.P.C: It is erroneous if Magistrates direct the police to conduct preliminary enquiry and register the fir](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-november-final-2024/#section-1563-crpc-it-is-erroneous-if-magistrates-direct-the-police-to-conduct-preliminary-enquiry-and-register-the-fir)
 * [POCSO COMPROMISE QUASH: Power under section 482 Cr. P.C could not be used to quash heinous offences based on compromise which has a serious impact on society](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-november-final-2024/#pocso-compromise-quash-power-under-section-482-cr-pc-could-not-be-used-to-quash-heinous-offences-based-on-compromise-which-has-a-serious-impact-on-society)
 * [S. 303(2) BNS: Anticipatory Bail was filed for a bailable offence however the  Hon’ble High Court quashed the FIR](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-november-final-2024/#s-3032-bns-anticipatory-bail-was-filed-for-a-bailable-offence-however-the-%c2%a0honble-high-court-quashed-the-fir)
 * [Under section 195 Cr.P.C Hon’ble High Court can commence criminal proceeding](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-november-final-2024/#under-section-195-crpc-honble-high-court-can-commence-criminal-proceeding)
 * [How to mark confession explained: If inadmissible portions of confession are allowed in deposition, there is a significant risk that the trial courts may be influenced by it](https://section1.in/weekly-digest-november-final-2024/#how-to-mark-confession-explained-if-inadmissible-portions-of-confession-are-allowed-in-deposition-there-is-a-significant-risk-that-the-trial-courts-may-be-influenced-by-it)

### 󠀁[Section 156(3) Cr.P.C: It is erroneous if Magistrates direct the police to conduct preliminary enquiry and register the fir](http://localhost:8080/section1/section-1563-cr-p-c-it-is-erroneous-if-magistrates-direct-the-police-to-conduct-preliminary-enquiry-and-register-the-fir/)󠁿

Prayer-Magistrate has adopted wrong procedure by directing the police to register
the FIR if cognizable offence is made out-Procedure to approach Judicial Magistrate
for petition under section 156(3) Cr.P.C-As per Lalitha Kumar constitutional bench
Station House Officer is duty bound to register FIR if cognizable offence is found
out in the information-Application of Judicial mind is necessary-Magistrate erred
in directing the police to conduct enquiry and register fir if cognizable offence
is found out-Magistrate’s order was recalled-Direction to magistrate to submit report.

### 󠀁[POCSO COMPROMISE QUASH: Power under section 482 Cr. P.C could not be used to quash heinous offences based on compromise which has a serious impact on society](http://localhost:8080/section1/pocso-compromise-quash-power-under-section-482-cr-p-c-could-not-be-used-to-quash-heinous-offences-based-on-compromise-which-has-a-serious-impact-on-society/)󠁿

The judgment regarding the opening of an FIR involves a teacher who allegedly misbehaved
with a child in the XI grade by patting her cheeks and touching her upper body. 
The Honorable High Court quashed the FIR after noting that the matter had been compromised
with the child’s father. The appellants, who are third parties to the proceedings
and reside in the same district as the accused, challenged the quashing of the FIR,
arguing that it has societal implications. Their locus standi was challenged because
they were not parties to the original case. Two key questions arose from the proceedings
and the Apex court answered as follows: 1. The amicus curiae argued that if the 
State did not pursue the matter, a public-spirited individual should have locus 
standi in the interest of justice, as offenses under the POCSO Act are harmful to
society. Additionally, there is a procedure to convert a petition filed under Article
32 into a Special Leave Petition. A private party can file a petition under Article
136 if an acquittal results in a serious miscarriage of justice. 2. The compromise
was accepted without considering the nature and gravity of the offense, and the 
Station House Officer (SHO) was directed to submit a closure report. The Apex Court
found that the Honorable High Court failed to give proper consideration to the principles
outlined in Gian Singh’s case. Guidelines for quashing were issued, stating that
the power under Section 482 of the Cr. P.C. should not be used to quash serious 
offenses based solely on a compromise, as this could have a significant impact on
society. Finally, the appeal was allowed.

