Acquittal: Last Seen Alive: Prosecution must prove not only the mere ownership but that the deceased was actually wearing the said ornaments when she was last seen alive (Informer not examined)

A criminal appeal arose from concurrent judgments convicting an individual for murder and sentencing them to life imprisonment based on circumstantial evidence. The appellate court evaluated the foundational links, including alleged motive, last-seen theories, and recovery of personal ornaments. Finding significant gaps, unexplained delays, and unreliable testimony regarding the recovery, the court determined the chain of circumstances was incomplete. Consequently, the conviction was set aside and the accused was acquitted of the murder charge.

Bheemanagouda @ Bheemajja – Criminal Appeal No. 5402 of 2026 (Arising out of SLP(Crl.) No. 13798 of 2025) – 2026 INSC 1239 – 18.11.2026 – Prashant Kumar Mishra and Vipul M. Pancholi, JJ.

https://www.sci.gov.in/view-pdf/?diary_no=327062025&type=j&order_date=2026-11-18&from=latest_judgements_order

Appellant and impugned order challenged

The appellant challenged the final judgment and order passed by the High Court which dismissed his criminal appeal and confirmed the trial court’s judgment convicting him under Section 302 of the IPC and sentencing him to life imprisonment [paras 1, 2, 6].

Factual matrix

The prosecution alleged that the appellant had an illicit relationship with the deceased, murdered her by strangulation using a plastic strap at a limestone kiln, stuffed her body into an iron drum, and robbed her ornaments, which were later allegedly recovered from his house [paras 3.1 to 3.6].

Other courts verdicts

The trial court convicted the appellant under Section 302 IPC while acquitting him under Section 201 IPC, whereas the high court dismissed the appeal and confirmed the conviction [paras 2, 5.4, 6].

The appellant contended that the case rested entirely on circumstantial evidence, that the alleged motive was unproved, that last-seen witnesses were unreliable due to an inordinate delay of nearly two months in recording statements, and that the recovery of ornaments under Section 27 of the Evidence Act was flawed, could not form the sole basis for a murder conviction, and did not connect him to the homicide. Per contra, the State supported the concurrent findings by arguing that homicidal death, motive, last-seen proximity, and the prompt recovery of stolen ornaments from the appellant’s possession completed the unbroken chain of circumstantial evidence pointing to his guilt [paras 7.1 to 7.6, 8.1 to 8.5].

Ratio Decidendi

In a case based solely on circumstantial evidence, the prosecution must establish a complete and unbroken chain of circumstances pointing guilt exclusively to the accused beyond reasonable doubt, and where motive is speculative, last-seen evidence suffers from unexplained and inordinate delays, and the recovery of stolen property lacks independent corroboration or a direct nexus to the homicide, conviction cannot be sustained [paras 9, 10.2, 11.2, 13.1, 13.2, 13.5, 15].

Directions issued

None

Important paragraphs
Motive

Motive is important when the case rests on circumstantial evidence: 10. The first circumstance relied upon by the prosecution is the motive of the appellant behind the incident in question. Motive, though not a sine qua non in cases resting on direct evidence, assumes vital importance where the entire case rests on circumstantial evidence and it is an important link in the chain of circumstances, as reiterated in the case of Indrajit Das v. State of Tripura [(2023) 18 SCC 506]. The case of the prosecution is that the motive of the appellant behind the incident in question was that the appellant and the deceased were in an illicit relationship and the appellant harboured suspicion regarding her character, suspecting her intimacy with another person.

Only PWs deposed that they were aware of illicit relationship of the deceased? Explained: 10.1. In this regard, the Trial Court held that based on the evidence of the witnesses examined before the court, the prosecution proved its case against the appellant beyond all reasonable doubt, establishing that the appellant committed the murder of the deceased due to her illicit relationship with another person, as submitted by the Public Prosecutor. The High Court affirmed the said finding, observing that PW-5 (nephew), PW-8 (son) and PW-11 (cousin), relatives of the deceased, deposed that they were aware of the illicit relationship between the appellant and the deceased. Consequently, the prosecution established that the deceased and the appellant shared an illicit relationship at the relevant time.

