7. In cases where a reversal of acquittal is sought, the courts must keep in mind that the presumption of innocence in favour of the accused, on grounds of it surviving the rigours of a full trial, is strengthened and stands fortified. The prosecution then, while still working under the same burden of proof, is required to discharge a more onerous responsibility to annul and reverse the fortified presumption of innocence. This fortification of the presumption of innocence has been held in a catena of judgments by this court.
8. In the case of Allarakha K. Mansuri vs. State of Gujarat [2002(1) RCR(Criminal) 748], this Court has held that in cases of reversal of acquittal, where two views are possible, the view which favors the accused has to be adopted. For the sake of Convenience, the relevant paragraph of the judgment is being produced hereunder:
“The settled position of law regarding the powers to be exercised by the High Court in an appeal against the order of acquittal is that though the High Court has full powers to review the evidence upon which an order of acquittal is based, it will not interfere with an order of acquittal because with the passing of an order of acquittal the presumption of innocence in favour of the accused is reinforced. The High Court should be slow in disturbing the finding of the fact arrived at by the trial court. The golden thread which runs through the web of administration of justice in criminal case is that if two views are possible on the evidence adduced in the case, one pointing to the guilt of the accused and the other to his innocence, the view which is favourable to the accused should be adopted.”
9. Further, in the case of Suman Chandra Vs. Central Bureau Of Investigation [Criminal Appeal No.1645 of 2021] wherein the acquittal of the accused was challenged, this court held that while exercising its powers to reverse an acquittal, the order of the trial court must not only be erroneous, but also perverse and unreasonable. The relevant paragraph of the judgment is being extracted herein:
“It is well settled law that reversal of acquittal is permissible only if the view of the Trial Court is not only erroneous but also unreasonable and perverse. In our considered opinion, the view taken by the Trial Court was a possible view, which was neither perverse nor unreasonable, and in the facts and circumstances of the present case, ought not to have been reversed or interfered with by the High Court.”
10. Similarly in the case of Mrinal Das & Others Vs. The State of Tripura3, this Court held that interference in a judgment of acquittal can only be made if the judgment is “clearly unreasonable” and there are “compelling and substantial reasons” for reversing the acquittal. The relevant paragraph of the judgment is being reproduced herein:
“An order of acquittal is to be interfered with only when there are “compelling and substantial reasons”, for doing so. If the order is “clearly unreasonable”, it is a compelling reason for interference. When the trial court has ignored the evidence or misread the material evidence or has ignored material documents like dying declaration/report of ballistic experts etc., the appellate court is competent to reverse the decision of the trial Court depending on the materials placed”.
CONCLUSION:
11. As can be seen from the above-mentioned judgments, an additional layer of protection is granted to an accused in cases where the accused already enjoys an acquittal. In the present case, we are in agreement with the decision of the High Court. From a perusal of the judgment of the Trial Court, it can be seen that no perversity has been committed by the Trial Court while reaching its conclusion. All the evidence on record has been carefully perused and a detailed analysis has been carried out to come to the conclusion.
12. In such circumstance, we find no reason to interfere with the decision of the Trial Court as well as the High Court. As a consequence, the appeal stands dismissed.
PARTY: ROOPWANTI vs. STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS – CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1904 OF 2014 – 24TH FEBRUARY, 2023.
URL: Download
Files : Download
