# Section 193 Cr.P.C – Why a sessions court cannot take cognizance of an offence even though such an offence exclusively triable by that court? Explain the exceptions to same with illustrations?

- Link: https://section1.in/why-a-sessions-court-cannot-take-cognizance-of-an-offence-even-though-such-an-offence-exclusively-triable-by-that-court-explain-the-exceptions-to-same-with-illustrations/
- Published: 2023-09-12T12:11:38+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Cognizance: Sessions judge directly taking cognizance: impact](https://section1.in/why-a-sessions-court-cannot-take-cognizance-of-an-offence-even-though-such-an-offence-exclusively-triable-by-that-court-explain-the-exceptions-to-same-with-illustrations/#cognizance-sessions-judge-directly-taking-cognizance-impact)
 * [Cognizance: Sessions court: part cognizance](https://section1.in/why-a-sessions-court-cannot-take-cognizance-of-an-offence-even-though-such-an-offence-exclusively-triable-by-that-court-explain-the-exceptions-to-same-with-illustrations/#cognizance-sessions-court-part-cognizance)
 * [Cognizance: Wrong cognizance by special court & retrial](https://section1.in/why-a-sessions-court-cannot-take-cognizance-of-an-offence-even-though-such-an-offence-exclusively-triable-by-that-court-explain-the-exceptions-to-same-with-illustrations/#cognizance-wrong-cognizance-by-special-court-amp-retrial)

**QUESTION NO.2**

##### Cognizance: Sessions judge directly taking cognizance: impact

This procedure alone has to be followed in this case, unless the Act is amended,
empowering or conferring power upon the court of Sessions to take cognizance of 
the offence directly, as indicated by me comparing the provisions available in other
Acts viz., the P.C Act, E.C Act, TNPID Act. If the above procedures are not followed
and if the Sessions Court has taken cognizance then the Madras High Court further
held that on this ground alone quashing of proceedings may not be possible, and,
if at all a direction could be given to the court concerned, to send the complaint
to the Judicial Magistrate concerned, having jurisdiction to commit the case, if
offences are made out [Dr.S.Sourubarani and Dr.S.Akila vs. C.Selvi – 2005-1-LW (
Cri) 139 (Mad)].

##### Cognizance: Sessions court: part cognizance

It is well settled that cognizance of an offence can only be taken once. In the 
event, the Magistrate takes cognizance of the offence and then commits the case 
to the court of session, the question of taking fresh cognizance of the offence 
and, thereafter, proceed to issue summons, is not in accordance with law. If cognizance
is to be taken of the offence, it could be taken either by the Magistrate or by 
the Court of Session. The language of section 193 of the Code very clearly indicates
that once the case is committed to the Court of Session by the learned Magistrate,
the Court of Session assumes original jurisdiction and all that goes with the assumption
of such jurisdiction. The provisions of section 209 Cr.P.C will, therefore, have
to be understood as the learned Magistrate playing a passive role in committing 
the case to the court of Session finding from the police report that the case was
triable by the Court of Session. Nor can there be any question of part cognizance
being taken by the Magistrate and part cognizance being taken by the learned Court
of Session [Dharam Pal & Others vs. State of Haryana – AIR 2013 SC 3018=2013(9) 
SCALE 207=2013 Cr.L.J 3900 (SC)=2013(2) LW (Cri) 417 (SC)=2013 MLJ (Cri) 444 (SC)].