Witnesses had no direct knowledge of the illicit relationship of the deceased but only general knowledge: 10.2. On perusal, it is clear that both the Trial Court and the High Court committed an error by treating the general knowledge of an illicit relationship as proof of the motive to commit murder. On a careful scrutiny of the depositions of the family members of the deceased, namely PW-5 (nephew), PW-7 (husband), PW-8 (son) and PW-11 (cousin), it emerges that the deceased was living separately from her husband and there were allegations of an illicit relationship with the appellant. However, PW-5 admitted during cross-examination that he did not personally witness any illicit relationship between the deceased and the appellant and further admitted that he had informed the police that he merely suspected the appellant in connection with the deceased’s death. Similarly, PW-7 admitted that he had no personal knowledge of the affair. Significantly, none of the prosecution witnesses testified that the appellant harboured suspicion that the deceased was involved with another man or that any quarrel had ever taken place between them on that account. Thus, we are of the opinion that the motive alleged by the prosecution is a matter of conjecture and surmise, which cannot be accepted as an established circumstance against the appellant.

Last seen together theory

How to appreciate last seen together theory explained: 11. The second circumstance pressed by the prosecution is the “last seen together” theory, founded on the testimonies of Nagappa (PW-13) and Palakshappa (PW-14). This Court in Kanhaiya Lal v. State of Rajasthan (supra), held that the circumstance of last seen together does not by itself lead to an inference of guilt unless there is proximate and independent corroborative material establishing a link between the accused and the crime.

11.1. A perusal of the record discloses that the incident occurred on the night of 04.09.2013 and the dead body was discovered on the morning of 05.09.2013. The appellant was arrested on 12.09.2013. Significantly, the statements of PW-13 and PW-14 under Section 161 Cr.P.C. were recorded by the investigating officer on 01.11.2013, which is after nearly 2 months.

If the delay in recording the statements not explained last seen evidence is not conclusive: 11.2. The Trial Court rightly took note of this unexplained delay and expressly rejected their testimonies, holding that “the evidence is not believable to rely on the last seen theory”. However, the High Court relied upon their testimonies without addressing the 58-day delay or providing any reasoning for reversing the said finding of the Trial Court. Thus, we are of the view that where the delay in recording the statements remains completely unexplained, the “last seen” evidence is not conclusively established and was rightly rejected by the Trial Court.

Medical evidence and the narrative of the prosecution regarding homicidal nature of death is inconsistent: 12. The prosecution further sought to establish the dumping of the dead body inside an iron drum near the limestone kiln by the appellant. It is observed that while the homicidal nature of the death caused by ligature strangulation is established by medical evidence, the narrative of the prosecution regarding the concealment of the body has inconsistencies.

Informer not examined

Informer’s phone call regarding the body: 12.1. The complainant (PW-1) stated in his complaint that on the day before the incident as there was no business, the remaining lime was placed into a drum belonging to one Huligemma and was covered with plastic to shield it from the rain. The following morning, around 9:00 AM on 05.09.2013, the complainant received a phone call alerting him that a woman’s body was inside their lime drum and upon hearing the news, he immediately arrived at the lime burning site where he discovered the body of a woman with her limbs folded inside the drum, after which he alerted all the workers present at the site.

Informer not examined: 12.2. At this stage, it is relevant to observe that the investigating agency neither traced nor examined this informant. Furthermore, neither the inquest report nor the post-mortem report prepared by Dr. Raju G.M. (PW-16) reveals any trace or stain of limestone on the clothing or the person of the deceased. Thus, we are of the opinion that this circumstance as well creates doubt as to the veracity of the prosecution version regarding the discovery of the body.

State did not file any appeal against the acquittal of accused under section 201 IPC: 12.3. In addition, the Trial Court acquitted the appellant of the charge under Section 201 IPC, observing that none of the prosecution witnesses examined before the court, including the investigating officer, stated that the appellant had placed the dead body of the deceased in a barrel with the intention of causing the disappearance of evidence. Significantly, the State did not file an appeal to the acquittal of the appellant under Section 201 IPC and consequently, the acquittal under Section 201 IPC has attained finality.

