# Murder: What is ‘cruel’ under exception 4 of section 300 IPC?

- Link: https://section1.in/what-is-cruel-under-exception-4-of-section-300-ipc/
- Published: 2023-07-29T15:23:03+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [FACTUAL ASPECTS](https://section1.in/what-is-cruel-under-exception-4-of-section-300-ipc/#factual-aspects)
 * [OUR VIEW](https://section1.in/what-is-cruel-under-exception-4-of-section-300-ipc/#our-view)

##### FACTUAL ASPECTS

1. The appellant who was at the relevant time Lance Naik in the Indian Army was 
convicted by the Court Martial for the offence punishable under Section 302 of the
IPC (for short, ‘IPC’) read with Section 69 of the Army Act, 1950 (for short, ‘the
Army Act’). The Court Martial sentenced the appellant to suffer imprisonment for
life. The Court Martial also dismissed the appellant from service. Thereafter, the
appellant filed preconfirmation and additional preconfirmation petitions which were
rejected by the Major General Officer Commanding by his order dated 28th September
2005. Thereafter, the appellant filed a petition to the Chief of the Army Staff 
who rejected the same by his order dated 12th June 2006. Thereafter, the appellant
filed a Petition under Article 226 read with Article 227 of the Constitution of 
India and Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short ‘CrPC’)
before the Hon’ble High Court of Punjab and Haryana. The High Court transferred 
the matter to the Armed Forces Tribunal, Chandigarh. By the impugned judgment, the
Armed Forces Tribunal, Chandigarh dismissed the Petition and confirmed the conviction
and sentence of the appellant. Against the impugned order of the Tribunal, the Appellant
again filed a Writ Petition before the Hon’ble High Court of Punjab and Haryana 
and by order dated 10.10.2018, the High Court while dismissing the Writ Petition
granted liberty to the appellant to avail remedy under Section 30 of the Armed Forces
Tribunal Act, 2007.

##### OUR VIEW

11. **The appellant did not have a weapon at that time and he used the weapon of
the deceased. Out of 20 rounds in the magazine of the rifle, he fired only one bullet.**
Moreover, after the incident, the appellant did not run away and he along with PW
13 lifted the deceased and laid him by the side of the road. He frankly disclosed
his version of the incident to PWs 13 and 14. **The appellant along with two other
army men, lifted the deceased for putting him in the ambulance and he accompanied
the deceased to the hospital. These facts brought on record show that there was 
no premeditation on the part of the appellant.** Both the appellant and the deceased
had consumed liquor. There was a fight between him and the deceased over the issue
of seniority. In fact, when the appellant told the deceased to bring water for him,
the deceased refused to do so on the ground that he was senior to the appellant.
In a disciplined force like Army, the seniority has all the importance. Therefore,
there is every possibility that the dispute over seniority resulted in the appellant
doing the act in a heat of passion. It appears that in the heat of passion, the 
appellant snatched a rifle held by the deceased and fired only one bullet. If there
was any premeditation on the part of the appellant or if he had any intention to
kill the deceased, he would have fired more bullets at the deceased. Hence, there
was no intention on his part to kill the deceased. Whether the appellant had done
a cruel act or not, has to be appreciated after considering three facts. Firstly,
the appellant was a soldier on guard duty, secondly, the appellant and the deceased
had a fight over the seniority and thirdly, though there were 20 rounds in the rifle
of the deceased, he fired only one round. **There was a sudden fight over seniority
when the appellant and the deceased had consumed liquor. There was no premeditation.
The appellant, in the facts of the case, cannot be said to have acted in such a 
cruel manner which will deprive him of the benefit of exception 4 to Section 300
of IPC. The term cruel manner is a relative term. Exception 4 applies when a man
kills another. By ordinary standards, this itself is a cruel act. The appellant 
fired only one bullet which proved to be fatal. He did not fire more bullets though
available. He did not run away and he helped others to take the deceased to a hospital.
If we assign a meaning to the word ‘cruel’ used in exception 4 which is used in 
common parlance, in no case exception 4 can be applied. Therefore, in our view, 
exception 4 to Section 300 was applicable in this case. Therefore, the appellant
is guilty of culpable homicide not amounting to murder.** The appellant snatched
the rifle from the hands of the deceased and fired one bullet at the deceased. This
act was done with the intention of causing such bodily injury to the deceased as
was likely to cause death. Therefore, the first part of Section 304 of IPC will 
apply in this case. Under the first part of Section 304 of IPC, an accused can be
punished with imprisonment for life or with imprisonment for a term which may extend
to 10 years.

xxx

13. Therefore, the appeal is partly allowed. The conviction of the appellant for
the offence punishable under Section 302 of IPC is altered to the one under Part
1 of Section 304 of IPC. The appellant is sentenced to undergo imprisonment for 
the term which he has already undergone. The appellant was enlarged on bail by this
Court on 8th April 2020. The bail bonds of the appellant shall stand cancelled.

PARTY: No.15138812Y L/Nk Gursewak Singh vs. Union of India & Anr – Criminal Appeal
No.1791 of 2023 – July 27, 2023.

**[https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2019/41324/41324_2019_11_1501_45419_Judgement_27-Jul-2023.pdf](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2019/41324/41324_2019_11_1501_45419_Judgement_27-Jul-2023.pdf)**

**[Gursewak singh vs. Union of India – section 304 – I cruel](https://demonew.section1.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/Gursewak-singh-vs.-Union-of-India-section-304-I-cruel.pdf)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