##### Cognizance: Wrong cognizance by special court & retrial

On a plain reading of the section 193 Cr.P.C, it is clear as noon day that no Court
of Session can take cognizance of any offence as a court of original jurisdiction
except as otherwise expressly provided by the Code or any other law for the time
being in force. The question whether the Special Court is Court of sessions; and
whether there is any special provision in the Act (especially under the Act like
SC & ST Act enabling the said court to take cognizance. Supreme Court reiterated
the passage from Gangula Ashok and another v. State of A.P [following A.R.Antulay
v. Ramdas Sriniwas Nayak and another and Directorate of Enforcement v. Deepak Mahajan
and another ] in Vidyadharan v. state of Kerala and Moly and another , held that
the Special Judge under the Act cannot entertain a complaint filed before it and
issue process after taking cognizance without the case being committed to it for
trial by the competent Magistrate. After careful perusal of the aforesaid decisions,
we have no scintilla of doubt that the view expressed which has a base of commonality
is absolutely to dwell upon the same more so when there is no cavil or conflict 
in this regard can there has been no reference on the said score. Additionally, 
no doubt has been expressed relating to the exposition of the said view, and irrefragably
correctly so. Now Supreme Court in State of M.P v. Bhooraji and others after referring
sections 462 and 465 of the Code of Criminal procedures and adverted to the concept
of ‘a failure of justice’ and held that, but if a specified Sessions court, on the
basis of the legal position then felt to be correct on account of a decision adopted
by the High Court, had chosen to take cognizance without a committal order, what
is the disadvantage of the accused in following said course. Supreme Court in the
above said case further held that we repeatedly asked the learned counsel for the
accused to tell us what advantage the accused would secure if the case is sent back
to the Magistrate’s court merely for the purpose of retransmission of the records
to the Sessions Court through a committal order. We did not get any satisfactory
answer to the above query put to the counsel. After so stating, the court proceeded
to deal with the stance whether the special judge as a court of session would remain
incompetent to try the case until the case is committed and, after critical ratiocination,
declined to accept the said stand and opined that the expression “a court of competent
jurisdiction” as envisaged in section 465 of the Code of Criminal Procedure is to
denote a validly constituted court conferred with the jurisdiction to try the offence
or offences and such a court could not get denuded of its competence to try the 
case on account of any procedural lapse and the competence would remain unaffected
by the non-compliance with the procedural requirement. After adverting to the concept
of failure of justice, it is obligatory to dwell upon the aspect whether there is
or can be any failure of justice if a special judge directly takes cognizance of
an offence under the Act. Supreme court in Rattiram v. State of M.P [3 judges bench]
after discussed the above concluded that tested on the aforesaid premised reasons,
it is well nigh impossible to conceive of any failure of justice or causation of
prejudice or miscarriage of justice on such non-compliance. It would be totally 
in-apposite and inappropriate to hold that such non-compliance vitiates the trial.
Supreme Court in the above said case further observed about the victim of the offence
that under these circumstances, the right of the collective as well as the right
of the victim springs to the forefront and then it becomes obligatory on the part
of the accused to satisfy the court that there has been ‘failure of justice’ or ‘
prejudice’ has been caused to him. Unless the same is established, setting aside
of conviction as a natural corollary or direction for retrial as the third step 
of the syllogism solely on the said foundation would be an anathema to justice. 
Be it noted, one cannot afford to treat the victim as an alien or a total stranger
to the criminal trial. The criminal jurisprudence, with the passage of time, has
laid emphasis on victimology which fundamentally is a perception of a trial from
the view point of the criminal as well as the victim. Both are viewed in the social
context. The view of the victim is given due regarded and respect in certain countries.
In respect of certain offences in our existing criminal jurisprudence, the testimony
of the victim is given paramount importance. Sometimes it is perceived that it is
the duty of the court to see that the victim’s right is protected. A direction for
retrial is to put the clock back and it would be a travesty of justice to so direct
if the trial really has not been unfair and there has been no miscarriage of justice
or failure of justice. With the above observation Supreme Court in Rattiram v. state
of M.P [(2012) 2 MLJ (Cri) 627 (SC)] finally promulgated that the decisions rendered
in Moly and another and vidyadharan v. state of kerala have not noted the decision
in state of M.P v. Bhooraji and others, a binding precedent, and hence they are 
per incurium.

_**Answer:**_ It cannot be said that the Sessions court cannot take cognizance directly.
If the Sessions court has Original jurisdiction to the offence such as TNPID, P.
C Act, POCSO, S.C/S.T Act e.t.c… of course it can directly take cognizance (if the
law permits) without committal from the Magistrate. But, for other Acts since there
is no second cognizance concept or taking two cognizance for an offence, though 
there is a specific provision u/s 193 Cr.P.C, the Sessions court cannot take cognizance
again for the offence for which cognizance was already taken by the committal Magistrate(
ref: above judgments).

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