Recovery

Recovery is doubtful: 13. This brings us to the circumstance heavily relied upon by the courts below, namely, the recovery of ornaments under Section 27 Evidence Act. The High Court held that the identification of the ornaments by PW-8 (son), PW-10 (niece) and PW-11 (cousin), all relatives of the deceased, gives credibility to the prosecution case that the ornaments belonged to the deceased, were missing from her person and were recovered at the instance of the appellant from his house, thereby connecting the appellant to the crime. The High Court further observed that, apart from a bare denial, the appellant offered no explanation for being in possession of the said ornaments. However, in the present case, we are of the view that the recovery itself is doubtful in the following circumstances:

13.1. On perusal of the record, the seizure mahazar (Ex. P-7) was signed by 3 panch witnesses, one Ashok, Mehaboob Basha (PW-12) and PW-23 (the goldsmith/appraiser). Ashok was not examined by the prosecution and PW-23 in his deposition failed to mention the attendance of Ashok during the proceedings. Both PW-12 and PW-23 did not testify to the disclosure statement made by the appellant in police custody that led to the discovery during the recovery procedure. Thus, in the absence of cogent evidence from any independent witness supporting the statement of disclosure made by the appellant, the essential prerequisites under Section 27 Evidence Act remain unsatisfied in the facts of the present case. Additionally, PW-12 admitted in his cross-examination that the contents of the seizure mahazar were dictated entirely by PW-24 (CPI), that he did not personally know what was written therein and that he did not know the door number or ownership of the house from which the trunk was retrieved. While PW-12 claimed that all 3 persons signed both spot mahazar and seizure mahazar (Ex. P-6 and Ex. P-7), PW-23 admitted in his cross-examination that his signature on Ex. P-6 (spot mahazar) was struck out without explanation and that the police had obtained his signature on only one document that day. At this stage, it is relevant to note that if his signature was already affixed on the spot mahazar (Ex. P-6), the prosecution has failed to explain how his signature also appears on seizure mahazar (Ex. P-7). Furthermore, PW-23 admitted that he is a regular police witness who has examined gold and silver articles and given statements in multiple cases for the Harapanahalli Police Station over many years, that he did not even carry a weighing machine with him at the time of the seizure and that the seized articles were ordinary ornaments commonly available in the market.

Ownership of the ornaments

Prosecution must prove not only the mere ownership but that the deceased was actually wearing the said ornaments when she was last seen alive: 13.2. Additionally, to establish a link through recovery, the prosecution was required to prove not merely ownership, but that the deceased was actually wearing the said ornaments when she was last seen alive. However, on perusal of the record, it is evident that no statement under Section 161 Cr.P.C. of the relatives of the deceased was recorded identifying the seized jewels as those worn by the deceased when she was last seen alive. PW-13 and PW-14, the “last seen” witnesses, did not mention any jewellery worn by the deceased. Further, although PW-8 (the son) identified the deceased’s jewellery, he had left the deceased a day earlier and could not testify to what she wore at the time of leaving. While PW-10 (niece) and PW-11 (cousin) deposed to having observed certain ornaments on the deceased upon her departure, neither witness deposed to witnessing her leave with the appellant. It is also to be noted that according to the I.O. (PW-24), the statements of PW-10 and PW-11 were not recorded until after the arrest of the appellant and PW-10 herself admitted in cross-examination that the police never examined her. Therefore, the prosecution completely failed to establish that the deceased was actually wearing the recovered ornaments when she was last seen alive with the appellant. In addition, learned counsel for the appellant rightly submitted that the foundational premise of the prosecution’s case is that there existed an ongoing and intimate relationship between the deceased and the appellant and thus it is natural and plausible that some of her belongings, including ornaments, might have been kept or left at his house in the ordinary course of their association.

13.3. Furthermore, the timeline of the recovery is contradicted by the deposition of PW-13. The case of the prosecution is that the ornaments were recovered 8 days after the incident upon arrest of the appellant. However, PW-13 admitted in cross-examination that on the following day of the incident, the police visited the village for investigation, asking him to accompany them and informed him that the deceased’s earrings and gold effects had already been found at the residence of the appellant.

13.4. It is also pertinent to note that the sole motive advanced by the prosecution and accepted by the courts below was that the appellant committed murder of the deceased on account of an illicit relationship between them coupled with suspicion regarding her character. Thus, where the motive of the offence is rooted in personal animosity arising out of such a relationship, the prosecution did not establish any motive or intent for the appellant to commit theft of her jewellery. Significantly, no charge was framed against the appellant under Section 379, 392 or 404 IPC for theft or robbery, as the prosecution tried him exclusively for offences punishable under Sections 302 and 201 IPC.

