Obtaining copies of the case records is the statutory right of the parties, either directly or through their advocates, in their case. These records are needed to defend their case or to file their appeal, revision etc. So, to get these records, a Party or his advocate files an Application Known as Copy Application.
I am speaking here is about ONLY about rule 209 of Criminal Rules of Practice, 2019 which sets the Procedure for requesting these copies form the concerned court in which the parties case is pending or disposed.
The application shall be presented by the applicant or his advocate in the ‘open court’ with the name of the applicant, his Position in the case or proceeding as the case may be, the name of the advocate and the description of the Proceeding or document of which a copy is required.
Once the copy application is submitted in the ‘open court’ with the above requirements, it can either be allowed by the court or dismissed. Where is the question of returning the same contemplated under the Rules of Practice?
Why the C.A must be given in open court? No doubt, under rule no.209 the words ‘open court’ are not engrafted equivalently, the words ‘copying section’ also omitted. The words ‘copy section’ speaks for itself as if its duty is only to copy and not adjudicating applications.
Right, here, Rule 209 of the Criminal Rules of Practice, 2019 is equivalent to Rule 339 of the erstwhile 1958 Rules which is anchored in a foundational principle of procedure: a Copy Application embodies a formal prayer for certified judicial records, a relief that lies exclusively within the province of the Presiding Officer to grant or refuse.
Neither a ministerial clerk nor the Copying Section possesses any independent authority to adjudicate upon such a prayer; their mandate is purely to execute the command of the Court.
The machinery contemplated under Rule 219 governing the calling of stamp papers at designated hours and the delivery of certified papers from court bundle is set in motion only after the judicial mind has been exercised/applied by the court and the prayer is allowed, thereby shielding the Bench from routine clerical labour work.
Yet, the threshold act of entertaining and deciding a Copy Application remains a distinctly judicial function. It demands judicial scrutiny to ascertain whether the applicant stands as a party entitled to copies as of right under Rule 209, a stranger obliged to demonstrate sufficient cause by affidavit under Rule 210, or whether the sought record falls within the statutory bar prior to the final report under Rule 231. Should an application prove untenable in law, the jurisdiction to reject or dismiss it vests solely with in the parameters of the Court or prerogative of the court.
Consequently, even where routine Copy Applications are physically tendered at a centralised Copying Section or to a ministerial officer for administrative convenience and preliminary scrutiny under Rule 211, they are received strictly as an agent of the Court and must invariably be submit the same before the Presiding Officer for judicial orders. Unfortunately, emergent prayers under Rule 212 requires a special attention but treated as same as other Copy Applications.
Why Call for memo? Thereafter, the court (strictly only the BC or MC) asks the applicants to file the extra documents called “call for memo”. A memo is nothing but an “information in writing sent by one person to another in the same business organisation (see: Oxford/Cambridge Dictionary)”.
The copy application (note this is an application/petition and not a memo) is itself an official request made by the applicant in which a C.A number will be allocated. The court does not need an extra memo or notification just to get the copies that are already lying in its office. The only administrative/clerikal duty is to check whether the particulars told in the provision i.e., rule. 209 in the Tamilnadu Criminal Rules of Practice, 2019 is correctly filled or not.
Usually, the court provides adjournment under Section 346 of BNSS, but it must be understood that Section 346 of BNSS provides the Power to postpone or adjourn the Proceedings only pertaining to inquiries or trials and not for any administrative work like issuing certified copies.
Timely access to court records is essential for speedy justice; simple administrative requests should never be turned into complex Procedural hurdles.
Reference: A.Leo Charles … Petitioner Vs M.Vijayakumar … Respondent – CRL.OP.No.14184 of 2015 – In The High Court Of Judicature At Madras Dated 11.06.2015 Coram The Honourable Mr.Justice P.N.Prakash;
-The End-
Written by: Ms Sathiya Jyothi Sabapathy – School of Excellence in law, Chennai – Finished Law, passed the AIBE exam, yet to receive the enrolment number.