### 󠀁[S. 303(2) BNS: Anticipatory Bail was filed for a bailable offence however the  Hon’ble High Court quashed the FIR](http://localhost:8080/section1/s-3032-bns-anticipatory-bail-was-filed-for-a-bailable-offence-however-the-honble-high-court-quashed-the-fir/)󠁿

The petitioner filed an application for anticipatory bail for the offence under 
section 303(2) of the BNS., 2023 regarding the theft of tyres valued at Rs. 3,000.
It is the admitted prosecution case that the value of the stolen property is less
than Rs. 5,000. Since the value of the stolen property is Rs. 3,000, this is classified
as a non-cognizable offence. Therefore, the police should have registered the FIR
only after obtaining the appropriate order from the Magistrate. The petition for
anticipatory bail is not maintainable since the offence is bailable. Hon’ble Madras
High Court has quashed the FIR.

### 󠀁[Under section 195 Cr.P.C Hon’ble High Court can commence criminal proceeding](http://localhost:8080/section1/under-section-195-cr-p-c-honble-high-court-can-commence-criminal-proceeding/)󠁿

Appeal against the quashing of order taking cognizance and further direction to 
take action under section 195 Cr.P.C-An Australian national was caught at the airport
for having possession of packets of contraband in his underwear-Judicial Magistrate
released accused personal belongings on his application-Underwear was returned to
sessions court and marked as an exhibit during trial-Sessions court convicted but
though Hon’ble High Court acquitted him based on the practical test conducted before
it and further directed to inquire into the matter-Based on a report the Hon’ble
High Court directed the sheristadar to lodge FIR before police-Charge sheet was 
filed against court clerk and advocate for conspiring together with intention to
cause the disappearance of evidence-Quash preferred against taking cognizance due
to the bar under section 195(1)(b) Cr.P.C-Quash allowed with further directions 
to take appropriate measures under section 195(1)(b) of the Cr.P.C-Appeal against
the order of the Hon’ble High Court-Reasoning of the court below-Issues for consideration-
Discussion and analysis-Rulings regarding locus standi of permitting third parties
in appeal in criminal proceedings-Locus standi explained-Since the case quashed 
by the High Court involves serious allegations the locus standi of the appellant
does not come in way-Section 195 Cr.P.C-Principles to prosecute under section 195
Cr.P.C-Cognizance was quashed based on section 195 Cr.P.C-The criminal proceedings
arise based on Hon’ble High Court direction and not from private individual-High
Court can exercise jurisdiction under section 195(1) Cr.P.C-Quashing the criminal
proceedings was unwarranted-Case is restored.

### 󠀁[How to mark confession explained: If inadmissible portions of confession are allowed in deposition, there is a significant risk that the trial courts may be influenced by it](http://localhost:8080/section1/how-to-mark-confession-explained-if-inadmissible-portions-of-confession-are-allowed-in-deposition-there-is-a-significant-risk-that-the-trial-courts-may-be-influenced-by-it/)󠁿

Appeal against the conviction rendered by Sessions court was confirmed by the Hon’ble
High Court-Allegation was accused persons abducted the deceased and there after 
the torso with other body parts of deceases was recovered from a canal-Consideration-
Evidence of eyewitness (PW-26) describing the incident as if how the deceased was
abducted by seven to eight boys-Importance of dock identification and ascribing 
the accused roles about the incident-Since P.W.-26 material part of testimony is
full of omissions her testimony is kept out of consideration-Since another eye-witness
was not examined an adverse inference will have to be drawn against the prosecution-
Circumstantial evidence-PW-1 informed in cross that he has no personal knowledge
about the contents of CD-Expert witness admitted that CD contains images is prone
to editing and further prosecution did not produce certificate under section 65B
Indian Evidence Act-The courts did not see the CCTV footage but relied upon it-CCTV
footage is one of the circumstance and was not proved-The body parts recovery was
not done at the instance of the accused-Reliance on inadmissible evidence-Hon’ble
Supreme Court extracted the confession portion extracted in the deposition (testimony)-
I.O attempted to prove the confession made to him which has a complete prohibition
on proving such confession-If inadmissible portions in confession allowed in the
deposition there is every possibility that the trial courts may get influenced by
it-The gravity of the offence-The courts can convict the accused based on legally
admissible evidence and there cannot be a moral conviction-Conclusion and operative
part: Appellant acquitted.