Unexplained possession of stolen articles merely enables a presumption only: 13.5. It is well settled by a three-judge bench of this Court in Sanwat Khan v. State of Rajasthan (supra) and reaffirmed in Raj Kumar @ Raju v. State (NCT of Delhi) (supra), that the unexplained possession of stolen articles belonging to the deceased merely enables a presumption under Illustration (a) to Section 114 Evidence Act regarding theft or receipt of stolen property. Therefore, in the present case, in the absence of cogent evidence showing that the robbery/theft and murder formed part of the same transaction, we are of the view that such recovery, by itself, cannot be stretched to infer guilt of the appellant for murder under Section 302 IPC.

May be and must be distinction explained: 14. At this stage, it is pertinent to reiterate the observation made in the decision of this Court in Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade v. State of Maharashtra, that “Certainly, it is a primary principle that the accused must be and not merely may be guilty before a court can convict and the mental distance between ‘may be’ and ‘must be’ is long and divides vague conjectures from sure conclusions.”

Conclusion

15. On a holistic consideration of the evidence on record, the chain of circumstantial evidence cannot be said to be complete and unbroken. The prosecution has failed to establish the circumstances pointing conclusively to the guilt of the appellant beyond reasonable doubt. The findings of guilt recorded by the Trial Court and confirmed by the High Court are based on conjectures and surmises. Therefore, the appellant is entitled to the benefit of doubt and the conviction under Section 302 IPC cannot be sustained in law.

Acquittal: 16. For the aforesaid reasons, the appeal is allowed. Accordingly, the conviction of the appellant under Section 302 IPC as well as the sentence of imprisonment for life and fine imposed by the Trial Court in Sessions Case No. 101 of 2014 and affirmed by the High Court of Karnataka in the final judgment and order dated 09.07.2024 in Criminal Appeal No. 1355 of 2017, are hereby quashed and set aside, however, the acquittal of the appellant under Section 201 IPC by the Trial Court is maintained. Consequently, the appellant is acquitted for the offence punishable under Section 302 IPC.

17. Since the appellant is presently in custody undergoing the sentence of life imprisonment, he shall be released forthwith, unless his presence is required for any other case.

Resources

  • Judgments Cited
    • Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra – Establishing the five golden principles governing cases based on circumstantial evidence [(1984) 4 SCC 116] [paras 7.1, 8.5, 9]
    • Sanwat Khan v. State of Rajasthan – Holding that unexplained possession of stolen articles of the deceased only raises a presumption of theft and cannot alone infer murder unless robbery and murder form a single transaction [(1952) 2 SCC 641] [paras 7.5, 13.5]
    • Raj Kumar @ Raju v. State (NCT of Delhi) – Reaffirming that recovery of stolen property does not automatically stretch to infer guilt for murder without proof that both offenses formed a single continuous transaction [(2017) 11 SCC 160] [paras 7.5, 13.5]
    • State of U.P. v. Satish – Discussing the principle of last-seen together as a facet of circumstantial evidence requiring proximity and corroboration [(2005) 3 SCC 114] [paras 8.3]
    • Kanhaiya Lal v. State of Rajasthan – Holding that last-seen together does not lead to an inference of guilt unless proximate and independent corroborative material links the accused to the crime [(2014) 4 SCC 715] [paras 8.3, 11]
    • Shri Bhagwan v. State of Rajasthan – Addressing inferences arising from the recovery of stolen property shortly after a crime [2001 SCC (Cri) 1095] [paras 8.4]
    • State (NCT of Delhi) v. Navjot Sandhu – Discussing evidentiary inferences in continuous transactions [2005 SCC (Cri) 1715] [paras 8.4]
    • Abdul Nassar v. State of Kerala – Reaffirming principles governing circumstantial evidence [2025 SCC OnLine SC 111] [paras 8.5]
    • Indrajit Das v. State of Tripura – Highlighting the vital importance of motive in cases resting on circumstantial evidence [(2023) 18 SCC 506] [paras 10]
    • Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade v. State of Maharashtra – Emphasizing that the mental distance between “may be” and “must be” guilty divides vague conjectures from sure conclusions [(1973) 2 SCC 793] [paras 14]
  • Acts and Sections Involved